Forfeited Earnest Money in New Mexico: Capital or Ordinary After AbbVie and CRI-Leslie

A street-art figure on a sidewalk in downtown Roswell, New Mexico, seat of Chaves County

Benito runs cattle on 2,400 acres outside Roswell. In early 2026 he contracted to sell the land and cattle operation for $6.2 million, and the buyer put $310,000 of earnest money with a Chaves County title company. The buyer’s financing fell apart, and on July 1 the deposit was released to Benito. A year later he agreed to buy the stock of a Ruidoso outfitting company, backed out after due diligence, and lost his own $75,000 deposit.

Benito is invented. His question is real, and despite the 2025 AbbVie headlines, the answer turns on what was being sold and who owned it.

Is forfeited earnest money taxed as capital gain or ordinary income in New Mexico?

Start with 26 U.S.C. § 1234A. “Gain or loss attributable to the cancellation, lapse, expiration, or other termination of” a “right or obligation … with respect to property which is (or on acquisition would be) a capital asset in the hands of the taxpayer” is “treated as gain or loss from the sale of a capital asset.”

The issue is whether the property was a capital asset. Section 1221(a) carves out inventory and, in § 1221(a)(2), depreciable business property and “real property used in his trade or business.” Vacant land held as an investment is a capital asset, so a deposit a buyer forfeits on it is capital gain.

New Mexico does not change the label. Its tax starts from “base income,” which for individuals is “adjusted gross income” plus listed additions (NMSA 1978, § 7-2-2(B)), so the federal character carries over.

Why is a forfeited deposit on a working ranch ordinary income after CRI-Leslie?

Business real estate is not a capital asset. In CRI-Leslie, LLC v. Commissioner, 882 F.3d 1026 (11th Cir. 2018), a Tampa hotel owner kept a $9.7 million nonrefundable deposit after its buyer defaulted in 2008. The Eleventh Circuit held it was ordinary income. The hotel was real property used in the owner’s business, so § 1234A “simply doesn’t apply.” Treating closed and failed sales differently may look odd, but “oddity is not absurdity.” The Tax Court ruled the same way below, 147 T.C. 217 (2016).

Benito’s land and improvements are “real property used in the trade or business” under 26 U.S.C. § 1231(b)(1). Breeding cattle held 24 months or more fall under § 1231(b)(3), and calves raised for sale are excluded as property held for sale. None of it is a capital asset. A closed sale would have produced § 1231 gain taxed as long-term capital gain; a failed sale is no sale. The $310,000 is ordinary income, except perhaps a slice tied to acreage held purely as an investment.

What did AbbVie v. Commissioner decide, and does it bind New Mexico taxpayers?

In AbbVie Inc. & Subsidiaries v. Commissioner, 164 T.C. 340 (2025), AbbVie deducted a $1.6 billion fee paid to abandon a combination with Shire, and the IRS called it a capital loss. The court held that a right “with respect to property” is one “to exchange (i.e., to buy, sell, or otherwise transfer or receive) an interest in property,” and that AbbVie’s agreement was “fundamentally a services agreement.” Neither company owned its own shares, and “neither AbbVie nor New AbbVie had any right or obligation to acquire the Shire shares” without shareholder and court approval. The court drew on Pilgrim’s Pride Corp. v. Commissioner, 779 F.3d 311 (5th Cir. 2015), which read § 1234A as reaching “contractual rights to buy or sell capital assets.” It did not decide whether § 162 or § 165 supplied the deduction.

The IRS did appeal. The Tax Court docket in No. 2597-23 shows the Commissioner’s notice of appeal on September 11, 2025 (Seventh Circuit No. 25-2622), then a February 9, 2026 Seventh Circuit mandate dismissing it under Federal Rule of Appellate Procedure 42(b). As of October 30, 2026, I found no acquiescence decision and no IRS notice or proposed regulation on break fees.

A New Mexico individual’s Tax Court appeal goes to the Tenth Circuit under 26 U.S.C. § 7482(b)(1)(A). I found no Tenth Circuit decision on § 1234A. Under Golsen v. Commissioner, 54 T.C. 742, 757 (1970), the Tax Court follows a circuit decision “squarely in point” only where appeal lies to that circuit. The Fifth and Eleventh Circuits would not bind it, but its own CRI-Leslie and AbbVie opinions point the same way. Trial would be in Albuquerque (see Tax Court trials from New Mexico).

Does AbbVie help a New Mexico buyer who loses a deposit on a ranch or business?

Rarely. The court agreed § 1234A “encompasses certain contingent rights and obligations” and distinguished a case where “parties with complete authority to buy and sell property agreed to do so subject to certain conditions.” That describes nearly every New Mexico ranch or closely held company sale: the owner who signs owns what is sold, and a financing or water rights contingency does not make it a services contract.

A buyer asks what the property would have been in his hands. Shares are capital assets, so a lost deposit on a stock deal is a capital loss, usable by an individual only against capital gains plus $3,000 a year under 26 U.S.C. § 1211(b), with the rest carried forward under § 1212(b). Equipment and buildings a buyer would use in his business would not be capital assets. In Chief Counsel Advice 202224010 (2022, not precedent), the IRS split a termination payment by relative asset values and treated only the capital-asset share as capital. An individual’s loss must also be business or profit-seeking under 26 U.S.C. § 165(c), which rules out a deposit on your future home.

Does it matter whether the deal was an option or a purchase contract?

Yes. A lapsed option is treated as sold on its expiration date, with the character the property would have had in the holder’s hands (26 U.S.C. § 1234(a)), and Treas. Reg. § 1.1234-1 treats the loss as a § 1231 loss when the property would have been § 1231 property. The same regulation calls a grantor’s gain on a lapsed option (other than on stock, securities or commodities) generally ordinary. That rule predates the 1997 expansion of § 1234A, so a landowner who sold an option should not count on capital gain.

Timing turns on the paperwork too. In Commissioner v. Indianapolis Power & Light Co., 493 U.S. 203 (1990), deposits were not income because the holder lacked “complete dominion” and its right to keep them was “contingent upon events outside its control.” Once the refund right is gone and the money is released, the seller holds it under a claim of right “without restriction as to its disposition,” taxable under North American Oil Consolidated v. Burnet, 286 U.S. 417 (1932). In my experience the contract’s termination clause fixes that date.

What does Benito owe on the ranch deposit and the Ruidoso loss?

Illustration only. Benito and his wife file jointly with $400,000 of 2026 taxable income before the deposit. Under Rev. Proc. 2025-32, the 2026 joint 32 percent bracket runs from $403,550 to $512,450 and the 35 percent bracket to $768,700. Taxed as ordinary income, the $310,000 adds $104,842.50 of federal tax.

A passive investor keeping $310,000 on raw land would pay 15 percent up to $613,700 of 2026 joint taxable income and 20 percent above, or $51,315, plus $11,780 of net investment income tax under 26 U.S.C. § 1411, for $63,095. Ranching the land costs Benito about $41,750 more. Section 1411 should not reach his ordinary income from an active business.

New Mexico’s joint rate for 2025 and later is 5.9 percent above $315,000 (NMSA 1978, § 7-2-7(A)), so the deposit costs $18,290 if Benito is already over that line. The 2024 rewrite of NMSA 1978, § 7-2-34 allows the greater of $2,500 of net capital gain or 40 percent of up to $1 million of net capital gain from selling a business. Ordinary income gets neither. A sale that never closed fits the business prong poorly, so capital treatment would have saved about $147.50.

The Ruidoso deposit went toward shares the sellers owned, so § 1234A makes the $75,000 a capital loss. With no 2027 capital gains, Benito deducts $3,000 and carries $72,000 forward. If he sells investment property in 2027 at a $75,000 gain, the loss wipes it out.

Deal type Seller keeps deposit Buyer forfeits deposit Governing authority
Raw land held for investment Capital gain Capital loss ($3,000 limit for individuals) § 1234A; § 1211(b)
Working ranch or business real estate Ordinary income Ordinary loss if the buyer would use it in a business CRI-Leslie; § 1221(a)(2)
Operating business sold as an asset sale Split by asset Split by asset, mostly ordinary CCA 202224010; § 1234A
Stock sale signed by the owners Capital gain Capital loss § 1234A

Frequently Asked Questions

Is earnest money taxable when the buyer first deposits it?

Generally not while it sits in escrow and the buyer can still get it back. It becomes income when the refund right ends and the money is released.

Can I deduct earnest money I lost on a house I planned to live in?

No. Section 165(c) allows individuals only business, for-profit, and casualty or theft losses, and a home deposit is none of those.

Did the IRS appeal the AbbVie decision?

Yes, to the Seventh Circuit in September 2025. The appeal was dismissed under Rule 42(b), with the mandate issued February 9, 2026, so the Tax Court decision stands.

Does New Mexico tax a forfeited deposit differently than the IRS?

Not in character, because New Mexico starts from federal adjusted gross income. A capital gain deposit may qualify for the $2,500 deduction in NMSA § 7-2-34.

Is a forfeited deposit on investment land treated differently from one on ranch land?

Yes. Investment land is a capital asset, so the deposit is capital gain. Ranch land used in the business is not, so under CRI-Leslie the deposit is ordinary income.

How North Star Law Firm Can Help

North Star Law Firm advises New Mexico sellers and buyers on business sale tax structuring and real estate tax strategy, and represents taxpayers whose failed-deal reporting ends up in Tax Court litigation.

Phillip Zagotti, JD/CPA, represents taxpayers before the IRS and the U.S. Tax Court and is admitted to the U.S. District Court and Bankruptcy Court for the District of New Mexico. The firm works alongside New Mexico-licensed counsel on state-law questions. If a buyer walked away from your ranch or business, or you lost a deposit yourself, contact North Star Law Firm.