Bankruptcy Mediation in New Mexico: LBR 9019-3, Rule 9019 and the Subchapter V Plan

A bronze galloping-horse sculpture outside the Hubbard Museum of the American West in Ruidoso, New Mexico

Dale runs a cabin-rental and property-management company in Ruidoso, and on September 2, 2026 the company filed a Subchapter V case in the bankruptcy court in Albuquerque. His former 40 percent partner says the company owes him $900,000 for his buyout, and the bank has objected to the cash-collateral budget. At the status conference, the Subchapter V trustee suggested mediation. Dale suspects a stall, and he wants to know who pays and whether anything he admits can be used against him.

Mega-cases made mediation routine years ago. For a New Mexico small business, the answers are local.

Does the New Mexico bankruptcy court have a mediation rule?

Yes, and it is new. Proposed in August 2025 without drawing a single comment, it was adopted by an order entered November 25, 2025, effective December 1, 2025. The 2023 local rules had none.

NM LBR 9019-3 lets the court appoint “another available active or recall status United States Bankruptcy Judge from any judicial district” as mediator (a retired judge recalled to service), or a non-judge mediator with quasi-judicial immunity. Participants automatically waive claims against the mediator. A judge who would be disqualified under 28 U.S.C. § 455 or § 144 cannot serve unless the parties consent in writing after disclosure.

That “any judicial district” language matters. The court’s website has listed one sitting judge, Chief Judge Robert Jacobvitz, since Judge David Thuma died in May 2025. Nobody wants the judge who will rule on the plan hearing their bottom line in caucus, so a judge-mediator now comes from outside New Mexico. In In re Trinity Legacy Consortium, LLC, No. 22-10973-j11 (Bankr. D.N.M. Sept. 25, 2023), Judge Jacobvitz held off converting a Farmington homebuilder’s case and, with consent, appointed Judge Thuma to mediate; four of six major creditors settled. The court posts no mediator panel that I could find.

The rule is silent on fees, but because it treats a judge-mediator’s work as a judicial duty, I would not expect a bill. A private mediator is different: the court’s form order, NM LF 7016-2, caps what the estate pays without further approval, and the estate’s share is an administrative expense allowed after notice and a hearing (§ 503(b)).

What does it mean that the Subchapter V trustee must facilitate a consensual plan?

The trustee must “facilitate the development of a consensual plan of reorganization” (11 U.S.C. § 1183(b)(7)). The court must hold a status conference within 60 days after the order for relief, and at least 14 days before it the debtor files a report on its efforts “to attain a consensual plan of reorganization” (§ 1188(a), (c)). The plan is due within 90 days (§ 1189(b)).

That is informal mediation. But the trustee, who is heard on valuation and confirmation and may object to claims, is not a pure neutral. A case trustee also bills the estate under § 330(a), and NM LBR 2016-1(d) has the debtor pay 75 percent of each monthly statement. Formal mediation adds a neutral with no other role and a written order.

Why does a consensual Subchapter V plan matter?

A plan confirmed under § 1191(a) needs every impaired class to accept. Otherwise the debtor must show under § 1191(b) and (c) that the plan is “fair and equitable,” which includes committing projected disposable income for three to five years.

Under a consensual plan, confirmation discharges pre-confirmation debts (§ 1141(d)(1)(A)) and the trustee’s service ends at substantial consummation (§ 1183(c)(1)). Under a nonconsensual plan, discharge waits for three to five years of payments (§ 1192), and the trustee usually makes the plan payments (§ 1194(b)) and stays on for the plan’s life. Courts are also split on whether § 1192(2) exposes a corporate or LLC debtor to § 523(a) claims, covered in the firm’s post on keeping a § 523(a) claim alive in Subchapter V. One cost to plan for: a consensual plan must pay allowed administrative expenses in cash on the effective date unless the holder agrees otherwise (§ 1129(a)(9)(A)), while § 1191(e) lets a nonconsensual plan spread them out.

Is what I say in bankruptcy mediation confidential?

Less than people assume. Federal Rule of Evidence 408, which applies in bankruptcy under Rule 1101, bars settlement offers and negotiation statements only when used to prove or disprove a disputed claim’s validity or amount, or to impeach. A court may admit them to show bias or undue delay.

LBR 9019-3 bars compelling the mediator’s testimony or notes, but it does not bind the parties. The mediation order does that. NM LF 7016-2 says mediation statements “shall not be divulged” to the court or third parties and, “Notwithstanding anything in Federal Rule of Evidence 408 to the contrary,” bars introducing any aspect of the mediation in any proceeding.

The Alternative Dispute Resolution Act has district courts authorize ADR “in all civil actions, including adversary proceedings in bankruptcy” (28 U.S.C. § 651(b)) and adopt confidentiality rules (§ 652(d)), and the bankruptcy court is a unit of the district court (§ 151). The district court’s Local Civil Rule 16.2 still mentions a “bankruptcy facilitation panel” for adversary proceedings, but Rule 1.6(a) defers to the bankruptcy court’s rules, and I found no current panel. Read your order’s confidentiality paragraph closely.

Does a mediated settlement still need the bankruptcy judge’s approval?

Yes. Under Bankruptcy Rule 9019(a) the court approves a compromise on motion “after notice and a hearing,” and every creditor and the U.S. Trustee get notice. The debtor in possession files it, holding a trustee’s powers (§ 1184). Rule 2002(a)(3) requires 21 days’ notice, and NM LBR 9013-1(d) sets the objection deadline at 21 days from service. Any party in interest, including an unhappy bank, may object (§ 1109(b)).

The test comes from Kopp v. All American Life Insurance Co. (In re Kopexa Realty Venture Co.), 213 B.R. 1020 (10th Cir. BAP 1997): probable success on the merits, difficulty collecting a judgment, the complexity and expense of litigating, and creditors’ interests “in deference to their reasonable views.” Kopexa vacated an approval resting on business judgment alone. The decision must be “an informed one based upon an objective evaluation of developed facts” (Reiss v. Hagmann, 881 F.2d 890 (10th Cir. 1989), reversing approval of a deal the sole creditor opposed). D.N.M. applies the same factors and asks whether a deal falls “below the lowest point in the range of reasonableness” (In re Starkweather, No. 20-10717-t7 (Bankr. D.N.M. June 17, 2021)). Bring evidence, not just a term sheet.

How would mediation change Dale’s case?

Illustration only. The status conference must occur by November 1, 2026 (it is set for October 29, so Dale’s report is due October 15), and the plan by December 1, 2026. Between February and April 2026 the company paid the partner $130,000 on the buyout while he was still a member and arguably an insider, inside the one-year window of § 547(b)(4)(B). Until he repays an avoidable transfer, § 502(d) requires disallowance of his claim. That is leverage.

An out-of-district recall-status judge mediates on November 6. The partner takes an allowed $350,000 unsecured claim paid over five years, the estate releases the preference claim, and the bank agrees to plan terms. Dale serves the Rule 9019 motion November 10; if no objection arrives by December 1, he submits an order, and the plan he files that day builds in the deal. With every impaired class accepting and the rest of § 1129(a) met, it confirms under § 1191(a), bringing discharge at confirmation and no fight over projected disposable income.

Litigating means an adversary proceeding, then a judgment starting the 14-day appeal clock of Rule 8002(a)(1), explained in the firm’s post on the 14-day bankruptcy appeal trap. Mediation does not stop the 90-day clock either: Trinity Legacy extended it while talks were close but warned against more delay, and although mediation later settled the largest claim, no plan was confirmed and the case was dismissed in July 2025.

Path Who the neutral is Cost to the estate and timing Confidentiality basis
Trustee facilitation (§ 1183(b)(7)) Subchapter V trustee, who keeps other duties Trustee’s fees under § 330(a); from the status conference on Rule 408 only
Judge mediator (LBR 9019-3(a)) Active or recall-status bankruptcy judge from any district No mediator bill expected; depends on an outside judge’s calendar Mediation order plus LBR 9019-3(d)
Non-judge mediator (LBR 9019-3(f)) Attorney or professional the court appoints Estate share capped by order; scheduled by agreement Mediation order (NM LF 7016-2) plus LBR 9019-3(d)
Litigate the adversary proceeding None; the presiding judge decides Full litigation cost; months, then a 14-day appeal window Public record

Frequently Asked Questions

Can the New Mexico bankruptcy court order me to mediate?

LBR 9019-3 is written around parties who request judge-assigned mediation. The court’s form order says it does not normally require attendance but may under a modified order.

Is the Subchapter V trustee a mediator?

Informally. Section 1183(b)(7) tells the trustee to facilitate a consensual plan, but the trustee also takes positions on confirmation, and those talks fall outside any mediation order.

How long do creditors have to object to a Rule 9019 settlement in New Mexico?

Rule 2002(a)(3) requires at least 21 days’ notice, and NM LBR 9013-1(d) sets a 21-day objection deadline from service.

Who pays a bankruptcy mediator?

A judge-mediator serves as part of judicial duties. A private mediator is paid as the order provides, and the estate’s share needs court approval.

Does mediation extend the 90-day Subchapter V plan deadline?

No. The debtor must ask under § 1189(b) and show circumstances for which it should not justly be held accountable. D.N.M. treats that as an equitable test but expects a real plan, not a placeholder.

Is a mediated settlement binding before the court approves it?

Not on the estate. The agreement should be expressly subject to Rule 9019 approval, and the court weighs the Kopexa factors before it takes effect.

How North Star Law Firm Can Help

North Star Law Firm represents debtors, creditors and former owners in Subchapter V cases and other New Mexico bankruptcy matters, including mediated claim disputes and preference claims that stand between a business and a consensual plan.

Phillip Zagotti, JD/CPA, is admitted to the U.S. District Court and Bankruptcy Court for the District of New Mexico and represents taxpayers before the IRS and the U.S. Tax Court. The firm works alongside New Mexico-licensed counsel on state-law questions. If a trustee has suggested mediation in your case, contact North Star Law Firm.