Category: Tax Defense

  • Asked to Sign IRS Form 872 in New Mexico? Fine, Form 872-T and the State Clock

    Asked to Sign IRS Form 872 in New Mexico? Fine, Form 872-T and the State Clock

    A framing contractor in Rio Rancho has spent the fall answering a revenue agent’s questions about his 2023 Schedule C, mostly about cash paid to subcontractors. In November 2026 the agent mails him a filled-in form that would push the IRS deadline on that return to December 31, 2027, with a cover letter that makes it sound routine.

    It deserves more thought. On September 30, 2026, the Tax Court held in Fine v. Commissioner, 167 T.C. No. 13, that a taxpayer cannot cut a signed Form 872 short. And for someone who files in New Mexico, the form skips a second question: what the state’s clock does meanwhile.

    Can a Form 872-T end a Form 872 early?

    No. In Fine, a couple had signed Forms 872 for 2015 and 2016. After Appeals talks failed, their lawyer faxed Forms 872-T, ticking the form’s only box (which refers to Form 872-A). The notices of deficiency came inside the consent dates but long past 90 days from the faxes. Judge Ashford’s answer: “only the passage of time can terminate Form 872.”

    Form 872 names a date. Form 872-A names none; under its printed terms (IRM 25.6.22.7.1; Rev. Proc. 79-22) it ends 90 days after a Form 872-T reaches the IRS office handling the case, or 90 days after the agency mails one of its own, and a notice of deficiency also ends it. Form 872-T offers no box for a fixed-date consent, and Form 872 never mentions the termination form. An open-ended promise can be ended at will, but a dated one holds, consistent with Treas. Reg. § 301.6501(c)-1(d), which allows an extension “for any period of time agreed upon in writing.” For anyone already holding a Form 872-A, the 90 days start only when the right office receives a properly executed Form 872-T, never from a letter or call (IRM 25.6.22.7.1.4).

    Fine came on the IRS’s motion for partial summary judgment, granted by order on October 5, 2026. The merits were tried in March 2023, and as of October 16, 2026 the docket shows no ruling on the deficiencies. A New Mexico individual’s appeal goes to the Tenth Circuit under 26 U.S.C. § 7482(b)(1)(A), and I found no Tenth Circuit decision on the point, so under Golsen the Tax Court would apply Fine.

    Why is the IRS asking me to sign Form 872 in a New Mexico audit?

    Because time is running out. Under 26 U.S.C. § 6501(a), more income tax generally must be assessed within three years after the return was filed, and § 6501(b)(1) treats an early return as filed on its due date. Fraud removes the limit under § 6501(c)(1) (see the firm’s post on preparer fraud after the Murrin cert denial), but most audits are fought inside the three years.

    Section 6501(c)(4)(A) lets the IRS and the taxpayer extend the period by written agreement made before it expires. Under IRM 25.6.22.2.1, examiners ask when the statute will expire within 180 days with work unfinished, or when the case must go to Appeals, which needs at least 365 days left when it receives the file. Without that cushion there is no administrative appeal, as IRS Publication 1035 acknowledges.

    Section 6501(c)(4)(B) also requires the IRS, each time it asks, to tell the taxpayer of the “right to refuse to extend the period of limitations, or to limit such extension to particular issues or to a particular period of time.” The notice is printed on Form 872 and repeated in the cover letter (IRM 25.6.22.3).

    Asked to Sign a Form 872? Contact Us Now

    What is a restricted consent, and when should I ask for one?

    A restricted consent keeps the statute open only for named issues and lets it close on everything else (IRM 25.6.22.8). The standard clause limits any deficiency to adjustments in the described “area(s) of consideration,” plus related penalties and “consequential changes” (IRM 25.6.22.8.12). Fine itself noted that the taxpayers “could have set a shorter timeframe or limited the IRS’s examination to certain issues.”

    The IRS treats this as a right to ask. Under IRM 25.6.22.8.2, it generally agrees only when the open issues are few enough to describe precisely and everything else is agreed and ready to assess, and Area Counsel must approve the wording. Agreed items must be assessed on a partial agreement inside the original deadline (IRM 25.6.22.8.4). In my experience the request lands best late in an exam, when one question, such as whether workers were employees or subcontractors, is the only real dispute left.

    What happens if I refuse to extend the statute of limitations with the IRS?

    Refusing is lawful, and Publication 1035 says that “under no circumstances” will a penalty be charged for it. What usually follows is a notice of deficiency mailed before the statute runs, on whatever record the examiner has (IRM 25.6.22.3(8)). The notice starts the 90 days under 26 U.S.C. § 6213(a) to petition the Tax Court, a period that cannot be stretched (see the firm’s post on the Tax Court 90-day deadline in New Mexico).

    Settlement remains possible. Under Rev. Proc. 2016-22, § 3.01, IRS Counsel generally refers a docketed case to Appeals unless Appeals issued the notice. After a petition, 26 U.S.C. § 6503(a) suspends the assessment period until the Tax Court decision is final and for 60 days after. The cost is posture: Appeals then works against a trial calendar, from a notice the agent may have rushed.

    Does signing a federal Form 872 extend New Mexico’s assessment deadline?

    Not by its own terms. Under NMSA 1978, § 7-1-18(A), the Taxation and Revenue Department may not assess “after three years from the end of the calendar year in which payment of the tax was due.” Subsection F lifts the limit if “the taxpayer has signed a waiver of the limitations on assessment imposed by this section,” meaning New Mexico’s own limits. Nothing in the section makes a federal consent count, or adds a fixed period after one.

    Instead it tracks the federal result. Subsection E says that when an IRS audit changes the basis for federal tax and “results in liability for any tax,” the tax “may be assessed at any time, but not after three years from the end of the calendar year in which filing of a federal adjustments report is required.” Under NMSA 1978, § 7-1-13(E), that report and any tax are due “no later than one hundred eighty days after the final determination date,” which for an agreement both sides must sign is the day the last one signs (§ 7-1-13(N)(8)(a)). State income tax starts from federal adjusted gross income (NMSA 1978, § 7-2-2), so a Form 872 moves the state window indirectly, by postponing the federal outcome it runs from. How TRD applies subsection E to a given return is a state-law question I would take to New Mexico-licensed counsel.

    How would the choices play out for a Rio Rancho contractor?

    Illustration only. The contractor filed his 2023 return on March 20, 2024, so under § 6501(b)(1) the federal statute ends April 15, 2027. The agent’s December 31, 2027 date leaves exactly 365 days if the file reaches Appeals by December 31, 2026. Signed as presented, the date is locked in under Fine, though he may refuse the next request. A consent restricted to the subcontractor issue would require him to settle the rest (say, a vehicle expense adjustment) and have it assessed by April 15, 2027. He can propose September 30, 2027 instead, but IRM 25.6.22.3(9) says the IRS need not accept a shorter period. If he refuses and a notice is mailed February 24, 2027, his last day to petition is Tuesday, May 25, 2027.

    His 2023 New Mexico income tax was due in 2024, so § 7-1-18(A) runs to December 31, 2027. If he signs and the last signature on an Appeals settlement goes on August 12, 2027, his federal adjustments report is due by February 8, 2028, and subsection E lets TRD assess through December 31, 2031. Litigating would tie those dates to the Tax Court decision.

    Choice Federal effect Tax Court and Appeals New Mexico effect
    Sign Form 872 as presented Date binds; Form 872-T cannot shorten it Exam continues; Appeals needs 365 days § 7-1-18(E) runs from the later federal result
    Restricted consent Only named issues stay open IRS may refuse; Counsel approves wording Report duty covers every final adjustment
    Shorter date Binding only if the IRS signs Too little time can bypass Appeals State tail may start sooner
    Refuse Notice of deficiency likely; no penalty 90 days to petition; usually referred to Appeals Report due 180 days after final decision
    Already signed Form 872-A Form 872-T ends it 90 days after receipt Expect a notice within the 90 days Same report rule

    Frequently Asked Questions

    Can I revoke a Form 872 after I sign it?

    No. Fine holds that a Form 872 ends only on its stated date, and a Form 872-T does not change that. You can still decline a later request for more time.

    Is there a penalty for refusing to sign Form 872?

    No. Publication 1035 says no penalty will be charged. Expect a notice of deficiency instead, with 90 days to petition the Tax Court.

    How long does the IRS have after I send a Form 872-T?

    Ninety days after the IRS office considering your case receives it, and only if you are ending a Form 872-A. A letter or phone call does not start that period.

    Does the IRS have to accept a restricted consent?

    No. The IRS treats the statutory notice as a right to request one. It generally agrees only when the open issues can be described clearly and the rest is agreed.

    Does New Mexico require a report after a federal audit change?

    Yes. NMSA 1978, § 7-1-13(E) calls for a federal adjustments report and payment within 180 days after the federal final determination date. Section 7-1-18(E) then allows assessment until three years after the end of the calendar year in which that report was required.

    How North Star Law Firm Can Help

    North Star Law Firm represents New Mexico taxpayers in IRS audits and before the IRS Independent Office of Appeals. When a notice of deficiency issues, the firm handles Tax Court litigation.

    Phillip Zagotti, JD/CPA, represents taxpayers before the IRS and the U.S. Tax Court and is admitted to the U.S. District Court and Bankruptcy Court for the District of New Mexico. The firm works alongside New Mexico-licensed counsel on state-law questions. If an examiner wants your signature on a Form 872 by Friday, contact North Star Law Firm.


  • New Mexico Nonprofit Lost Its 501(c)(3)? Automatic Revocation vs. a Section 7428 Fight

    New Mexico Nonprofit Lost Its 501(c)(3)? Automatic Revocation vs. a Section 7428 Fight

    The new treasurer of a Las Cruces youth soccer club searched the IRS’s Tax Exempt Organization Search while assembling a grant application. What came back was a revocation date of November 15, 2025. In Santa Fe, another board member is holding a certified letter, labeled a final adverse determination, that ended a two-year IRS examination. Both groups have lost 501(c)(3) status. The way back differs for each, and so does the clock.

    Most writing about fighting a revocation assumes the Santa Fe situation. In New Mexico, the Las Cruces one is far more common.

    Was our New Mexico nonprofit’s 501(c)(3) revocation automatic, or did it come from an IRS exam?

    Automatic revocation happens under 26 U.S.C. § 6033(j) when an organization skips its Form 990, 990-EZ, or 990-N e-Postcard three years running. Nobody audits anything. The status is “considered revoked on and after the date set by the Secretary for the filing of the third annual return or notice,” and the IRS must publish the names. Its automatic revocation page says the list is updated monthly and a letter (the CP-120A) goes to the last known address.

    I pulled the IRS bulk revocation file dated September 30, 2026. It lists 8,474 New Mexico entries; 5,426 are coded 501(c)(3), and 4,678 of those show no reinstatement. The IRS posted 288 new New Mexico names in the twelve months ending September 29, 2026. Plenty of older entries are groups that quietly folded, so the raw count overstates the live problem.

    There is no appeal. The IRS says “the law prohibits the IRS from undoing a proper automatic revocation,” 26 U.S.C. § 7428(b)(4) bars a declaratory judgment suit over it, and Rev. Proc. 2026-5, § 12.02, denies these organizations any review by the Independent Office of Appeals. Only an exam revocation leads to court.

    How does retroactive reinstatement under Rev. Proc. 2014-11 work after an automatic revocation?

    Section 6033(j)(2) makes a revoked organization reapply, and § 6033(j)(3) lets the IRS reinstate back to the revocation date for reasonable cause. Rev. Proc. 2014-11 sets four routes. The dividing line is 15 months after the later of the CP-120A date or the date the name was posted.

    The streamlined route (section 4) fits an organization that could have filed the 990-EZ or 990-N for each missed year and has never been auto-revoked. It applies inside 15 months with the user fee, and reasonable cause is deemed; no old 990-N is required. The IRS reinstatement page allows Form 1023-EZ for it.

    Full Form 990 filers use section 5: apply within 15 months, mail paper returns for the missed years, and show reasonable cause for at least one year. Past 15 months, section 6 demands reasonable cause for all three. Section 7 reinstates only from the new application’s postmark. The 2026 user fee is $275 for Form 1023-EZ and $600 for Form 1023, consistent with Appendix A of Rev. Proc. 2026-5.

    Nonprofit Lost Its 501(c)(3) Status? Contact Us Now

    What would reinstatement look like for a Las Cruces youth sports club?

    Take an illustrative club on a June 30 fiscal year, taking in about $31,000 a year from registrations and a fall tournament, always a 990-N filer. The 990-N is due by the 15th day of the fifth month after year end, so November 15. The founder filed through June 30, 2022, then moved to Tucson.

    The missed due dates are November 15 of 2023, 2024, and 2025, so revocation took effect November 15, 2025. The IRS’s required warning after the second miss went to the founder’s old address. In the real bulk file, the IRS posted 40 New Mexico organizations with that November 15, 2025 date on March 10, 2026. If the club was among them and its CP-120A is dated no later, the streamlined window closes June 10, 2027.

    The IRS lets donors deduct gifts made before an organization’s name appears on the list, so a parent’s $500 check in December 2025 is safe. A grandparent’s $1,500 gift in August 2026 came after posting. An approved 1023-EZ filed before June 10, 2027 restores status to November 15, 2025 and covers it. Miss the window without reasonable cause for all three years, and postmark reinstatement leaves gifts from March 10, 2026 forward nondeductible until the new application.

    How does a Section 7428 declaratory judgment case work after an IRS exam revocation?

    Exam revocations begin with a proposed letter. Rev. Proc. 2026-5 routes them through its section 9 protest process: 30 days to submit a written protest and ask for an Appeals conference. If the IRS wants the revocation retroactive, a written § 7805(b) request to limit that must be filed before the final letter, or the point is lost in court (§ 12.04).

    Section 7428(b)(2) requires exhausting IRS remedies. Its 270-day rule mainly helps when the IRS sits on an application; in a revocation, exhaustion means working through protest and Appeals. After the final determination is mailed, § 7428(b)(3) requires filing “before the 91st day after the date of such mailing.” Only the organization may sue.

    The petition goes to the Tax Court, the Court of Federal Claims (28 U.S.C. § 1507), or the federal district court in Washington, D.C. Federal court in New Mexico is not an option, even for a Farmington charity. During the case, § 7428(c) keeps an individual donor’s gifts deductible up to $1,000 in total, but not for anyone responsible for the conduct behind the revocation.

    What can the Tax Court in Albuquerque do for a New Mexico nonprofit, and has the Tenth Circuit weighed in?

    Albuquerque can matter more than people expect. Initial-qualification cases are ordinarily decided on the administrative record, but under Tax Court Rule 217(a) a revocation case is limited to that record only if both sides agree it holds all relevant facts, and the judge may find facts that differ from it. Rule 212 has the organization request a place for submission when it files, and Albuquerque is a Tax Court trial city. Rule 142(a) puts the burden of proof on the petitioner unless a statute or the court says otherwise.

    Appeals from the Tax Court go to the circuit of the organization’s main office under 26 U.S.C. § 7482(b)(1)(D), so New Mexico cases go to the Tenth Circuit, whose precedent the Tax Court follows under Golsen v. Commissioner, 54 T.C. 742 (1970), aff’d, 445 F.2d 985 (10th Cir. 1971). That precedent is old and thin. Hutchinson Baseball Enterprises, Inc. v. Commissioner, 696 F.2d 757 (10th Cir. 1982), affirmed a Tax Court ruling that an amateur baseball group kept its exemption. Church of World Peace, Inc. v. IRS, 715 F.2d 492 (10th Cir. 1983), held that a good-faith refusal to produce records cannot forfeit § 7428 rights. I found no Tenth Circuit decision applying § 6033(j), unsurprising for a statute with no court route.

    What happens to New Mexico gross receipts tax and other state filings when federal tax-exempt status is lost?

    NMSA 1978, § 7-9-29 exempts receipts of organizations that show they “have been granted exemption from the federal income tax,” other than unrelated business income, and § 7-9-60 lets vendors deduct sales to 501(c)(3) buyers that give nontaxable transaction certificates. Both lean on the federal letter. How the Taxation and Revenue Department treats a gap later closed by retroactive reinstatement is a question for New Mexico counsel.

    Property tax uses a different test. N.M. Const. art. VIII, § 3 exempts “all property used for educational or charitable purposes,” and NRA Special Contribution Fund v. Board of County Commissioners, 1978-NMCA-096, looked at actual use, not federal status. Two state filings usually lapse alongside the 990: the Attorney General filing under the Charitable Solicitations Act, NMSA 1978, § 57-22-6, and the Secretary of State annual report under § 53-8-83, due the 15th day of the fifth month after the taxable year. For the soccer club, that is November 15 too.

    Issue Automatic revocation (§ 6033(j)) Exam revocation (§ 7428)
    Trigger Three straight years with no 990, 990-EZ, or 990-N IRS exam finding the group no longer qualifies
    Effective date Due date of the third missed filing Set in the letter, sometimes retroactive
    Review None; reinstatement application only Protest and Appeals, then Tax Court, Federal Claims, or D.D.C.
    Key deadline 15 months from later of CP-120A or posting Before the 91st day after the final letter is mailed
    Donors Gifts before posting; gap closed by retroactive reinstatement Up to $1,000 per individual during the case

    Frequently Asked Questions

    Can a New Mexico nonprofit appeal an automatic revocation for not filing Form 990?

    No. Section 7428(b)(4) bars a court challenge, and the IRS says it cannot undo a proper automatic revocation. The remedy is a reinstatement application, ideally retroactive under Rev. Proc. 2014-11.

    How long do we have to ask for streamlined retroactive reinstatement?

    Fifteen months after the later of the CP-120A date or the date the IRS posted the name. The organization must have been eligible for the 990-EZ or 990-N in all three missed years and never auto-revoked before.

    Can our New Mexico nonprofit bring a Section 7428 case in Albuquerque?

    Not in the District of New Mexico, which has no jurisdiction over these cases. The Tax Court does sit in Albuquerque, though, and a revocation case can be tried there unless both sides agree the administrative record is complete.

    Are donations still deductible during a Section 7428 lawsuit?

    Partly. Section 7428(c) protects each individual’s gifts during the case up to $1,000 total, counting spouses as one contributor. Insiders responsible for the revocation get no protection.

    Does losing 501(c)(3) status end the New Mexico gross receipts tax exemption?

    The § 7-9-29 exemption depends on showing a federal 501(c)(3) grant, which a revoked group cannot do. How a later retroactive reinstatement affects the gap period should be confirmed with New Mexico counsel.

    How North Star Law Firm Can Help

    North Star Law Firm helps New Mexico nonprofit boards figure out which revocation they face and build either the reinstatement package or the protest record. Its tax defense practice covers IRS examinations and Tax Court litigation, and its unfiled returns work extends to missing 990s.

    Phillip Zagotti, JD/CPA, represents taxpayers before the IRS and the U.S. Tax Court and is admitted to the U.S. District Court and Bankruptcy Court for the District of New Mexico. The firm’s post on choosing a forum against the IRS goes deeper on litigation. The firm works alongside New Mexico-licensed counsel on state-law questions. If your organization is on the revocation list or a final letter just arrived, the 15-month or 91st-day clock is already running, so contact North Star Law Firm.


  • Conservation Easement Audit in New Mexico: Fraud Penalties and No Jury After Silver Moss

    Conservation Easement Audit in New Mexico: Fraud Penalties and No Jury After Silver Moss

    A revenue agent’s report reached a ranch outside Wagon Mound this summer. It disallowed the family’s deduction for a December 2023 conservation easement and proposed a 75 percent fraud penalty, with 40 percent in the alternative. The gift also earned a New Mexico land conservation credit, partly sold already. Their first question: will a jury hear the fraud charge?

    Santa Fe investors in syndicated easement partnerships get similar letters. The jury answer for both comes from Silver Moss Properties, a 2025 Tax Court opinion, but what the IRS is attacking matters more.

    What is the IRS attacking in a New Mexico conservation easement audit?

    Most audits I see attack perpetuity, value, or both. Under 26 U.S.C. § 170(h), the restriction must be “granted in perpetuity” and its conservation purpose “protected in perpetuity.” In Mitchell v. Commissioner, 775 F.3d 1243 (10th Cir. 2015), a Colorado ranch easement failed because the lender had not subordinated its mortgage at the time of the gift, as Treas. Reg. § 1.170A-14(g)(2) requires. Ranches with land loans share that exposure unless the lender signed first.

    The proceeds clause is unsettled. Hewitt v. Commissioner, 21 F.4th 1336 (11th Cir. 2021), held the extinguishment-proceeds rule in § 1.170A-14(g)(6)(ii) procedurally invalid; Oakbrook Land Holdings, LLC v. Commissioner, 28 F.4th 700 (6th Cir. 2022), upheld it. In Valley Park Ranch, LLC v. Commissioner, 162 T.C. No. 6 (2024), an Oklahoma case headed for the Tenth Circuit, the Tax Court followed Hewitt, but the parties settled in September 2026, so the Tenth Circuit remains silent.

    Can the IRS make a syndicated conservation easement penalty stick at 75 percent?

    Under 26 U.S.C. § 6663, fraud costs 75 percent of the underpayment, and proving any portion fraudulent taints the rest unless the taxpayer rebuts it. The government bears the burden under 26 U.S.C. § 7454(a), by clear and convincing evidence.

    In North Donald LA Property, LLC v. Commissioner, T.C. Memo. 2026-19, a partnership claimed $115,391,000 for an easement the court valued at $175,824, yet fraud failed because the return disclosed the deal; a return that says “please audit me” leaves the IRS “an uphill battle.” For passive investors, the managers’ conduct was what counted.

    Claiming 200 percent or more of correct value is a gross valuation misstatement carrying 40 percent under 26 U.S.C. § 6662(h), and § 6664(c)(3) bars a reasonable-cause defense for charitable property. These penalties generally need written supervisory approval under 26 U.S.C. § 6751(b), so ask for the form early.

    For partnership gifts after December 29, 2022, § 170(h)(7) denies the deduction outright above 2.5 times the partners’ basis (absent a three-year holding or family partnership), triggering an automatic 40 percent penalty. Regulations effective October 8, 2024 (T.D. 10007) made syndicated easements listed transactions, replacing Notice 2017-10 going forward; nondisclosure keeps the year open under § 6501(c)(10).

    Facing a Conservation Easement Audit? Contact Us Now

    Is there a jury trial in Tax Court for a fraud penalty after Silver Moss?

    No. In Silver Moss Properties, LLC v. Commissioner, 165 T.C. 37 (2025), Judge Pugh’s reviewed opinion, with no dissent, gave two reasons. Suits against the United States fall outside the Seventh Amendment unless the government consents, and Congress never provided juries in partnership proceedings. And revenue collection, penalties included, is a “public right” Congress may leave to judges, as Helvering v. Mitchell, 303 U.S. 391 (1938), held for the fraud penalty’s ancestor. SEC v. Jarkesy, 144 S. Ct. 2117 (2024), involved fraud on private investors; § 6663 targets fraud on the Treasury.

    Silver Moss is a TEFRA partnership case about Florida land, and the opinion decided only the jury motion. The deduction itself remains open; the court denied an immediate appeal and set trial for April 19, 2027. Any appeal goes to the Fifth Circuit because the partnership was in Mississippi.

    Later, Riddle Aggregates, LLC v. Commissioner, 165 T.C. No. 12 (2025), extended the reasoning to accuracy penalties, and the Supreme Court denied certiorari on the jury question in Hirsch v. United States Tax Court, No. 25-739, on June 22, 2026. In Norcave Properties, L.L.C. v. IRS, No. 25-30542 (5th Cir. Aug. 21, 2026), a partnership’s pre-payment jury suit was dismissed under the Anti-Injunction Act. I found no Tenth Circuit ruling on the jury question.

    Should a New Mexico taxpayer pay first and ask for a jury in Albuquerque?

    A rancher owning the land personally has 90 days after a notice of deficiency under 26 U.S.C. § 6213(a) to petition the Tax Court, which tries cases in Albuquerque before any payment, with appeal to the Tenth Circuit under 26 U.S.C. § 7482(b)(1)(A). A jury requires full payment (Flora v. United States, 362 U.S. 145 (1960)), a refund claim (§ 7422(a)), a six-month wait (§ 6532(a)(1)), and suit in the District of New Mexico, where 28 U.S.C. § 2402 allows a jury on request.

    Partnerships differ. Since 2018, penalties are decided at the partnership level (26 U.S.C. § 6221(a)) and collected as an imputed underpayment at the top rate (§ 6225). A district court or Court of Federal Claims petition under § 6234 requires a deposit, and no forum offers a jury there. A 45-day push-out election under § 6226 moves adjustments to partners; Norcave hinted that may open an individual forum, but no court has said a jury follows.

    My view: a Mora County family might do well with jurors on fraud, but everything must be paid first, and the Tax Court’s recent easement fraud rulings have not been harsh. The firm’s post on Tax Court versus a refund suit walks through that choice.

    Does an IRS valuation cut affect the New Mexico land conservation tax credit?

    The Land Conservation Incentives Act, NMSA 1978, § 75-9-1 et seq., supports a credit under NMSA 1978, § 7-2-18.10 (corporations use § 7-2A-8.9) of 50 percent of value, capped at $250,000 for gifts since 2008, with a 20-year carryover. The Energy, Minerals and Natural Resources Department certifies the gift, and the credit may be sold once, in blocks of at least $10,000. A 2026 bill to raise it to 80 percent and $2,000,000, House Bill 186, died.

    The credit is independent of the federal deduction but rests on the same appraisal. The statute has no recapture language, and I found no authority on whether the Taxation and Revenue Department would revisit a credit after an IRS value cut, so it is an open risk. Because of the cap, the amount changes only if value falls below $500,000 or the gift fails the state’s own perpetuity requirement.

    New Mexico starts from federal adjusted gross income and itemized deductions (NMSA 1978, § 7-2-2), and NMSA 1978, § 7-1-13 requires reporting final federal adjustments within 180 days (90 for an audited partnership). But § 7-2-18.10(J) already strips the federal deduction from New Mexico itemized deductions for credit claimants, so on my reading losing it federally should not raise New Mexico taxable income. And in Esgar Corp. v. Commissioner, 744 F.3d 648 (10th Cir. 2014), which also upheld a farmland valuation, Colorado credits sold within weeks produced short-term capital gain.

    How do the numbers work for a Mora County ranch easement?

    Hypothetical figures only. A couple with a $600,000 basis in 2,400 Mora County acres gives an easement appraised at $3,000,000 in December 2023. Ranching is over half their gross income and the land stays in grazing, so § 170(b)(1)(E)(iv) raises their limit from 50 to 100 percent of their contribution base. On income near $200,000, they deduct about that much yearly and carry the rest forward up to 15 years. Basis does not cap a long-held gift, but had an investor LLC paid $600,000 in 2022 and donated in 2024, § 170(h)(7) would deny all of it, since $3,000,000 exceeds 2.5 times basis. New Mexico’s credit is 50 percent of $3,000,000, capped at $250,000.

    Now the IRS values the easement at $900,000. The claim is 333 percent of that, past the 200 percent line. If the lost $2,100,000 would have sheltered income taxed at 24 percent, that is about $504,000 of tax over the carryforward years. The 40 percent penalty would be $201,600; fraud, if proven, $378,000. Since the first $900,000 stays allowed, early years may show no underpayment. The state credit stays at $250,000; half of $900,000 still exceeds the cap.

    Penalty Trigger Rate Key defense or burden
    Gross valuation, § 6662(h) Value claimed 200% or more of correct 40% No reasonable cause for charitable property
    Syndicated disallowance, § 170(h)(7) Post-2022 partnership gift over 2.5 times basis 40% No reasonable cause; no supervisory approval needed
    Civil fraud, § 6663 Intent to evade 75% IRS proves by clear and convincing evidence
    Appraiser, § 6695A Appraisal produces a misstatement Greater of 10% or $1,000, capped at 125% of fee Value more likely than not correct

    Frequently Asked Questions

    Is a Tax Court jury trial ever available?

    No. Silver Moss held that neither the Seventh Amendment nor any statute provides a Tax Court jury, even on a fraud penalty. A jury requires a district court refund suit after full payment.

    Does an inflated appraisal automatically mean a fraud penalty?

    No. The IRS must prove intent by clear and convincing evidence, and in North Donald full disclosure defeated fraud despite a huge overvaluation. The 40 percent valuation penalty still applied.

    Will New Mexico take back my land conservation credit if the IRS wins?

    The statute has no recapture provision, and I found no authority either way. Under the $250,000 cap, a federal value cut often leaves the amount unchanged.

    What changed for syndicated conservation easements after 2022?

    Since December 29, 2022, § 170(h)(7) denies partnership deductions above 2.5 times the partners’ basis, with a 40 percent penalty. Regulations effective October 8, 2024 made these deals listed transactions.

    Has the Tenth Circuit ruled on conservation easements?

    Yes. Mitchell (unsubordinated mortgage) and Esgar (valuation and credit sales) both went against Colorado landowners. It has not ruled on the proceeds regulation or on jury rights for tax penalties.

    How North Star Law Firm Can Help

    North Star Law Firm handles IRS audit defense and Tax Court litigation for landowners and investors, including penalty challenges built on supervisory approval and the fraud burden.

    Phillip Zagotti, JD/CPA, represents taxpayers before the IRS and the U.S. Tax Court and is admitted to the U.S. District Court and Bankruptcy Court for the District of New Mexico. The firm works alongside New Mexico-licensed counsel on state-law questions. If an easement audit report or penalty letter has arrived, contact North Star Law Firm.


  • Missed the Tax Court 90-Day Deadline in New Mexico? Tolling, Time Zones and Day 91

    Missed the Tax Court 90-Day Deadline in New Mexico? Tolling, Time Zones and Day 91

    A pipe-yard welder moves from Farmington to Las Cruces in the spring of 2026, after filing his 2025 return from the old San Juan County address. In November an IRS balance-due letter finds him in Doña Ana County, referring to a notice of deficiency mailed in July. His 90 days to challenge it in the U.S. Tax Court are gone.

    Can missed Tax Court deadlines be excused? September made it look possible: the Tax Court let a partnership’s late petition in, and the Senate passed a tolling bill. For New Mexico individuals, the 90 days remain a wall that goes up at 9:59 p.m. Mountain time.

    Does the Tax Court 90-day deadline still bar a late petition from New Mexico?

    Yes, for now. Under 26 U.S.C. § 7482(b)(1)(A), an individual’s appeal goes to the circuit where the taxpayer legally resides, which for New Mexico is the Tenth Circuit. Under Golsen v. Commissioner, 54 T.C. 742 (1970), aff’d, 445 F.2d 985 (10th Cir. 1971), the Tax Court applies that circuit’s on-point precedent and otherwise uses its own.

    Its own precedent has not moved. Hallmark Research Collective v. Commissioner, 159 T.C. 126 (2022), dismissed a petition that came in one day late, holding the deadline in 26 U.S.C. § 6213(a) jurisdictional and beyond equitable tolling despite Boechler, P.C. v. Commissioner, 596 U.S. 199 (2022), which made the 30-day collection due process deadline tollable. The reviewed opinion in Sanders v. Commissioner, 161 T.C. 112 (2023), reaffirmed it. The Tenth Circuit’s older cases agree, including Foster v. Commissioner, 445 F.2d 799 (10th Cir. 1971). My search turned up no Tenth Circuit ruling on the point since Boechler.

    Other circuits split three ways. The Second, Third, Sixth and Eighth call the deadline nonjurisdictional and tollable (Buller, 2d Cir. 2025; Culp, 75 F.4th 196 (3d Cir. 2023); Oquendo, 6th Cir. 2025; Maniktala, 8th Cir. Aug. 11, 2026). The First Circuit, in Kyick Holdings (Aug. 17, 2026), found it nonjurisdictional but mandatory, so no tolling. The Seventh and Ninth still say jurisdictional. The Supreme Court turned down the government’s Culp petition in June 2024, and its docket showed nothing pending on October 9, 2026. Only an appeal could retire Foster.

    Why did a partnership get equitable tolling in Tax Court when individuals cannot?

    Partnerships covered by the Bipartisan Budget Act audit rules get 90 days after a final partnership adjustment is mailed, under 26 U.S.C. § 6234(a). Big Apple Tompkins Realty LLC v. Commissioner, 167 T.C. No. 7 (Aug. 5, 2026), read that subsection as permission to file rather than a restriction on the court’s authority. Kings Road Property, LLC v. Commissioner, 167 T.C. No. 11 (Sept. 21, 2026), then accepted a petition 16 days late.

    Same court, same 90 days, opposite results, and history explains why. Hallmark leaned on the prior-construction canon: the deficiency deadline has been called jurisdictional since 1924, and Congress kept reenacting the words without disturbing that reading. A 2015 regime has no such record.

    Its facts still matter. Both certified-mail packages came back from a correct address, and an IRS employee told counsel no notice had gone out. The court declined to say returned mail alone would do, and in Kyick a returned notice earned nothing. A New Mexico partnership’s appeal lies in the Tenth Circuit (§ 7482(b)(1)(E)), so Kings Road governs unless that circuit says otherwise.

    Missed a Tax Court Deadline? Contact Us Now

    What time is the Tax Court filing deadline in New Mexico?

    For an electronic filing, 9:59 p.m. Mountain time. Under Tax Court Rule 22(d), an e-filed petition is timely only if filed “at or before 11:59 p.m., eastern time” on the last day. New Mexico and the East Coast both observe daylight saving time, so the gap is two hours all year. A petition reaching DAWSON, the court’s filing system, at 10:00 p.m. in Gallup arrives on the next day in Washington.

    In Nutt v. Commissioner, 160 T.C. 470 (2023), an Alabama couple filed at 11:05 p.m. Central, 12:05 a.m. Eastern, and lost. In a different Sanders v. Commissioner, 160 T.C. No. 16 (2023), an upload 11 seconds past midnight Eastern was late. A real DAWSON outage on the due date extends the deadline under 26 U.S.C. § 7451(b); trouble with your own laptop does not. Without tolling, one minute late is as fatal as one year.

    How is the 90-day period counted on a New Mexico notice of deficiency?

    The clock starts at mailing, not arrival. Section 6213(a) allows 90 days, or 150 when the notice is addressed to a person outside the country. A last day that lands on a Saturday, Sunday or D.C. legal holiday moves to the next business day (see 26 U.S.C. § 7503); a New Mexico state holiday does not count. A petition filed by the date printed on the notice is timely even if that date is wrong.

    For a last-day filer in Hobbs or Raton, paper has one edge: Eastern time plays no part. Under 26 U.S.C. § 7502(a), a timely Postal Service postmark counts as the filing date. Private carriers qualify only for the DHL, FedEx and UPS services on the IRS’s designated list (Notice 2016-30).

    Does a notice of deficiency count if it went to my old New Mexico address?

    Usually. Under 26 U.S.C. § 6212(b)(1), a notice sent to the taxpayer’s last known address is enough, received or not. Treas. Reg. § 301.6212-2 makes that the address on your latest properly processed return, absent “clear and concise notification” of another; Postal Service change-of-address data can also update it. A move reported to “another government agency” does not count, so telling the New Mexico Taxation and Revenue Department or the MVD changes nothing at the IRS. Form 8822 does.

    In Armstrong v. Commissioner, 15 F.3d 970 (10th Cir. 1994), a notice returned “unclaimed” from a Tulsa post office box was valid because diligence is judged at mailing. That rule is why the returned packages in Kings Road did not void the notice, leaving tolling as the only way in.

    How does the deadline play out for a Las Cruces taxpayer?

    Illustration only: the IRS mails and dates the welder’s 2024 notice on Monday, July 27, 2026, to the Farmington address on his 2025 return. Day 90 is Sunday, October 25, so his last day is Monday, October 26. An e-filed petition must reach DAWSON by 9:59 p.m.; a mailed one needs a postmark no later than October 26.

    He learns of it on Friday, November 20, 116 days after mailing. Farmington was his last known address, so the notice is valid and a petition now would be dismissed under Hallmark. In Ohio or Missouri he could at least argue tolling. Had he filed Form 8822 in May, the Farmington mailing itself would be open to attack.

    What can a New Mexico taxpayer do after missing the Tax Court deadline?

    Each remaining route costs more. Audit reconsideration asks the IRS to reopen the exam; IRM 4.13.1 lists a move and missed mail as reasons and allows it after a jurisdictional dismissal, given new information. Before levying, the IRS must offer a collection due process hearing with its Independent Office of Appeals, and 26 U.S.C. § 6330(c)(2)(B) lets someone who never received the notice dispute the tax itself. A doubt-as-to-liability compromise offer, governed by Treas. Reg. § 301.7122-1(b)(1), remains open where no court has decided the amount.

    A refund suit requires full payment first under Flora v. United States, 362 U.S. 145 (1960), which arose in the Tenth Circuit. Then comes a claim within the § 6511(a) window, a six-month wait or denial under § 6532(a)(1), and suit in the District of New Mexico or the Court of Federal Claims. The firm’s post on Tax Court versus a refund suit or bankruptcy court compares them.

    On September 30, 2026, the Senate passed H.R. 5349 as amended, the Taxpayer Assistance and Service Act; its section 307 would make the § 6213(a) deadline tollable in cases pending on or after enactment. The House must act again.

    Deadline Rule for a New Mexico filer Can lateness be excused? Key authority
    Individual deficiency petition, § 6213(a) 90 days (150 if addressed abroad), jurisdictional No tolling in Tax Court Hallmark; Foster
    BBA partnership petition, § 6234(a) 90 days, not jurisdictional Yes, on diligence and extraordinary circumstances Big Apple; Kings Road
    Collection due process petition, § 6330(d)(1) 30 days, not jurisdictional Tolling available Boechler
    E-filed petition, last day 9:59 p.m. Mountain (11:59 p.m. Eastern) Only if DAWSON was down Rule 22(d); § 7451(b); Nutt
    Mailed petition USPS postmark on or before the last day Treated as filed when mailed § 7502; Notice 2016-30

    Frequently Asked Questions

    Does the Tax Court treat the 90-day deadline as jurisdictional for New Mexico residents?

    Yes, in that court. It applies Hallmark because the Tenth Circuit has yet to rule since Boechler, and its older decisions agree, so the reason for the delay is never reached.

    Does the Kings Road decision help an individual who filed late?

    Not directly. It covers partnership petitions under the BBA rules, and the individual deadline carries a far longer history.

    What time must a New Mexico taxpayer e-file a Tax Court petition?

    By 9:59 p.m. Mountain time on the last day. Rule 22(d) uses 11:59 p.m. Eastern, and the court has dismissed a petition that arrived 11 seconds late.

    Does a notice of deficiency count if it never reached me?

    Generally yes, if the IRS used your last known address. Not receiving it matters mainly in a collection due process hearing, where it may let you dispute the tax itself.

    Will the Senate-passed bill rescue a petition already dismissed as late?

    Probably not. The Senate version reaches cases pending on or after enactment and disclaims any inference for cases the Tax Court finally decided before then. It is not law until the House agrees and the President signs.

    How North Star Law Firm Can Help

    North Star Law Firm handles Tax Court litigation for New Mexico taxpayers and represents taxpayers in Appeals and collection due process hearings after the Tax Court door closes. Where the assessment is wrong, it also weighs offers in compromise.

    Phillip Zagotti, JD/CPA, represents taxpayers before the IRS and the U.S. Tax Court and is admitted to the U.S. District Court and Bankruptcy Court for the District of New Mexico. The firm works alongside New Mexico-licensed counsel on state-law questions. If an IRS deficiency notice is on your counter, contact North Star Law Firm.


  • Tax Preparer Fraud Statute of Limitations in New Mexico After the Murrin Cert Denial

    Tax Preparer Fraud Statute of Limitations in New Mexico After the Murrin Cert Denial

    On June 22, 2026, the Supreme Court denied review in Murrin v. Commissioner, No. 25-988, without comment. That left a real conflict on the tax preparer fraud statute of limitations: whether the IRS can reach back decades when a preparer, not the taxpayer, falsified the return. The Tax Court and Third Circuit say yes; the Federal Circuit said no in 2015, on different facts.

    For an Albuquerque or Las Cruces family whose preparer was later indicted, the answer depends on where the fight happens, because the Tenth Circuit, which hears New Mexico appeals, has not ruled.

    Listen to this post

    North Star Tax and Legal Briefing: Tax Preparer Fraud Statute of Limitations in New Mexico After the Murrin Cert Denial

    A preparer falsifies returns, the client never knows, and years later the IRS sends a notice for every tainted year. This episode explains when the limitations period stays open after the Murrin cert denial, what the Tenth Circuit has not decided, and what a New Mexico taxpayer should do within the 90-day window.

    Download the MP3 · Episode page on Podbean

    Show / hide the episode transcript

    A New Mexico couple files their returns on time, every year, through a storefront preparer. Years later, that preparer is convicted of padding his clients’ returns with fake deductions. The couple never knew. Then, long after the normal three-year window has closed, the I R S mails a notice covering every one of those years at once. Can the government really reach back that far when the fraud belonged to the preparer, not the taxpayer? In the Tax Court, the answer is yes. In one federal appeals court, the answer was no. And this June, the Supreme Court declined to settle it. For New Mexico taxpayers, where the fight happens may decide how it ends.

    Start with the normal rule. The I R S generally has three years after a return is filed to assess more tax. There is a six-year window when a return leaves out more than twenty-five percent of the income it should have reported. But a preparer who invents deductions usually omits no income at all, so that longer window never opens. What’s left is the fraud exception. It removes the deadline entirely for a false or fraudulent return filed with intent to evade tax. Here is the key distinction to hold onto. The statute never says whose intent. It does not say the taxpayer’s, and it does not say the preparer’s. It simply says a return filed with intent to evade can be assessed at any time. Everything in this episode turns on how the courts fill in that silence.

    The Tax Court answered first, in two thousand seven, in the Allen case. A truck driver’s preparer had been convicted on thirty counts of aiding false returns, and the court held that the preparer’s intent alone was enough to keep the client’s years open indefinitely. It applied the same rule in the Murrin case, upholding a two thousand nineteen notice for tax years nineteen ninety-three through nineteen ninety-nine. The taxpayer conceded about sixty-five thousand dollars in tax, and the court put the interest at close to two hundred fifty thousand dollars. The Third Circuit affirmed, calling the statute agnostic about who intended to evade. On June twenty-second of this year, the Supreme Court denied review without comment, so that decision stands. Now the other side. The Federal Circuit read the statute more narrowly in two thousand fifteen. But that ruling is thinner than it looks. The fraud there came from an outside attorney who designed a tax shelter, not a return preparer, and the court expressly reserved the closer case of someone more directly involved in preparing the return. And the Tenth Circuit, which hears New Mexico appeals, has never ruled on the question at all.

    Take a hypothetical Albuquerque couple whose preparer added about six thousand dollars of tax per year in fake deductions across four years, on correct tax near thirty thousand dollars a year. The three-year windows closed long ago. Then a notice arrives for all four years. The tax alone is twenty-four thousand dollars. The twenty percent accuracy penalty adds another forty-eight hundred. Interest runs from the original due dates, and at a hypothetical five percent average rate it comes to roughly twenty thousand three hundred dollars more. That is the compounding problem: the older the year, the larger the interest. One piece of good news. The seventy-five percent fraud penalty turns on the taxpayer’s own fraud, which the government must prove. A client who knew nothing generally faces only the twenty percent penalty, and reasonable cause and good faith can defeat it.

    Forum choice matters here. A Tax Court petition costs nothing up front, but it must be filed within ninety days, and the Tax Court will apply its own rule. A refund suit requires paying the full assessment first, a check near forty-nine thousand dollars in our example. And petitioning the Tax Court generally bars a later refund suit for the same year. So, three things this week. If you have received a notice for an old year, calendar the ninety-day deadline today. Gather every return and every message from the preparer, because the penalty defense lives in what you knew and when. And before anyone files your next return, confirm the preparer signs it and lists an identifying number, read it before you sign, and keep a copy. That’s what we do at North Star Law Firm. The initial consultation is free, and the full written analysis with citations is at N M dash legal dot net.

    What does the tax preparer fraud statute of limitations in § 6501(c)(1) say?

    Under 26 U.S.C. § 6501, the IRS generally has three years to assess. Subsection (c)(1) removes the deadline: “In the case of a false or fraudulent return with the intent to evade tax, the tax may be assessed . . . at any time.” It never says whose intent. The willful-evasion rule in (c)(2) excludes income tax. The six-year period in (e)(1)(A) needs omitted gross income above 25 percent of what was reported, and a preparer who invents deductions usually omits none. That leaves (c)(1) as the only open door.

    The Tax Court first applied (c)(1) to preparer fraud in Allen v. Commissioner, 128 T.C. 37 (2007), where a Memphis truck driver’s preparer was convicted on 30 counts of aiding false returns. It followed Allen in Murrin v. Commissioner, T.C. Memo. 2024-10, upholding a 2019 notice for 1993 through 1999. The Third Circuit affirmed in Murrin v. Commissioner, 158 F.4th 527 (3d Cir. 2025) (amended Oct. 17, 2025), drawing on the passive-voice reasoning of Bartenwerfer v. Buckley, 598 U.S. 69 (2023). It called the statute “agnostic” about who intended to evade. Ms. Murrin conceded $65,318 in tax, with interest the court estimated near $250,000.

    What did the Supreme Court’s denial leave standing?

    The petition was filed February 17, 2026. The Solicitor General’s brief in opposition argued there was no square conflict, and the June 22, 2026 order list denied review without reasons.

    The other side of the split is BASR Partnership v. United States, 795 F.3d 1338 (Fed. Cir. 2015), and it is thinner than it looks. The fraud came from an outside attorney who designed a shelter. Judge O’Malley’s concurrence leaned heavily on the TEFRA partnership rule in former § 6229, and majority footnote 3 reserved whether someone “more closely connected to the tax preparation” counts. The Second Circuit in City Wide Transit, Inc. v. Commissioner, 709 F.3d 102 (2d Cir. 2013) found an embezzling accountant’s fraud sufficient on a taxpayer concession, and Finnegan v. Commissioner, 926 F.3d 1261 (11th Cir. 2019), involving Murrin’s same preparer, held the challenge waived.

    Which forum does a New Mexico taxpayer have, and what does each one cost?

    A Tax Court petition filed within 90 days under § 6213(a) requires no payment, but the court will apply Allen. Under Golsen v. Commissioner, 54 T.C. 742 (1970), it follows a circuit decision “squarely in point” only where appeal lies to that circuit, as it explained in Valley Park Ranch, LLC v. Commissioner, 162 T.C. No. 6 (2024). A New Mexico resident’s appeal goes to the Tenth Circuit under § 7482(b)(1)(A), and a search found no Tenth Circuit decision on third-party intent. The nearest case, Omega Forex Group, LC v. United States, No. 17-4066 (10th Cir. Oct. 22, 2018), turned on the taxpayer’s own fraud.

    The refund route starts with full payment of the assessment, as Flora v. United States, 362 U.S. 145 (1960) requires, then a claim within the § 6511(a) window under § 7422(a), then a six-month wait unless the claim is disallowed sooner under § 6532(a)(1). Suit can go to the Court of Federal Claims (28 U.S.C. § 1491; § 1346(a)(1)), with appeal to the Federal Circuit and BASR, or to the District of New Mexico, where appeal lies to the Tenth Circuit. Under § 6512(a), a Tax Court petition generally bars a later refund suit for the year.

    Notice of Deficiency for an Old Year in New Mexico? Contact Us Now

    If the preparer committed the fraud, what penalties and interest remain?

    The 20 percent penalty in § 6662 reaches a substantial understatement, one above the greater of 10 percent of the correct tax or $5,000. The 75 percent fraud penalty in § 6663 is different; the Third Circuit read it as reaching only the taxpayer’s own fraud, which the IRS must prove under § 7454(a).

    The defense is reasonable cause and good faith under § 6664(c)(1). United States v. Boyle, 469 U.S. 241 (1985) treats reliance on advice about “a matter of tax law” as reasonable. Neonatology Associates, P.A. v. Commissioner, 115 T.C. 43 (2000) sets a three-part test for that reliance. Allen, though, expects taxpayers to catch items that are “obviously false or incorrect.” Interest under § 6601(a) runs from the original due date. The individual rate for the current quarter is 7 percent (IR-2026-98). The amended Third Circuit opinion left interest challenges open, though abatement under § 6404(e) is narrow and counts IRS delay only after written contact.

    How would this play out for an Albuquerque couple whose preparer was convicted?

    A hypothetical Northeast Heights couple filed 2012 through 2015 joint returns on time through a storefront preparer. He added fake deductions worth $6,000 of tax per year, on correct tax near $30,000, and was convicted in 2024. The three-year windows closed between April 2016 and April 2019. With no omitted income, the six-year rule never applied. In 2026 the IRS mails a notice for all four years, relying on the tax preparer fraud statute of limitations.

    The tax totals $24,000. Each year’s $6,000 exceeds $5,000, so the § 6662 penalty adds $4,800. At a hypothetical 5 percent average rate compounded daily, interest through 2026 is about $20,300, excluding interest on penalties. The refund route means a check near $49,000 first. The Tax Court costs nothing up front but applies Allen, leaving the penalty defense and a possible Tenth Circuit appeal.

    Path Pay first? Appeal goes to Preparer-fraud rule
    Tax Court petition No Tenth Circuit Allen applies; circuit undecided
    Court of Federal Claims refund suit Yes, in full Federal Circuit BASR, subject to footnote 3
    D.N.M. refund suit Yes, in full Tenth Circuit Open question
    Concede, then seek relief No None Relief only, no limitations defense

    What relief remains after an old-year assessment, and how does New Mexico’s statute differ?

    Assessed tax is collectible for ten years under § 6502(a), so a 2027 assessment runs into 2037. An offer based on doubt as to liability is unavailable after a final court decision under Treas. Reg. § 301.7122-1(b), while effective tax administration offers remain. Where one spouse dealt with the preparer, § 6015 relief is decided “without regard to community property laws,” which matters in New Mexico.

    The state statute reads differently. NMSA 1978, § 7-1-18 starts with three years from the end of the year tax was due. Its fraud period is ten years, not unlimited, and covers “a false or fraudulent return made by a taxpayer with intent to evade tax.” A federal change also triggers a report due 180 days after final determination under § 7-1-13(E), with its own assessment window.

    What should New Mexico taxpayers check before a preparer files?

    A paid return must carry the preparer’s identifying number under § 6109(a)(4) and a signature, with a § 6695(b) penalty for failing to sign. The IRS warns about unsigned “ghost” returns in IR-2024-96, and its preparer selection page links a credential directory. Read the return before signing; keep a copy. The preparer faces the greater of $5,000 or 75 percent of his income from the return under § 6694(b) and felony exposure under § 7206(2), but neither pays the client’s tax. See the firm’s guide to IRS preparer investigations in New Mexico.

    Frequently Asked Questions

    Can the IRS assess tax for a year my preparer falsified without my knowledge?

    In the Tax Court, yes. Allen and Murrin hold that a preparer’s intent to evade tax keeps the period open indefinitely under section 6501(c)(1), even when the taxpayer knew nothing. The Federal Circuit read the statute more narrowly in BASR, and the Tenth Circuit has not decided the question.

    Did the Supreme Court decide Murrin?

    No. The Court denied certiorari on June 22, 2026, in No. 25-988. The Third Circuit’s decision stands and the conflict with BASR remains. The government had argued the conflict was not square, because BASR involved an attorney who created a tax shelter rather than a return preparer.

    Will I owe the 75 percent fraud penalty if my preparer committed the fraud?

    The civil fraud penalty under section 6663 turns on the taxpayer’s own fraud, and the IRS bears the burden of proving it. A taxpayer who knew nothing of the scheme more often faces the 20 percent accuracy penalty under section 6662, which reasonable cause and good faith can defeat.

    Should a New Mexico taxpayer pay and sue in the Court of Federal Claims to use BASR?

    Sometimes. That route requires full payment and a refund claim before suit, usually with a six-month wait. BASR involved an outside attorney rather than a preparer, and its footnote 3 reserved the closer case. Petitioning the Tax Court first generally bars a later refund suit for that year.

    Does New Mexico follow the same unlimited rule for its own taxes?

    No. NMSA 1978, section 7-1-18 allows ten years, not unlimited time, for a false or fraudulent return made by a taxpayer with intent to evade. A federal adjustment carries its own state reporting duty and assessment window. North Star Law Firm works with New Mexico-licensed counsel on state-law questions.

    How North Star Law Firm Can Help

    North Star Law Firm represents New Mexico taxpayers facing a notice of deficiency for years tainted by a preparer’s fraud, through Tax Court litigation and penalty abatement work. Where one spouse dealt with the preparer, innocent spouse relief is part of the firm’s tax defense practice.

    Phillip Zagotti, JD/CPA, represents taxpayers before the IRS and the U.S. Tax Court and is admitted to the U.S. District Court for the District of New Mexico. On forum choice, see where a New Mexico taxpayer fights the IRS. The firm works alongside New Mexico-licensed counsel on state-law questions. To review an old-year notice before the 90 days run, contact North Star Law Firm.


  • The SBA Demand Letter New Mexico Borrowers Can’t Ignore: A 30-Day Playbook

    The SBA Demand Letter New Mexico Borrowers Can’t Ignore: A 30-Day Playbook

    The U.S. Small Business Administration suspended 870,000 pandemic-loan borrowers, it announced on September 14, 2026 (SBA News Release 26-91). Its state chart lists 2,383 in New Mexico, tied to $151,969,959 in PPP and COVID EIDL approvals, about $63,800 per borrower. Those are approvals, not fraud findings. Still, loan size shapes what an SBA demand letter means for New Mexico borrowers, because it helps decide which enforcement track the government can use.

    The release also launched “Operation No Doze,” final 30-day demand letters starting with about 8,000 borrowers in Kansas and Missouri. New Mexico was not in that first wave. It follows the firm’s August post on DOJ’s National Fraud Enforcement Division.

    What does an SBA suspension do, and can it be contested?

    A suspended borrower is barred from new SBA business and disaster lending and from other SBA programs, including 8(a) contracting. For a Las Cruces firm that bids federal work, that can sting more than the loan. The releases, though, never cite the rule behind the suspensions.

    If the notice is a formal Notice of Suspension under the nonprocurement rules SBA adopted in 2 C.F.R. part 2700, the borrower has 30 days after receipt to submit opposition under 2 C.F.R. § 180.725, and 2 C.F.R. § 180.760 limits the suspension to 12 months unless proceedings begin. If it cites something else, or nothing, identifying the regime comes first.

    What happens when an SBA demand letter goes unpaid after 30 days?

    SBA says nonpayment within 30 days can mean an Administrative False Claims Act case or a DOJ referral on top of Treasury collection. Under 31 U.S.C. § 3711(g), nontax debt 180 days delinquent must go to Treasury; in April SBA reported referring 562,000 suspected fraudulent loans worth about $22.2 billion (SBA News Release 26-47).

    Before offset, 31 U.S.C. § 3716(a) requires written notice, access to the agency’s records, agency review, and a chance to sign a repayment agreement. Offset has no time limit under § 3716(e)(1). Federal tax refunds are reachable under 31 C.F.R. § 285.2. For Social Security, 31 C.F.R. § 285.4(e) caps the monthly offset at the lesser of 15 percent or the amount above $750: a Roswell retiree drawing $1,250 loses $187.50, and one drawing $700 loses nothing.

    Wages are exposed under 31 U.S.C. § 3720D, up to 15 percent of disposable pay after 30 days’ notice, with a hearing under 31 C.F.R. § 285.11 for a debtor who asks within 15 business days. Treasury’s process differs from the IRS levy in the firm’s post on stopping an IRS wage garnishment.

    SBA warns Cross-Servicing may add fees “of up to 28 percent.” Fiscal Service’s own pages state no percentage; 31 U.S.C. § 3717(e) passes processing costs to the debtor plus up to 6 percent a year after 90 days. Fiscal Service lists no State Reciprocal Program participants, and the firm could not confirm New Mexico’s. The state’s refund intercept statute, NMSA 1978, § 7-2C-3, names no federal claimant agency.

    Got an SBA Demand Letter in New Mexico? Contact Us Now

    Which civil track fits a New Mexico-sized loan?

    SBA’s “Administrative False Claims Act” is the 1986 Program Fraud Civil Remedies Act, renamed by Pub. L. 118-159 in December 2024. Under 31 U.S.C. § 3802, a knowingly false claim brings a per-claim penalty plus an assessment of up to twice the claim. 13 C.F.R. § 142.1(b) sets SBA’s penalty at $14,308. An administrative law judge decides, and an answer is due 30 days after service under 13 C.F.R. § 142.12.

    Older summaries cap it at $150,000. The 2024 amendment raised the cap in 31 U.S.C. § 3803(c) to $1,000,000, which covers nearly every New Mexico pandemic loan. Notice is due within the later of six years or three years after discovery, capped at ten, under 31 U.S.C. § 3808(a).

    The civil False Claims Act, 31 U.S.C. § 3729, is DOJ’s heavier tool in federal court: treble damages plus a penalty that 28 C.F.R. § 85.5 sets at $14,308 to $28,619 per claim. Beyond the general clock in 31 U.S.C. § 3731(b), the COVID-19 EIDL Fraud Statute of Limitations Act of 2022, Pub. L. 117-165, and the PPP and Bank Fraud Enforcement Harmonization Act of 2022, Pub. L. 117-166, allow ten years for any criminal charge or civil enforcement action alleging borrower fraud. A 2020 application stays open into 2030.

    How do the numbers look for a Rio Rancho contractor?

    A hypothetical: a Rio Rancho framing contractor, a sole proprietor, took a $90,000 COVID EIDL in June 2020 and a $42,000 PPP loan in 2021 that was later forgiven. Both get flagged. Every figure below is hypothetical and a statutory maximum.

    Administratively, double the $132,000 is $264,000, and two claims add $28,616 in penalties, for $292,616. Under the False Claims Act, treble damages reach $396,000 and penalties run $28,616 to $57,238, a top of $453,238. Damages on a forgiven PPP loan are contested; these totals assume full loan amounts.

    If he ignores the letter, the EIDL moves to Treasury. A full 28 percent turns $90,000 into $115,200 before interest. A $2,900 refund in February 2027 is taken. At $1,900 a month in Social Security, offset stops at $285. With $3,000 a month in disposable wages, garnishment could reach $450. The forgiven PPP loan is not collectible, but it can still anchor a false claims theory.

    Should a borrower with clean books respond differently from one with real exposure?

    Yes. On September 23, SBA said the IRS compared tax information on loan applications with what borrowers reported to the IRS and found discrepancies tied to about $100 billion in loans (SBA News Release 26-95). A Farmington owner whose 2019 Schedule C supports the application, with bank statements showing the money went to payroll, is in a documentation fight and should answer inside the 30 days with records.

    An owner whose numbers do not match should talk to counsel before saying anything to SBA or the IRS, partly because a new certified statement can itself violate § 3802(a)(2). The mismatch also cuts both ways: overstated receipts taint the application, while real receipts suggest an underreported return. The IRS says it will seek fraud penalties, 75 percent of the fraud-driven underpayment under 26 U.S.C. § 6663, and 26 U.S.C. § 6501(c)(1) sets no deadline for a fraudulent return. The applications were signed under penalty of perjury. For both owners, day 30 is a hard date.

    Can an offer in compromise or bankruptcy end the problem?

    A fraud flag blocks the usual SBA compromise for a closed business. Section 3711(b)(1) bars agency compromise of a claim that “appears to be fraudulent, false, or misrepresented,” and 31 C.F.R. § 900.3(a) leaves those debts to DOJ. Clearing the flag reopens it.

    An SBA loan is ordinarily dischargeable. The government’s exceptions are 11 U.S.C. § 523(a)(2)(A), for false pretenses or actual fraud, and § 523(a)(2)(B), for a materially false written statement of financial condition. Under § 523(c) and Fed. R. Bankr. P. 4007(c), it must sue within 60 days after the first date set for the § 341 meeting. A meeting first set for December 3, 2026 means a February 1, 2027 deadline. Section 523(a)(7), for government penalties that are not compensation for actual loss, has no such deadline.

    In In re Ortega, No. 25-11139-j7 (Bankr. D.N.M. Sept. 15, 2026), the court held excusable neglect cannot extend that deadline, quoting the Tenth Circuit’s “strict sixty-day time limit.” The creditor was private. No published Tenth Circuit, BAP, or D.N.M. decision applying § 523(a)(2) to a PPP or EIDL loan was located on review.

    Track Who decides Money at stake Time limit
    SBA suspension SBA suspending official Program bar only 30 days to contest
    Administrative False Claims Act Administrative law judge Double the claim plus $14,308 per claim 6 years, 10 at most
    Civil False Claims Act Federal district court Triple damages plus $14,308 to $28,619 per claim 10 years
    Treasury collection Fiscal Service Balance, fees, offset, garnishment None on offset
    Bankruptcy fraud exception Bankruptcy court Debt survives if proven 60 days after first § 341 date

    Frequently Asked Questions

    Has every suspended New Mexico borrower received a 30-day demand letter?

    No. SBA said Operation No Doze letters would begin with about 8,000 borrowers in Kansas and Missouri. A suspension and a demand letter are separate events, so a borrower can be suspended before any repayment demand arrives. Read each notice for its own deadline.

    Can Treasury take Social Security to pay an SBA pandemic loan?

    Yes, within limits. Under 31 C.F.R. § 285.4, the monthly offset is the lesser of 15 percent of the benefit or the amount above $750. A $1,250 benefit loses $187.50, and a benefit of $750 or less is not offset.

    Is the Administrative False Claims Act different from the Program Fraud Civil Remedies Act?

    It is the same statute under a new name. Congress renamed the 1986 act in December 2024 and raised its per-claim ceiling from $150,000 to $1,000,000. An administrative law judge hears the case, and exposure is as much as twice the claim plus a per-claim penalty, now $14,308 at SBA.

    Can a fraud-flagged EIDL be settled through an SBA offer in compromise?

    Not by SBA alone. Federal law bars an agency from compromising a claim that appears fraudulent, and the federal claims collection standards reserve those debts to the Department of Justice. A borrower who used the money properly usually must clear the flag first.

    Will a Chapter 7 bankruptcy discharge an EIDL that SBA says was fraudulent?

    It can, unless the government proves an exception. A fraud complaint under § 523(a)(2) must be filed within 60 days after the first date set for the creditors’ meeting, and the New Mexico bankruptcy court enforces that deadline strictly. A government penalty may fall under § 523(a)(7), which has no comparable deadline.

    How North Star Law Firm Can Help

    North Star Law Firm represents New Mexico owners facing SBA suspension notices and demand letters, and its tax defense work covers the IRS side of these referrals. Its bankruptcy practice includes Chapter 7 cases for owners of closed businesses.

    Phillip Zagotti, JD/CPA, represents taxpayers before the IRS and the U.S. Tax Court and is admitted to the U.S. District Court and Bankruptcy Court for the District of New Mexico. If an IRS exam leaves a tax balance, the firm’s worked offer in compromise example shows the math. The firm works alongside New Mexico-licensed counsel on state-law questions. To have a notice reviewed before the 30 days run, contact North Star Law Firm.


  • Does a 363 Sale Wipe Out New Mexico Tax Successor Liability?

    Does a 363 Sale Wipe Out New Mexico Tax Successor Liability?

    A buyer who takes over an Albuquerque restaurant’s kitchen equipment and liquor license can end up owing the seller’s unpaid gross receipts tax under NMSA 1978, §§ 7-1-61 through 7-1-63. Sale fights like the BowFlex dumbbell case in New Jersey make news over product claims, but in New Mexico the liability that chases the assets is usually tax.

    Does a “free and clear” order in a District of New Mexico bankruptcy sale hold off the Taxation and Revenue Department and the IRS? It can, if the order is written for tax and both agencies are properly served. (The firm’s post on successor liability for New Mexico asset buyers covers the common-law theories.)

    What does New Mexico’s successor tax liability statute require of a buyer?

    Section 7-1-61(B) says business property “remains subject to liability for payment of the tax due” after it changes hands. The successor must either hold enough of the price in trust until the Department certifies nothing is due, or pay the seller’s tax on demand or assessment. “Tax” includes penalties and interest under every program in § 7-1-2 except the Income Tax Act, so gross receipts and state withholding tax are covered.

    Under 3.1.10.16 NMAC, one of eight indicators, such as a noncompete, lets the Department presume a successor. Section 7-1-63 gives the successor thirty days to pay before an assessment, and paying the full value of the transferred property discharges it. That ceiling vanishes for assumed debts, evasion schemes, de facto mergers, and “mere continuation” deals, so insider buyouts under a new LLC usually lose it.

    How does a New Mexico tax clearance certificate protect the buyer?

    Section 7-1-62 puts the Department on a clock. After a written request, it has thirty days (longer if the seller’s records reach audit later, but never past sixty) to issue a certificate or mail a notice of tax due. Miss that, and the successor is released.

    The request goes on Form ACD-31096 with the signed purchase agreement, and its instructions say a request made after the transaction’s effective date will not be processed. Restaurants and bars also need a separate liquor license clearance.

    Buying or Selling a New Mexico Business with Tax Debt? Contact Us Now

    Can a 363 sale order cut off New Mexico tax successor liability?

    11 U.S.C. § 363(f) authorizes selling property “free and clear of any interest in such property” under five conditions, most usefully (f)(5), where the holder could be compelled to take money. In re Trans World Airlines, Inc., 322 F.3d 283 (3d Cir. 2003), read “interest” to reach obligations arising from the property sold, not only liens. In re Leckie Smokeless Coal Co., 99 F.3d 573 (4th Cir. 1996), is closer to tax: Coal Act premiums, a statutory successor obligation, could be extinguished under (f)(5).

    In re Elk Grove Village Petroleum, LLC, 510 B.R. 594 (Bankr. N.D. Ill. 2014), an Illinois bulk-sales case, held that “IDOR’s right to assert transferee liability is an ‘interest’” under Section 363(f). The district court let that stand but held the state was owed adequate protection under § 363(e), though on remand it proved no realizable claim.

    No published Tenth Circuit or Tenth Circuit BAP decision on this question was located on review. Section 7-1-61(B) ties the liability to the property itself, which helps the buyer, and 11 U.S.C. § 106(a)(1) abrogates state sovereign immunity as to §§ 363 and 505.

    What happens to an IRS tax lien and unpaid payroll tax in a 363 sale?

    No federal statute mirrors § 7-1-61 for payroll tax. The IRS reaches a buyer mainly through its lien, which attaches to the taxpayer’s property under 26 U.S.C. § 6321 and binds a purchaser once notice is filed under § 6323(a). A filed lien is the easy case: the sale closes under (f)(3) or (f)(5), and the lien moves to the proceeds.

    The sale does not touch the trust fund recovery penalty. Section 6672 reaches any person “required to collect, truthfully account for, and pay over” the tax who willfully failed to, meaning owners and officers, and no sale order releases them.

    What notice must the Taxation and Revenue Department and the IRS receive?

    Mullane v. Central Hanover Bank & Trust Co., 339 U.S. 306 (1950), requires notice “reasonably calculated, under all the circumstances, to apprise interested parties,” which for known creditors means mail. The BowFlex bankruptcy court accepted newspaper notice only because the plaintiffs could not reasonably have been identified. In re Motors Liquidation Co., 829 F.3d 135 (2d Cir. 2016), refused to enforce GM’s sale order against plaintiffs owed mailed notice.

    A taxing authority with an assessment or open audit is plainly known. Bankruptcy Rule 2002(a)(2) requires 21 days’ mailed notice of the sale, and in Chapter 11, Rule 2002(j)(3) adds the IRS. Rule 6004(c) requires serving interest holders with the sale motion, using Rule 7004 service (7004(b)(6) for a state) through Rule 9014. The New Mexico bankruptcy court’s register of governmental addresses lists separate Department addresses for notices and for service of process. Serve both.

    How would the numbers work for an Albuquerque restaurant group?

    Picture a hypothetical Albuquerque restaurant group, one location in Nob Hill, selling its assets in Chapter 11 for $950,000 subject to a $600,000 bank lien. The Department has assessed $180,000 of gross receipts tax with penalty and interest, and the IRS holds a filed junior lien for $60,000 of payroll tax.

    In the clean version, both agencies are served at their register addresses, and the order names §§ 7-1-61 through 7-1-63. After the bank’s $600,000 and the IRS’s $60,000, $290,000 remains. The Department has a priority claim under 11 U.S.C. § 507(a)(8), which covers taxes “on or measured by income or gross receipts,” paid from that cash if administrative costs leave room, or through a plan under § 1129(a)(9)(C) within five years. The buyer owes nothing.

    Now suppose the Department was left off the service list and nobody asked for a clearance. The Department can argue the order never bound it and assess the buyer, and the value ceiling does nothing against $180,000. With no trust account, the buyer pays and then chases the estate.

    What can a buyer do if the Department assesses after closing?

    Prevention is cheaper: a holdback sized to the Department’s figure plus interest, and a sale order naming New Mexico successor liability with an injunction. An inflated assessment can be redetermined under 11 U.S.C. § 505(a), “whether or not previously assessed,” unless a tribunal decided it before the filing.

    Two tracks can run at once. NMSA 1978, § 7-1-24 generally allows a written protest within ninety days of the assessment’s mailing, a state-law step for New Mexico-licensed counsel. The other track returns to the bankruptcy court, which in BowFlex called enforcing its own sale order core, with § 105(a) authorizing orders “necessary or appropriate” to carry out the Code. Section 363(m) protects good-faith buyers on appeal, not missing notice.

    Liability Cut off by § 363(f) order? Notice that matters Buyer’s pre-closing step
    NM successor tax (§§ 7-1-61 to 7-1-63) Likely, as an “interest”; no Tenth Circuit ruling Mail to both D.N.M. register addresses ACD-31096 before closing; holdback; name the statute in the order
    Filed federal tax lien Yes; lien moves to proceeds Rule 2002(j)(3); Rule 6004(c) IRS payoff; lien paid or attached to proceeds
    Trust fund recovery penalty No; runs against responsible persons Not a sale-notice issue Seller’s owners resolve separately
    Pre-closing product liability Often, for unknown claimants with publication notice Mail to known claimants Search recalls and litigation
    Unassumed contract claims Generally, if excluded Rule 2002(a)(2) mailed notice Keep the assumed-liability schedule tight

    Frequently Asked Questions

    Does buying a New Mexico business make me liable for the seller’s gross receipts tax?

    It can. Under NMSA 1978, § 7-1-61, a successor must either hold enough of the purchase price in trust until the Taxation and Revenue Department certifies no tax is due, or pay the seller’s tax on demand. Liability generally caps at the value of the property received, except for continuations or assumed debts.

    How long does the Taxation and Revenue Department have to answer a tax clearance request?

    Under NMSA 1978, § 7-1-62, the Department has thirty days from the written request (longer if the seller’s records reach audit later, but never past sixty) to issue a certificate or mail a notice of tax due. If it misses that deadline, the successor is released.

    Can I request a New Mexico tax clearance after the sale closes?

    Generally no. The instructions to Form ACD-31096, the Department’s Tax Clearance Request, say a request made after the transaction’s effective date will not be processed. A signed purchase agreement must be attached, so the clearance belongs in the pre-closing schedule.

    Does a bankruptcy sale remove an IRS tax lien from the assets I buy?

    Usually, if the IRS is properly served. A sale under 11 U.S.C. § 363(f) can transfer assets free of a federal tax lien, which typically moves to the proceeds. Bankruptcy Rules 2002(j)(3) and 6004(c) require notice to the IRS and service on lienholders.

    Does a 363 sale end the seller’s personal liability for payroll taxes?

    No. The trust fund recovery penalty under 26 U.S.C. § 6672 falls on responsible persons, such as owners and officers who willfully failed to pay over withheld taxes. A sale order protects the buyer and assets, not those individuals, and personal guaranties survive.

    What happens if the Taxation and Revenue Department was not notified of the bankruptcy sale?

    The buyer’s protection is at risk. Due process requires mailed notice to known creditors, and courts have refused to enforce sale orders against parties denied it. A Department holding an assessment or running an audit is known, so it may assess the buyer under NMSA 1978, § 7-1-63 anyway.

    How North Star Law Firm Can Help

    North Star Law Firm advises New Mexico business buyers and sellers on business sale tax structuring, gross receipts tax exposure, and sale motions in Chapter 11, with IRS issues handled through its tax defense practice.

    Phillip Zagotti, JD/CPA, is admitted before the United States District Court and Bankruptcy Court for the District of New Mexico and the United States Tax Court. He is licensed by the State Bar of California and holds a Texas CPA license; he is not licensed by the State Bar of New Mexico, and the firm works alongside New Mexico-licensed counsel on state-law questions. Sellers may also want the firm’s post on a clean sale process. To discuss a deal, contact North Star Law Firm.


  • Bitcoin Hard Fork Taxes: What the Rogovy Tax Court Case Means in New Mexico

    Bitcoin Hard Fork Taxes: What the Rogovy Tax Court Case Means in New Mexico

    On March 18, 2026, Judge Ronald L. Buch of the United States Tax Court denied a motion for partial summary judgment in Docket No. 17513-24, and the motion he turned away was the taxpayers’ own. Benjamin A. Rogovy and Carol J. Castellon Miranda wanted a pretrial ruling that nine Bitcoin hard forks in 2017 and 2018 produced no income.

    The case was tried in Seattle in April 2026, and the final post-trial brief was due September 25. No opinion has issued. For a Santa Fe or Los Alamos holder with Bitcoin in cold storage in 2017, the better questions are whose appellate law governs and whether that year is even open.

    What is actually pending in Rogovy v. Commissioner?

    The notice of deficiency was mailed August 15, 2024. Per the petition and Bloomberg Tax, it determined about $24.5 million in 2017 and 2018 deficiencies with about $4.9 million in penalties, much of it not fork income. Judge Buch’s order puts the fork adjustments at $9,389,527 of S corporation K-1 income and $2,689,298 of other income.

    Contrary to some commentary, petitioners filed the motion, the Commissioner opposed it, and the court denied it because the parties dispute “whether the hard forks were realization events” and whether the couple had complete dominion over the forked coins. Nothing here predicts the outcome.

    How does the IRS apply the dominion and control test to a hard fork?

    26 U.S.C. § 61(a) taxes “all income from whatever source derived,” which Commissioner v. Glenshaw Glass Co., 348 U.S. 426, 431 (1955), read to reach “undeniable accessions to wealth, clearly realized, and over which the taxpayers have complete dominion.” Rev. Rul. 2019-24, 2019-44 I.R.B. 1004, treats an airdrop the holder controls as ordinary income, and a taxpayer “not able to exercise dominion and control” as having no receipt.

    Chief Counsel Advice 202114020 names the August 1, 2017 Bitcoin Cash fork. A holder with sole control of the private key had 2017 income at the fork; an exchange customer whose platform did not yet support the coin had income when support arrived. It is not precedent, but it signals how an examiner will read a cold-storage file.

    Petitioners rely on Treas. Reg. § 1.451-2(a): income is not constructively received when control is “subject to substantial limitations or restrictions.” The order describes experts split on how risky extraction was and a dispute over whether Mr. Rogovy knew of most forks.

    Unreported Crypto or a Digital Asset Notice? Contact Us Now

    Which appellate court’s law would govern a New Mexico holder’s hard fork case?

    Under Golsen v. Commissioner, 54 T.C. 742, 757 (1970), the Tax Court follows the court of appeals to which appeal lies once that court has decided the issue, citing “efficient and harmonious judicial administration.” An individual’s appeal under 26 U.S.C. § 7482(b)(1)(A) goes to the circuit of “the legal residence of the petitioner.” The Rogovy petition lists a Nevada address, which points to the Ninth Circuit. A New Mexico resident goes to the Tenth Circuit, where Golsen itself arose.

    No published Tenth Circuit decision on hard forks or airdrops was located on review. Judge Buch cited Harrington v. Commissioner, T.C. Memo. 2021-95, on substantial barriers to control, and the Tenth Circuit affirmed that case in an unpublished order and judgment, No. 22-9000 (10th Cir. Nov. 30, 2022), that turned on fraud and limitations rather than receipt. A New Mexico petitioner would argue mainly from Supreme Court and Tax Court authority.

    How do valuation and S corporation ownership complicate fork income?

    The IRS virtual currency FAQs assume a price exists: A26 uses what an exchange records, and A28 uses the value of what was given up, which for a fork recipient is nothing. The Bitcoin Cash memorandum accepts “any reasonable method,” but for thin forks in Rogovy like Bitcoin God the number can swing with the venue and hour chosen. Wallet logs and the date keys were first loaded into fork-capable software pick the year, and the year picks the price.

    26 U.S.C. § 1366 passes S corporation income to shareholders with its character kept “as if such item were realized directly from the source.” It cannot say who received the coins. The petition says Mr. Rogovy treated them as personal; the IRS treated his Bitcoin as property of Velorum, Inc., his S corporation, and the order notes some purchases ran through Velorum’s bank account. A New Mexico owner whose entity bought Bitcoin should expect the paper trail to matter.

    How do the penalty and limitations rules apply to 2017 and 2018 forks?

    Section 6662(a) adds 20 percent for a substantial understatement under § 6662(b)(2), which § 6662(d)(1)(A) sets for individuals at the greater of 10 percent of the correct tax or $5,000. The defense is reasonable cause under § 6664(c)(1), and Treas. Reg. § 1.6664-4(b)(1) credits “an honest misunderstanding of fact or law.” Chronology helps: Notice 2014-21 said nothing about forks, and Rev. Rul. 2019-24 arrived in October 2019, after every fork in the case.

    Section 6501(a) allows three years from filing, six under § 6501(e)(1)(A) if omitted gross income tops 25 percent of the amount stated, and longer with written consents under § 6501(c)(4). The petition says the couple signed two extensions and contests both periods. Once a petition is docketed, § 6503(a)(1) suspends assessment until the decision is final, plus 60 days.

    What would a 2017 fork look like for a Santa Fe couple today?

    Assume a Santa Fe couple held 40 BTC in a hardware wallet on August 1, 2017, with $200,000 of joint taxable income before the fork. At a hypothetical $500 per Bitcoin Cash, the fork adds $20,000 of ordinary income. Rev. Proc. 2016-55 taxed 2017 joint income between $153,100 and $233,350 at 28 percent, so the added tax is $5,600. Correct tax is $48,484.50, so the $5,000 floor governs, and $5,600 clears it for a $1,120 penalty plus interest. At $300 a coin the understatement is $3,360, under the floor.

    New Mexico follows: NMSA 1978 § 7-2-2 builds base income from federal adjusted gross income, so fork income reaches the PIT-1, and NMSA 1978 § 7-1-13(E) requires a federal adjustments report within 180 days after a final determination.

    Still, a 2017 return filed in April 2018 ordinarily closed in 2021, or 2024 under the six-year rule, absent consents or fraud. The live exposure is a later sale. Form 1099-DA reports gross proceeds for sales on or after January 1, 2025, and basis for certain transactions from January 1, 2026, per an IRS fact sheet. FAQ A25 ties basis to the amount included in income, awkward for a couple who reported nothing. The Form 1040 digital asset question counts a hard fork airdrop as a yes.

    An honest mistake in an open year calls for an amended return; the Voluntary Disclosure Practice is for people who “have willfully failed to comply,” and it is mid-redesign, as the firm’s post on the redesign and New Mexico’s managed audit explains.

    Glenshaw Glass element IRS position Taxpayers’ position (per the order) New Mexico holder’s proof problem
    Accession to wealth New coins with market value are income (Rev. Rul. 2019-24; CCA 202114020) Not raised in the motion Showing no real buyer existed
    Clearly realized Receiving a spendable new asset is realization No conversion event; Bitcoin interest unchanged Proving nothing moved that year
    Complete dominion Actual and constructive receipt; risk was limited Substantial risk and no notice of most forks Proof of key custody and what the holder knew
    Year of receipt Fork date for a holder controlling the keys Unclaimed coins were never received Wallet logs and key-import dates
    Amount Fair market value by any reasonable method Values disputed in the petition Defending a price source

    Frequently Asked Questions

    Do I owe tax on a Bitcoin hard fork if I never claimed the new coins?

    The IRS says a fork alone is not income, but new coins you control are ordinary income at fair market value. Its 2021 Chief Counsel Advice treats a 2017 Bitcoin Cash holder who alone controlled the private key as receiving coins at the fork. The pending Rogovy case tests that view.

    Who moved for summary judgment in Rogovy v. Commissioner?

    The taxpayers did. Benjamin Rogovy and Carol Castellon Miranda sought partial summary judgment in Tax Court Docket No. 17513-24, arguing nine hard forks produced no income. Judge Ronald L. Buch denied it on March 18, 2026, citing factual disputes. The case remains pending after an April 2026 trial.

    Would a Rogovy decision control a New Mexico taxpayer’s case?

    Not automatically. Under Golsen v. Commissioner, the Tax Court follows the court of appeals where an appeal would lie, which for an individual is the circuit of legal residence. A New Mexico resident appeals to the Tenth Circuit, where no published hard fork decision was located.

    Does unreported fork income affect my New Mexico income tax?

    Generally, yes. New Mexico’s personal income tax starts from federal adjusted gross income under NMSA 1978 § 7-2-2, so federal fork income flows to the state return, and NMSA 1978 § 7-1-13 requires a report within 180 days of a final IRS adjustment. State-law questions go to New Mexico-licensed counsel.

    Can the IRS still assess tax on a 2017 hard fork in 2026?

    Usually not. The normal period is three years from filing, or six when omitted gross income exceeds 25 percent of the gross income reported. Written consents or a fraudulent return extend it, and a Tax Court petition suspends the period while the case runs.

    Will Form 1099-DA show my forked coins?

    Only when you sell them through a broker. Brokers report gross proceeds on Form 1099-DA for digital asset sales on or after January 1, 2025, and basis for certain transactions on or after January 1, 2026. The form does not report the fork, and basis in forked coins equals the amount included in income.

    How North Star Law Firm Can Help

    North Star Law Firm represents New Mexico taxpayers in IRS audit defense over digital asset adjustments, in Tax Court litigation, and in penalty abatement requests, as part of its tax defense practice.

    Phillip Zagotti is an Attorney and CPA admitted to practice before the Internal Revenue Service and the United States Tax Court. He is licensed by the State Bar of California and holds a Texas CPA license; he is not licensed by the State Bar of New Mexico, and the firm works alongside New Mexico-licensed counsel on state-law questions. On forum, see the firm’s guide to choosing between the Tax Court and a refund suit. To discuss unreported crypto income or an IRS notice, contact North Star Law Firm.


  • Where a New Mexico Taxpayer Fights the IRS: Tax Court, Refund Suit, or Bankruptcy Court

    Where a New Mexico Taxpayer Fights the IRS: Tax Court, Refund Suit, or Bankruptcy Court

    The mailing date on a notice of deficiency matters first. A taxpayer in Roswell or Las Cruces then has 90 days to petition the United States Tax Court, or 150 days if the notice is addressed to a person outside the United States. 26 U.S.C. § 6213(a). That window is also when a New Mexico taxpayer picks a courtroom, because four federal forums can decide a federal tax liability, and they differ on prepayment, juries, speed and appellate precedent. Once a petition goes in, § 6512(a) all but closes off a refund suit for that year.

    What does the 90-day clock on a notice of deficiency actually control?

    Section 6213(a) does two jobs. It sets the window, and it freezes the government: no assessment and “no levy or proceeding in court for its collection” until the period has run and, if a petition is filed, the Tax Court’s decision is final. That freeze makes the Tax Court the default forum: nothing has to be paid to get in, the fee is $60, and petitions go through DAWSON. The cost of that door is the others.

    Where does a New Mexico taxpayer actually try a Tax Court case?

    The Tax Court lists Albuquerque among its trial locations, noting: “No permanent courtroom. See notice of trial for address.” A petitioner names a city on Form 5, and sessions are uneven. The Spring 2026 term calendared an Albuquerque session for the week of April 6, 2026, marked hybrid; the Fall 2026 forecast for September 7 through December 14, 2026 lists 26 places of trial without Albuquerque, though “REMOTE (Virtual)” appears.

    Small tax case treatment under § 7463 is available when $50,000 or less is in dispute for any one taxable year, and the trade is finality: such a decision “shall not be reviewed in any other court.” Who may appear turns on the court’s own bar: Tax Court Rule 200 asks an attorney applicant for a certificate of good standing from the highest court of any state.

    What does paying first buy in a refund suit in D.N.M. or the Court of Federal Claims?

    A refund suit runs in reverse. In Flora v. United States, 362 U.S. 145 (1960), the Supreme Court read 28 U.S.C. § 1346(a)(1) to require “full payment of the assessment before an income tax refund suit can be maintained.” Section 7422(a) bars suit until a claim has been duly filed, the claim must be timely under § 6511(a), and § 6532(a)(1) blocks suit for six months unless it is disallowed sooner, then bars it two years after a disallowance.

    Prepayment buys a jury. The Court of Federal Claims shares that jurisdiction under 28 U.S.C. § 1491(a)(1), but only the district court seats one: 28 U.S.C. § 2402 makes a § 1346(a)(1) action triable “by the court with a jury” at either party’s request. That trial runs in the District of New Mexico, at the Pete V. Domenici U.S. Courthouse in Albuquerque, with Justice Department Tax Division trial attorneys opposite instead of IRS Chief Counsel.

    Received a Notice of Deficiency in New Mexico? Contact Us Now

    When can a bankruptcy court decide the tax, and what does a CDP hearing add?

    A fourth door opens in bankruptcy. Under 11 U.S.C. § 505(a)(1) the court may determine the amount or legality of a tax, fine or penalty “whether or not previously assessed, whether or not paid,” and whether or not previously adjudicated, in chapters 7, 11, 12 and 13 by way of § 103(a). Section 505(a)(2)(A) withholds it where the amount was already adjudicated before filing, § 505(a)(2)(B) delays refund determinations for up to 120 days, and § 505(b) covers taxes the estate incurs.

    The collection due process route is narrower. Section 6330 gives 30 days to request a hearing and another 30 to petition the Tax Court, but the liability can be contested only where the taxpayer got no notice of deficiency and no earlier chance to dispute it.

    Where does the appeal go, and why does the Tenth Circuit matter before trial?

    Venue follows the taxpayer under § 7482(b)(1): an individual’s legal residence, an entity’s principal place of business. For New Mexico that is the Tenth Circuit in Denver. “The Tax Court’s legal conclusions are subject to de novo review, and its factual findings can be set aside only if clearly erroneous.” Petersen v. Commissioner, 924 F.3d 1111, 1114 (10th Cir. 2019). A Court of Federal Claims case goes to the Federal Circuit, 28 U.S.C. § 1295(a)(3).

    That map matters before filing. Under Golsen v. Commissioner, 54 T.C. 742 (1970), where the court of appeals to which appeal lies “has already passed upon the issue before us, efficient and harmonious judicial administration calls for us to follow the decision of that court.” Fed. R. App. P. 13(a)(1)(A) allows 90 days to appeal after entry of the decision, and appealing does not stop collection without the § 7485(a) bond, “not exceeding double” the appealed deficiency.

    What happens on the New Mexico side of the same dispute?

    State tax disputes run separately. NMSA 1978 § 7-1-24 allows 90 days to protest an assessment of tax over $50, heard by the Administrative Hearings Office under the Administrative Hearings Office Act, not by the Taxation and Revenue Department, with appeal to the New Mexico Court of Appeals within 30 days of the decision. NMSA 1978 § 7-1-25. The federal result loops back: § 7-1-13 calls for a federal adjustments report within 180 days of the final determination date. See also the firm’s gross receipts tax audit guide.

    How does this play out for a Roswell dairy owner, and who computes the number?

    Take a hypothetical. A dairy owner outside Roswell gets a notice of deficiency mailed October 5, 2026 for tax year 2023: $68,000 plus the § 6662(a) accuracy-related penalty, “20 percent of the portion of the underpayment,” or $13,600. The 90th day is Sunday, January 3, 2027, so § 7503 moves it to Monday, January 4. An S case is off the table above $50,000. Interest has run since the 2023 return came due, § 6601(a), at the 7 percent IRS rate compounded daily for the quarter beginning October 1, 2026, about $1,400 a quarter. A deposit under § 6603 stops that meter without conceding the case.

    Paying the $81,600 plus interest, filing a claim, waiting six months and suing in the District of New Mexico buys a jury, at the cost of $95,000 the herd may need more. If the dairy is already in a Chapter 11 or Chapter 12 case, the bankruptcy court reaches the same figures under § 505(a)(1) with no prepayment.

    Tax Court Rule 91(a)(1) requires the parties to stipulate “to the fullest extent” fairly reachable, and a stipulation is a conclusive admission, so it gets built from milk checks, feed invoices and depreciation schedules, while the administrative file and the Appeals officer’s workpapers show what the government already accepts. After the opinion, Rule 155 confines each side’s computation “strictly to consideration of the correct computation.” Section 7491 can shift the burden of proof where the taxpayer offers credible evidence and has cooperated, and § 7430 caps cost recovery by the 28 U.S.C. § 2412(d)(2)(B) net worth limits, $2,000,000 for individuals and $7,000,000 for businesses.

    Forum Pay first? Fact finder Key deadline Appeal to
    Tax Court deficiency No Judge 90 days, 150 if abroad Tenth Circuit
    D.N.M. refund suit Yes, in full Jury if asked Two years from disallowance Tenth Circuit
    Federal Claims Yes, in full Judge § 6532(a)(1) window Federal Circuit
    Bankruptcy § 505 No Judge Subject to § 505(a)(2) District court, BAP
    Tax Court CDP No Judge 30 days to petition Tenth Circuit

    Frequently Asked Questions

    How long does a New Mexico taxpayer have to file a Tax Court petition?

    Under 26 U.S.C. § 6213(a) the petition is due within 90 days after the notice of deficiency is mailed, or 150 days if the notice is addressed to a person outside the United States. Assessment and levy are barred while it runs.

    Does the Tax Court hold trial sessions in Albuquerque?

    Albuquerque is a listed Tax Court trial location with no permanent courtroom, so the notice of trial gives the address. The Spring 2026 term listed an Albuquerque session for the week of April 6, 2026 as hybrid; the Fall 2026 forecast omits it.

    Do I have to pay the tax before filing an IRS refund lawsuit in New Mexico?

    Yes. In Flora v. United States, 362 U.S. 145 (1960), the Supreme Court held that 28 U.S.C. § 1346(a)(1) requires full payment of the assessment before a refund suit can proceed in district court. A refund claim comes first under § 7422(a).

    Can a taxpayer get a jury in a federal tax case?

    Only in a district court refund suit. Tax Court and Court of Federal Claims trials are before a judge. Under 28 U.S.C. § 2402, a section 1346(a)(1) action against the United States is tried with a jury on either party’s request.

    Can a bankruptcy court determine how much a debtor owes the IRS?

    Often, yes. Under 11 U.S.C. § 505(a)(1) the court may determine the amount or legality of any tax, fine or penalty, whether or not previously assessed, paid or contested. Section 505(a)(2)(A) withholds that power if the matter was adjudicated before filing.

    Where does a Tenth Circuit tax appeal come from, and what is the deadline?

    For an individual, 26 U.S.C. § 7482(b)(1) sends review of a Tax Court decision to the circuit of the taxpayer’s legal residence, the Tenth Circuit for New Mexico. Fed. R. App. P. 13(a)(1)(A) allows 90 days from entry of the decision.

    How North Star Law Firm Can Help

    North Star Law Firm handles federal tax controversy for New Mexico taxpayers and businesses, from examination through appeal: IRS audit defense, IRS Appeals and collection due process hearings, and United States Tax Court litigation, including the forum analysis that belongs inside the 90-day petition window. The broader tax defense practice covers liens, levies, penalties and collection alternatives.

    Phillip Zagotti is an Attorney and CPA admitted to practice before the Internal Revenue Service and the United States Tax Court. He is licensed by the State Bar of California and holds a Texas CPA license; he is not licensed by the State Bar of New Mexico, and the firm works alongside New Mexico-licensed counsel on state-law questions. Also see the firm’s post on the 2026 Ways and Means tax administration bills. To discuss a notice of deficiency or which forum fits a dispute, contact North Star Law Firm.