Miriam’s Truth or Consequences company turns hot springs minerals into bath salts and skin care products. The S corporation has four employees and will sell about $1.9 million online this year: roughly $240,000 shipped to New Jersey, $310,000 to California and $410,000 to Texas. An employee in T or C staffs a live chat window. The site also has a static FAQ page, cart cookies, retargeting cookies and a wholesale account application. Miriam files a New Mexico return and nothing else.
Miriam is fictional, but I hear her question often: can a chat window run from Sierra County put her company on the hook for another state’s income tax?
What does P.L. 86-272 protect for a New Mexico online seller?
Public Law 86-272, codified at 15 U.S.C. § 381(a), denies every state the power to levy “a net income tax” against interstate income when the seller’s only business activity there is “the solicitation of orders” for sales of tangible personal property, with orders “sent outside the State for approval or rejection” and filled “by shipment or delivery from a point outside the State.” Section 383 defines a net income tax as “any tax imposed on, or measured by, net income.” Under § 381(b), the shield never works against a corporation’s state of incorporation or an individual’s home state.
Congress wrote the law in 1959 for salesmen who only took orders. In Wisconsin Department of Revenue v. William Wrigley, Jr., Co., 505 U.S. 214 (1992), the Supreme Court read “solicitation of orders” to include activities “entirely ancillary to requests for purchases,” but not repair or service work, and allowed a de minimis exception for activity that does not create “a nontrivial additional connection with the taxing State.”
The key word is “tangible.” A business selling services, subscriptions or downloads has no 86-272 protection. Miriam sells jars of salt, so she starts inside the statute.
Which states can make my New Mexico business file an income tax return?
A state first needs a nexus rule that reaches you. Since South Dakota v. Wayfair, Inc., 585 U.S. 162 (2018), ended the physical presence rule for sales tax, many states use sales thresholds for income tax too.
New Jersey’s N.J.A.C. 18:7-1.6(c) finds substantial nexus when a corporation has more than $100,000 of New Jersey receipts, or 200 or more separate transactions delivered there, for privilege periods ending on or after July 31, 2023. Miriam’s $240,000 clears that.
California’s Rev. & Tax. Code § 23101(b)(2) uses the lesser of an indexed $500,000 or 25 percent of total sales. The Franchise Tax Board lists $757,070 for 2025 and had posted no 2026 figure as of November 6, 2026. A quarter of Miriam’s sales is $475,000, so her $310,000 falls short. Section 23101(a) also defines doing business broadly, so the bright line is not California’s only hook.
Texas has no income tax. Its franchise tax rule, 34 Tex. Admin. Code § 3.586(f), reaches a remote entity with $500,000 or more of Texas gross receipts, and subsection (i) says 86-272 “does not apply to the Texas franchise tax.”
Over a state’s threshold, 86-272 is often the only thing between a seller and a return.
Can live chat on my website cost me 86-272 protection in other states?
The Multistate Tax Commission says yes. Section IV.C of the Statement on P.L. 86-272, revised August 4, 2021, treats a website interaction with a customer as business activity “within the customer’s state.” Static FAQs and cookies that only remember a cart stay protected. Regular product help after delivery “via either electronic chat or email” defeats immunity, as do branded credit card applications, nonsales job applications, and cookies whose data feeds inventory or product decisions.
New Jersey’s N.J.A.C. 18:7-1.9A, effective June 16, 2025, lists “post-sales assistance through an electronic chat, email, or application” as unprotected and FAQ pages as protected. Its cookie rule is narrower: cookies lose protection only when the seller packages the data for sale to outside buyers or uses it to sell services to businesses.
On October 1, 2026, the Tax Court of New Jersey ruled for the Director in American Catalog Mailers Association v. Director, Division of Taxation, Docket No. 010021-2025. I could not open the opinion; published summaries say real time support such as chat counts as New Jersey activity, FAQ pages stay protected, and cookies await a factual record. A chat happens at both ends at once, and one end is the customer’s screen in New Jersey, so it does not matter that Miriam’s employee types from T or C.
New York’s 20 NYCRR § 1-2.10 survived preemption review in American Catalog Mailers Ass’n v. Department of Taxation & Finance, Index No. 903320-24 (Sup. Ct. Albany County Apr. 25, 2025), though not for periods before December 2023; reports say the Appellate Division affirmed in May 2026. California’s Technical Advice Memorandum 2022-01 was reportedly struck in December 2023 as an underground regulation; I found no replacement.
The Tenth Circuit has no role; these fights belong to other states’ courts. In Congress, H.R. 427 and S. 3027 would protect activity that “facilitates” solicitation, but govinfo shows no action after committee referral, and the language the House put in H.R. 1 (section 70301) is not in Public Law 119-21.
Does P.L. 86-272 apply to New Mexico’s gross receipts tax?
No. The statute limits net income taxes only, and New Mexico’s gross receipts tax falls on receipts “from selling property in New Mexico” under NMSA 1978, § 7-9-3.5. A remote seller is “engaging in business” once prior year receipts sourced here reach $100,000 (NMSA 1978, § 7-9-3.3, effective July 1, 2019, per TRD’s FYI-200), and since July 1, 2021, NMSA 1978, § 7-1-14 sources goods to the delivery location. An out of state advisor who says 86-272 keeps a client out of New Mexico is answering the wrong tax. Our post on the Maryland digital ad ruling shows a similar gap.
New Mexico’s corporate income tax honors 86-272 for inbound sellers. TRD’s FYI-350 (Rev. Jan. 2, 2025) lists the immunity criteria, shows a flat 5.9 percent rate for taxable years beginning on or after January 1, 2025, and says the $50 franchise tax is due even from an immune corporation. It is silent on websites, and I found no TRD guidance adopting the MTC’s internet statement, although New Mexico belongs to the Multistate Tax Compact.
Miriam’s own gross receipts tax runs the other way. Goods shipped to customers in other states are deductible as interstate commerce under NMSA 1978, § 7-9-55. TRD’s 3.2.213.12 NMAC denies the deduction when a New Mexico resident asks for out of state delivery, or when a nonresident takes delivery, title or risk of loss here. My reading: sale terms passing title at the T or C loading dock invite an argument she does not need.
How do the numbers work for a Truth or Consequences seller?
Everything here is illustrative. If the chat costs her the New Jersey shield, and her company were a C corporation with $150,000 of federal taxable income apportioned by sales, New Jersey’s share would be 12.63 percent ($240,000 of $1.9 million), about $18,947. Because entire net income tops $100,000, New Jersey’s published rates apply 9 percent, roughly $1,705, against a $750 C corporation minimum at her receipts level. For an S corporation, the page shows no entity rate on income not subject to federal income tax and a $562.50 minimum. If another state taxes her share, NMSA 1978, § 7-2-13 gives her a New Mexico credit, capped at the New Mexico tax on that income.
Miriam is under the California and Texas bright lines, so the chat changes nothing there. If Texas sales pass $500,000, 86-272 will not help.
Limiting the chat to questions before a purchase sits closer to solicitation, in my reading. An outside call center does not help in the MTC view, since Article V says unprotected work by an independent contractor “also removes the statutory protection.”
At home, assume $1.5 million ships out of state. Those receipts come off her return under § 7-9-55, and the $400,000 delivered inside New Mexico is taxed at each delivery location’s combined rate, which TRD lists from 5.125 to 8.6875 percent. Our audit guide explains how TRD tests those deductions.
| Website activity | MTC statement (Aug. 4, 2021) | New Jersey after Oct. 1, 2026 | What Miriam can change |
|---|---|---|---|
| Static FAQ page | Protected | Protected | Expand it |
| Live chat after the sale | Unprotected | Unprotected; reportedly upheld | Limit chat to presale questions |
| Cart cookies | Protected | Protected if data is not sold | Keep them limited to the cart |
| Retargeting cookies | Not named; unprotected if data feeds inventory decisions | Protected unless data is sold; no ruling | Review the ad vendor’s data terms |
| Wholesale account application | Not named; nearest are credit card and job applications | Not addressed | Keep approvals in T or C |
| Downloadable care guide PDF | Static content is not business activity | Not named; like an FAQ | Keep it static |
Frequently Asked Questions
Does P.L. 86-272 protect a New Mexico corporation from New Mexico income tax?
No. Section 381(b) excludes a corporation in its state of incorporation, so the statute matters only elsewhere.
Does 86-272 cover a business that sells digital products or services?
No. It protects solicitation of orders for tangible personal property only. Sellers of services or downloads rely on nexus thresholds and apportionment instead.
Is a chatbot treated like live chat?
Nobody knows yet. The MTC statement does not name chatbots, and published summaries say the New Jersey court declined to rule on them without a factual record.
Can a seller protected by 86-272 still owe New Jersey anything?
Yes. Under N.J.A.C. 18:7-1.9, a protected foreign corporation with nexus still files and pays the minimum tax. Protection removes the tax measured by income, not the filing.
Does New Mexico follow the MTC’s internet rules?
I found nothing from TRD adopting them. FYI-350 lists the traditional immunity criteria and is silent on websites, chat and cookies.
How North Star Law Firm Can Help
North Star Law Firm helps New Mexico sellers with multistate tax exposure, including how the gross receipts tax treats out of state shipments, whether an S corporation or other structure fits a national seller, and catching up on unfiled returns where a filing duty already exists.
Phillip Zagotti, JD/CPA, represents taxpayers before the IRS and the U.S. Tax Court and is admitted to the U.S. District Court and Bankruptcy Court for the District of New Mexico. The firm works alongside New Mexico-licensed counsel on state-law questions. If your website talks to customers in other states and you have never filed outside New Mexico, contact North Star Law Firm.
