Isidro runs a heating and plumbing contractor in Raton through a single member LLC that files no tax return of its own. The business owes a regional bank $540,000 on a line and a term loan he personally guaranteed, plus about $130,000 to two merchant cash advance funders. The bank will take $330,000 in full by December 31, 2026, funded by a family loan. His bookkeeper calls it a $210,000 savings. Nobody has mentioned Form 1099-C.
Isidro is fictional; the conversation is not. A workout fixes the balance sheet, not the business, and it can produce a tax bill on money never received. Whether it does depends on where the forgiveness happens: across a table or inside a bankruptcy case.
Is cancellation of debt income taxable when a New Mexico business settles a loan for less?
As a starting point, yes. Gross income includes “income from discharge of indebtedness” under 26 U.S.C. § 61(a)(11). In United States v. Kirby Lumber Co., 284 U.S. 1 (1931), a company that bought back its own bonds below par was taxed on the difference.
Under Treas. Reg. § 1.6050P-1, a lender that discharges $600 or more files Form 1099-C when an “identifiable event” occurs, and one listed event is an agreement to discharge the debt for less than full consideration. The old rule treating 36 months without payment as an identifiable event was removed by T.D. 9793 in November 2016.
The form is evidence, not a verdict. The Tax Court said in Kleber v. Commissioner, T.C. Memo. 2011-233, that a 1099-C is not dispositive of an intent to cancel.
If I negotiate the payoff down, is that a “dispute” that avoids the tax?
Not in the Tenth Circuit. Preslar v. Commissioner, 167 F.3d 1323 (10th Cir. 1999) is a New Mexico case. The Preslars bought a 2,500 acre ranch near Cloudcroft for $1 million with a note to Moncor Bank, repayable by assigning cabin lot sales contracts. After the bank failed, the FDIC refused the assignments, and in 1988 they settled the $799,463 balance for $350,000. The Tax Court found no income because the liability was contested.
The Tenth Circuit reversed. The contested liability doctrine applies only when the original amount of the debt is unliquidated and in dispute; a fight over how it would be repaid did not qualify. The court also rejected the purchase price reduction rule of § 108(e)(5), which covers only “direct agreements between a purchaser and seller.” A bank lender is not the seller.
So hard bargaining is not a dispute. Unless Isidro can contest the $540,000 itself, the $210,000 is income, and the question is whether an exclusion applies.
Talk to Us Before You Sign a Workout
When does the insolvency exclusion on Form 982 cover a debt workout?
26 U.S.C. § 108(a)(1) excludes debt discharged in a title 11 (bankruptcy) case and debt discharged while the taxpayer is insolvent, along with narrower exclusions for farm and qualified real property business debt. Under § 108(a)(2), the bankruptcy exclusion comes first.
Insolvency has a ceiling. Section 108(d)(3) measures it as liabilities minus the fair market value of assets immediately before the discharge, and § 108(a)(3) excludes no more than that. Assets include property creditors cannot reach: Carlson v. Commissioner, 116 T.C. 87 (2001), counted exempt assets, and the worksheet in IRS Publication 4681 (the edition for 2025 returns) lists retirement accounts and pension interests. A guaranty of someone else’s debt counts only if you prove you will more likely than not have to pay it, under Merkel v. Commissioner, 192 F.3d 844 (9th Cir. 1999). I found no Tenth Circuit decision on that point; Merkel affirmed the Tax Court, whose test would apply in a New Mexico case.
For a cash method business, § 108(e)(2) removes forgiven amounts whose payment would have been deductible, such as unpaid interest. Insolvency is claimed on Form 982, line 1b; a bankruptcy discharge on line 1a.
Whose insolvency counts: the LLC, the S corporation or the owner?
Treas. Reg. § 1.108-9(a) makes the owner of a disregarded LLC the taxpayer: the owner must be insolvent, and the bankruptcy exclusion applies only if the owner is the title 11 debtor. A partnership or multimember LLC applies the exclusions partner by partner (§ 108(d)(6)); an S corporation applies them at the corporate level (§ 108(d)(7)(A)). After Gitlitz v. Commissioner, 531 U.S. 206 (2001) reversed the Tenth Circuit and let excluded income raise shareholder basis, Congress closed that door in Pub. L. 107-147, § 402 (2002). A C corporation is its own taxpayer. Our post on LLC, S corporation and C corporation treatment in tax and bankruptcy goes further.
How does Subchapter V cancellation of debt income compare with an out of court workout?
Illustratively, assume Isidro is unmarried. Immediately before the payoff: Assets are $1,020,000 (house, retirement account, trucks and equipment, receivables, cash). Liabilities are $1,130,000 (mortgage, the bank debt, the advances, trade debt, credit cards). The LLC is disregarded, so its debts are his. He is insolvent by $110,000. The family loan changes nothing; it adds equal cash and debt.
Out of court, $110,000 is excluded and $100,000 is taxable, reported on Schedule C, line 6 as Publication 4681 directs. Assume his other 2026 taxable income is $110,000. Under the 2026 brackets in Rev. Proc. 2025-32, most of the added income falls in the 24 percent bracket and the last $8,225 above $201,775 at 32 percent: about $24,660. New Mexico starts from federal adjusted gross income (NMSA 1978, § 7-2-2), and the single schedule in NMSA 1978, § 7-2-7 (as amended by Laws 2024, ch. 67) for 2025 and later taxes income between $66,500 and $210,000 at 4.9 percent, about $4,900 more. Roughly $29,560 comes due with the 2026 returns (the federal one on April 15, 2027, 26 U.S.C. § 6072(a)), not counting any self-employment tax. The real savings is nearer $180,000.
If Isidro himself is the Subchapter V debtor and his confirmed plan discharges the same $210,000 of the LLC’s bank debt, § 108(a)(1)(A) and (d)(2) exclude all of it, in the year the discharge takes effect (after the plan payments, under 11 U.S.C. § 1192, if a class did not accept). If only the LLC files, § 1.108-9 sends him back to the insolvency test, and $100,000 is still taxable.
Exclusion has a price. Under § 108(b), excluded income reduces tax attributes after the year’s tax is figured: net operating losses first, then credits, capital losses and property basis under § 1017, unless he elects under § 108(b)(5) to cut depreciable basis first. An individual Chapter 11 case also creates a separate taxable estate under 26 U.S.C. § 1398, and § 108(d)(8) makes the estate the taxpayer for the attribute reduction.
Bankruptcy has its own costs: filing, counsel and trustee fees, a public record that bonding companies and licensing boards can see, and, for a plan confirmed without every impaired class’s consent, three to five years of projected disposable income under 11 U.S.C. § 1191(c)(2). For some owners a $29,560 tax bill is cheaper. If the business is still losing money, the workout only buys time; see our post on which bankruptcy chapter fits a New Mexico business owner.
Is a loan modification taxable if no principal is forgiven?
Usually not. Under Treas. Reg. § 1.1001-3, a significant modification is an exchange of the old loan for a new one. A yield change is significant if it exceeds the greater of 25 basis points or 5 percent of the old annual yield. A deferral is not material if the deferred payments are due within a safe harbor period of the lesser of five years or 50 percent of the original term. If there is an exchange, § 108(e)(10) treats the old loan as paid with the new loan’s issue price; for a bank loan that is not publicly traded and carries adequate stated interest, 26 U.S.C. § 1274(a) generally sets that price at stated principal. An extension or rate change at the same principal usually produces no income; a principal cut does.
| Setting for the same forgiven debt | Is the forgiven amount taxed? | What is given up | Form to file |
|---|---|---|---|
| Out of court, owner solvent | Yes, all of it | Nothing, but the full tax is due | Schedule C, line 6 (sole proprietor) |
| Out of court, owner insolvent | Only the excess over his insolvency | Attributes, to the extent excluded | Form 982, line 1b |
| Subchapter V, owner is the debtor | No | Attributes (at the estate level), case costs, plan payments | Form 982, line 1a |
| Subchapter V, only the LLC files | Yes, unless the owner is insolvent | Case costs, without the bankruptcy exclusion | Form 982, line 1b if insolvent |
Frequently Asked Questions
I never received a Form 1099-C. Do I still report the forgiven debt?
Yes. Publication 4681 says canceled debt is income even without a 1099-C unless an exclusion applies.
If the bank releases my personal guaranty, is that income to me?
Generally not when you guaranteed someone else’s debt. In Landreth v. Commissioner, 50 T.C. 803 (1968), a guarantor released by the bank had no income because his net worth did not grow. Your own disregarded LLC’s debt is different: it is already yours.
Does an SBA EIDL compromise produce a Form 1099-C?
It can. The SBA’s offer in compromise requirements for disaster loans say a 1099-C may be filed for the unpaid amount.
Is settling a merchant cash advance canceled debt?
Only if the advance is a loan. Many are written as receivables purchases; see our post on merchant cash advances in New Mexico.
Does New Mexico tax canceled debt income?
It follows the federal result. New Mexico starts from federal adjusted gross income, so an amount excluded on Form 982 stays off the state return, and an included amount is taxed at graduated rates that top out at 5.9 percent.
When is the tax due on a December 31, 2026 payoff?
The discharge falls in 2026, so it belongs on the 2026 return due April 15, 2027. Paying a few days later moves it to 2027.
How North Star Law Firm Can Help
North Star Law Firm reviews proposed debt workouts for New Mexico business owners before they sign, measuring insolvency, sorting out entity issues, and comparing the result with a Subchapter V case. Its tax law practice prepares the Form 982 position.
Phillip Zagotti, JD/CPA, represents taxpayers before the IRS and the U.S. Tax Court and is admitted to the U.S. District Court and Bankruptcy Court for the District of New Mexico. The firm works alongside New Mexico-licensed counsel on state-law questions. If a lender has offered to take less than you owe and the deadline is close, contact North Star Law Firm.
