Category: Tax Defense

  • Texas or Colorado Common Law Marriage After a Move to New Mexico: Taxes and Bankruptcy

    Texas or Colorado Common Law Marriage After a Move to New Mexico: Taxes and Bankruptcy

    Brenda and Clay lived as husband and wife in Muleshoe, Texas, from 2015 to 2022, signing a lease and insurance forms there as spouses, though they never had a ceremony. In 2022 they moved to Portales. Since then Brenda, a school district employee with $58,000 in W-2 wages, has filed as head of household with her daughter. Clay hauls hay, nets about $74,000, files as single, and owes the IRS about $41,000 for 2022 through 2024. A neighbor told them New Mexico “has no common law marriage,” so after eleven years together they are single here.

    Brenda and Clay are fictional, and their neighbor is half right. New Mexico will not let a couple become married by living together here, but it honors a marriage valid where it was made, and it is a community property state. That produces two opposite tax mistakes.

    Does New Mexico recognize a common law marriage from Texas or Colorado?

    Yes, if the marriage was valid where it was formed. Marriage here is a civil contract under NMSA 1978, § 40-1-1, and requires a county clerk’s license under § 40-1-10. In re Gabaldon’s Estate, 38 N.M. 392, 34 P.2d 672 (1934) held that no common law marriage can be formed in this state. But § 40-1-4 makes marriages celebrated elsewhere valid here if they were valid where celebrated.

    The New Mexico Supreme Court applied that rule to a Texas informal marriage in Gallegos v. Wilkerson, 79 N.M. 549, 445 P.2d 970 (1968), where the couple lived in El Paso and held themselves out as spouses. In In re Estate of Lamb, 99 N.M. 157, 655 P.2d 1001 (1982), by contrast, repeating vows during a day or two at an El Paso hotel was not enough contact with Texas.

    Texas Family Code § 2.401(a)(2) looks for an agreement to be married, living together in Texas as spouses, and representing to others in Texas that they were married. Colorado asks whether the couple mutually agreed to enter marriage and then acted on it, under In re Marriage of Hogsett & Neale, 2021 CO 1. Whether a couple qualifies is a question for counsel in that state; if they do, the marriage lasts until divorce, annulment or death.

    Is a Texas informal marriage still a marriage for IRS filing status in New Mexico?

    Yes. Treas. Reg. § 301.7701-18(b)(1) recognizes a marriage for federal tax purposes if the state where it was entered into recognizes it, “regardless of domicile.” The IRS took that position for common law marriages in Rev. Rul. 58-66, as described in Rev. Rul. 2013-17, even after a move to a state that requires a ceremony.

    Marital status is fixed on the last day of the year under 26 U.S.C. § 7703(a)(1). Head of household under § 2(b)(1) requires that the filer be “not married at the close of his taxable year,” and § 7703(b) treats a married parent as unmarried only if the other spouse was out of the household for the last six months of the year. Clay lives in the house, so their real choices were always joint or separate.

    How does married filing separately work with community property in New Mexico?

    Under NMSA 1978, § 40-3-8(B), community property is property acquired by either or both spouses during marriage that is not separate property, and § 40-3-12(A) presumes property acquired during marriage is community. Federal tax follows that ownership: Poe v. Seaborn, 282 U.S. 101 (1930) let Washington spouses each report half of their community income.

    IRS Publication 555 (Rev. December 2024) counts wages earned during the marriage in New Mexico or Texas as community income and requires each spouse filing separately to report half of all community income plus all separate income, with Form 8958 attached. Each spouse also claims half the tax withheld from community wages. Self-employment tax does not split; under § 1402(a)(5)(A) it follows the spouse carrying on the business.

    Not knowing is a weak defense. In United States v. Mitchell, 403 U.S. 190 (1971), wives who knew little about the community income owed tax on their half. The relief lies in § 66(c) for separate filers and § 6015 for joint filers. How far the IRS can reach community assets for one spouse’s debt is covered in our post on community property and IRS tax debt in New Mexico.

    What does the wrong filing status cost in an illustrative Portales example?

    Take tax year 2025, with the 2025 standard deductions after the 2025 tax act ($15,750 single or separate, $31,500 joint, $23,625 head of household) and the 2025 brackets in Rev. Proc. 2024-40. I ignore credits and other deductions except the deduction for half of Clay’s self-employment tax (the tax itself is about $10,460 in every version).

    As filed, Brenda’s income tax is about $3,790 and Clay’s about $6,580, roughly $10,360 together. Jointly, it is about $10,960. Separately with the community split, each reports $29,000 of her wages and $37,000 of his profit; her tax is about $5,970 and his about $5,160, roughly $11,130.

    The correct status costs roughly $600 to $800 a year, because head of household brackets were never theirs. The bigger change is whose name the tax sits under: separately, Brenda’s share rises by more than half. An underpayment from the wrong status can also draw the 20 percent accuracy penalty in § 6662(a) if the IRS shows negligence.

    Cleanup has clocks. The IRS has three years after filing to assess under § 6501(a), with a parallel refund window in § 6511(a). Section 6013(b) lets spouses who filed married filing separately switch to a joint return, but under § 6013(b)(2)(A) not more than three years after the original due date. Brenda and Clay filed as head of household and single. The Eighth Circuit in Ibrahim v. Commissioner, 788 F.3d 834 (8th Cir. 2015) and the Tax Court in Camara v. Commissioner, 149 T.C. No. 13 (2017), held that a return wrongly claiming one of those statuses is not a “separate return,” so that bar did not apply; the IRS argued the opposite in both cases, and I found no Tenth Circuit decision on those facts. Electing joint is not automatic: § 6013(d)(3) makes joint filers jointly and severally liable, putting Brenda on the hook for Clay’s unpaid tax for those years.

    We only ever lived together in New Mexico. Can we file a joint return?

    No, however long you have been together. Merrill v. Davis, 100 N.M. 552, 673 P.2d 1285 (1983) refused to read cohabitation as an implied agreement to share property. Unmarried partners have no community property and no income splitting.

    Section 6013(a) lets only a husband and wife file jointly. A “joint” return signed by two unmarried people is not a valid joint return; each owes tax on his or her own income, and the joint and several liability of § 6013(d)(3) should not attach. I rest on the statute here; I found no opinion on these facts. A partner keeping a home for his or her own qualifying child may file as head of household.

    Can an unmarried New Mexico couple file a joint bankruptcy petition?

    No. 11 U.S.C. § 302(a) allows a joint case only for an individual “and such individual’s spouse,” and the Albuquerque bankruptcy court looked to state law on that question in In re Cohen, No. 7-10-15616 JR (Bankr. D.N.M. Feb. 7, 2012). I found no Tenth Circuit or Tenth Circuit BAP decision on a debtor claiming a common law spouse. Unmarried partners need two cases, each with $338 in Chapter 7 filing fees (28 U.S.C. § 1930(a)(1)(A) and the Bankruptcy Court Miscellaneous Fee Schedule effective December 1, 2023).

    If Clay files alone, § 541(a)(2) brings community property under his management or liable for his debts into his estate. In exchange, § 524(a)(3) protects later acquired community property from discharged community claims, subject to § 524(b) and to debts that are not discharged. His IRS debt turns on the three year, two year and 240 day rules in § 507(a)(8)(A) and § 523(a)(1). Late returns matter: in Mallo v. IRS, 774 F.3d 1313 (10th Cir. 2014), a Form 1040 filed after the IRS assessed the tax was not a “return,” and the debt survived. See our post on the automatic stay and the spouse who did not file.

    Couple Married for federal tax? Community property here; return options Joint bankruptcy petition?
    Informally married in Texas, moved here Yes, if valid in Texas Yes; joint, or separate with half each Yes
    Common law married in Colorado, moved here Yes, if valid in Colorado Yes; joint, or separate with half each Yes
    Lived together only in New Mexico No No; each files on own income No; two cases
    Ceremonially married anywhere Yes Yes; joint or separate Yes

    Frequently Asked Questions

    We were common law married in Texas. Can I file head of household in New Mexico?

    Usually not. You must be unmarried on December 31, and a married parent counts as unmarried only if the other spouse lived elsewhere for the last six months.

    Do I report half of my spouse’s income on a separate return?

    If you are married and domiciled in New Mexico, generally yes. Each spouse reports half of the community income and all separate income, with Form 8958 showing the split.

    Does New Mexico recognize common law marriage?

    A couple cannot form one here, but New Mexico recognizes one validly formed in another state.

    Can we switch from separate returns to a joint return later?

    If you filed married filing separately, often yes, within three years after the original due date, unless a Tax Court petition, refund suit, closing agreement or compromise cuts it off. A joint return makes both spouses liable for the full tax for that year.

    Does leaving Texas start the two year clock on a Texas informal marriage?

    No. The presumption in Family Code § 2.401(b) runs from when the couple separated and stopped living together, not from a move together.

    How North Star Law Firm Can Help

    North Star Law Firm helps New Mexico couples whose out of state marriage never made it onto their returns, including unfiled or incorrect returns, innocent spouse relief, broader IRS tax defense and, where the numbers call for it, Chapter 7.

    Phillip Zagotti, JD/CPA, represents taxpayers before the IRS and the U.S. Tax Court and is admitted to the U.S. District Court and Bankruptcy Court for the District of New Mexico. The firm works alongside New Mexico-licensed counsel on state-law questions. If you moved here from Texas or Colorado as a couple and have been filing as single, contact North Star Law Firm.


  • The IRS Changed Your Return and New Mexico Followed: Where the Fight Belongs

    The IRS Changed Your Return and New Mexico Followed: Where the Fight Belongs

    Celeste makes silver and turquoise jewelry in Socorro and sells it at weekend markets and through an online marketplace. For 2023 her payment processor issued a Form 1099-K showing $61,400 in gross payments, while her return reported $18,000 of Schedule C gross receipts and no expenses. A CP2000 notice arrived in 2025 and went into a drawer, and the IRS assessed the tax. In October 2026 the New Mexico Taxation and Revenue Department (TRD) sent a notice assessing personal income tax on the same increase, and a second letter asked about gross receipts tax.

    Celeste is fictional. The instinct to fight the state letter first is usually backward.

    The IRS changed my return. Why is New Mexico assessing me too?

    Under 26 U.S.C. § 6103(d), the IRS may share return information with a state tax agency that asks in writing. New Mexico’s income tax is built on federal adjusted gross income: “base income” in NMSA 1978, § 7-2-2 begins with adjusted gross income plus listed additions. Raise the AGI and the state number rises.

    Under NMSA 1978, § 7-1-13(E), a taxpayer must file a “federal adjustments report” and pay the resulting state tax within 180 days after the final determination date. For IRS action, that is generally the first day nothing remains open, with appeal rights waived or exhausted. Most people I see never file it, and TRD assesses instead.

    Should I fight the TRD assessment or the IRS adjustment?

    Both, but the IRS number usually decides it. A New Mexico assessment “is presumed to be correct” under NMSA 1978, § 7-1-17(C). The Administrative Hearings Office, which hears protests under NMSA 1978, § 7-1B-1 et seq., says in its tax protest FAQ that a taxpayer must offer evidence beyond unsubstantiated statements. When TRD’s figure mirrors a final federal figure, the best proof it is wrong is a corrected federal figure.

    California shows the alternative. In Appeal of G. Barraza, 2025-OTA-663 (Cal. Off. Tax App. Apr. 25, 2025) (nonprecedential), the taxpayer’s Tax Court petition had been dismissed for lack of jurisdiction and the IRS apparently never acted on his amended return; arguing expenses to the state with the federal assessment standing, he lost most of the case. A New Mexico protest saying only “the IRS was wrong,” without the federal correction in hand, has the same problem.

    Got an IRS or TRD Notice? Contact Us

    I ignored the CP2000 notice. What federal options are left?

    IRS Topic 652 describes the CP2000 as a proposal, not a bill, with 30 days to respond; silence brings a statutory notice of deficiency under § 6212. Under § 6213(a) you then have 90 days to petition the Tax Court, and the IRS cannot assess until that time passes. If you are inside those 90 days, petition; our post on the Tax Court 90 day deadline covers the traps.

    Once the tax is assessed, the main door is audit reconsideration. IRM 4.13.1 (rev. Dec. 10, 2025) requires a filed return, an unpaid assessment, and information the IRS has not considered. A taxpayer turned down can ask for Appeals review or pay and file a refund claim, and the IRM describes no Tax Court review of the denial.

    If you pay instead, under § 6511(a) a refund claim is due within three years from filing the return or two years from payment, whichever is later, and § 7422(a) requires that claim before any refund suit. At a collection due process hearing you may contest the liability itself only if you did not receive a notice of deficiency or otherwise have a chance to dispute it, under § 6330(c)(2)(B). The July 2026 Form 656-L (doubt as to liability offers) tells people disputing unreported income adjustments not to use it.

    Is the full Form 1099-K amount taxable income?

    No. The IRS page on what to do with Form 1099-K says the gross payment amount “isn’t adjusted for any” fees, credits, refunds, shipping, cash equivalents or discounts. Schedule C then subtracts returns and cost of goods sold. The assessment Celeste ignored taxed every dollar the processor touched.

    In a court proceeding, § 6201(d) puts on the IRS the burden of producing reasonable and probative information beyond the information return, once the taxpayer raises a reasonable dispute and has fully cooperated. The Tenth Circuit holds that “some reasonable foundation” is needed to keep a deficiency presumptively correct, Erickson v. Commissioner, 937 F.2d 1548 (10th Cir. 1991), though a 1099-K in your name usually supplies one. See our bank deposits post on that presumption.

    An illustrative reconstruction for Celeste assumes she is single with $30,000 of wages and sets aside the qualified business income deduction and credits. From the $61,400 gross, she documents $2,900 of refunds, $7,400 of marketplace and processing fees, $1,800 of tax the marketplace collected inside the gross, $2,700 of postage, $16,500 of silver, stones and findings, and $1,600 of booth fees and supplies. Her corrected Schedule C net is $28,500 against the $18,000 she reported.

    Using the 2023 brackets and $13,850 standard deduction in Rev. Proc. 2022-38, plus self-employment tax of 15.3 percent on 92.35 percent of net earnings (§ 1401; § 1402(a)(12)), the unreduced $43,400 increase costs about $7,689 of income tax and $6,132 of self-employment tax, or $13,821. That clears the $5,000 substantial understatement floor, so § 6662 adds a 20 percent penalty of about $2,764. The corrected increase is about $2,655, under the floor. New Mexico’s 2023 single schedule in NMSA 1978, § 7-2-7 (rates before 2025) yields roughly $1,976 of added tax on the IRS version and $478 on the corrected one.

    Can a Schedule C change bring a gross receipts tax inquiry too?

    It can. TRD compares federal Schedule C figures with gross receipts tax filings; in In re Marduk Consultants, Decision and Order No. 20-13 (N.M. Admin. Hearings Office Sept. 9, 2020), the Department compared the federal form to the CRS-1 returns and found they did not match.

    Selling at New Mexico markets is “engaging in business,” defined in NMSA 1978, § 7-9-3.3 as carrying on any activity, and § 7-9-4 taxes that privilege at a state rate of 4.875 percent since July 1, 2023, plus local rates. TRD’s FYI-206 explains that a marketplace provider reports receipts from the sales it facilitates, and § 7-9-117 lets the seller deduct those receipts with documentation that the provider is registered and paying. So the federal gross can overstate her gross receipts tax base too, at least for her marketplace sales. Our gross receipts tax audit guide covers that side.

    What New Mexico deadlines run while the IRS number is reopened?

    NMSA 1978, § 7-1-24(E) requires a written protest within 90 days after the notice of assessment is mailed; I found no provision letting TRD extend it, and the older regulation, 3.1.7.11 NMAC, calls the 90 day outer limit jurisdictional. Celeste’s notice is dated October 20, 2026. If mailed that day, day 90 is Monday, January 18, 2027, Martin Luther King Jr. Day, a legal holiday under NMSA 1978, § 12-5-2. NMSA 1978, § 12-2A-7(F) should move a deadline that lands on a holiday to the next day, Tuesday, January 19, 2027. TRD may not agree, so the safer reading treats January 18 as the deadline. TRD’s Protest Office page warns that protesting and paying then claiming a refund are alternative remedies.

    Section 7-1-18(E) lets TRD assess tax from a federal adjustment until three years after the end of the year the report was required. If the IRS later abates, § 7-1-26(F)(1)(c) allows a state refund claim until three years after the end of the calendar year in which that net negative federal adjustment becomes final. Interest runs at the federal underpayment rate under § 7-1-67, which TRD lists as 7 percent for July 1 through December 31, 2026, and the negligence penalty under § 7-1-69 is 2 percent a month, capped at 20 percent.

    The usual sequence, with New Mexico counsel on the state side: a timely protest holds the place, the federal reconsideration goes in with the reconstruction attached, and TRD gets the IRS abatement when it comes.

    Notice in hand Deadline Where it goes and who must prove what Effect on the other government’s number
    CP2000 still open Response date on the notice (30 days, Topic 652) IRS; you document the gross Nothing final; no state report due
    Notice of deficiency 90 days to petition, § 6213(a) Tax Court; § 6201(d) can shift production to the IRS Its outcome fixes the final determination date for the 180 day report
    Federal tax already assessed None for reconsideration; § 6511 for refunds Reconsideration, then refund claim; on you An abatement opens a § 7-1-26 state refund claim
    TRD notice of assessment 90 days from mailing, § 7-1-24(E) TRD protest, Administrative Hearings Office; presumed correct None; it follows the federal result

    Frequently Asked Questions

    Do I have to report an IRS change to New Mexico?

    Yes. Section 7-1-13(E) requires a federal adjustments report and payment within 180 days after the final determination date.

    Can I protest the TRD assessment just because I am fighting the IRS?

    Yes. A protest filed within the 90 days keeps the state dispute alive while the federal number is reopened, but a pending federal dispute with no reconstruction behind it is a thin ground.

    Is audit reconsideration available after a CP2000 assessment?

    Yes, if the assessment is unpaid and you have information the IRS has not seen. It goes to the campus that issued the CP2000, and approval is discretionary.

    What if I already paid the IRS?

    Then the path is generally a refund claim under § 6511, due within three years of filing or two years of payment. A refund suit under § 7422 can follow.

    Does the 1099-K threshold matter for 2023?

    The IRS says the 2025 tax act retroactively reinstated the threshold of more than $20,000 and more than 200 transactions (IR-2025-107). Celeste’s $61,400 clears the dollar test regardless.

    Will the gross receipts tax letter follow the income tax result?

    Not automatically. It turns on New Mexico receipts and deductions such as the marketplace seller deduction, so it needs its own response.

    How North Star Law Firm Can Help

    North Star Law Firm reopens the federal numbers behind state assessments through IRS audit defense and audit reconsideration, IRS appeals and CDP hearings, and Tax Court litigation, and rebuilds Schedule C records that also answer gross receipts tax questions.

    Phillip Zagotti, JD/CPA, represents taxpayers before the IRS and the U.S. Tax Court and is admitted to the U.S. District Court and Bankruptcy Court for the District of New Mexico. The firm works alongside New Mexico-licensed counsel on state-law questions. If an IRS change has turned into a TRD notice with a 90 day clock, contact North Star Law Firm.


  • Out of State Witness for a New Mexico Tax Court Trial: Subpoenas, Zoomgov and Kirkland

    Out of State Witness for a New Mexico Tax Court Trial: Subpoenas, Zoomgov and Kirkland

    Yolanda runs a chile processing and packing business in Deming as a sole proprietor. The IRS disallowed about $310,000 of her 2022 and 2023 cost of goods sold and contract labor and sent a notice of deficiency. Her Tax Court case is set for the Albuquerque trial session in spring 2027. The one person who can explain her books, her former bookkeeper, moved to Tucson in 2025 and will not come back voluntarily.

    Then a Chapter 7 trustee served Yolanda, a nonparty, with a subpoena from the bankruptcy court in El Paso for her purchase records from a failed produce broker and for testimony “by videoconference” at an adversary trial. Yolanda is fictional. Both problems are common, and they run on different rules.

    Listen to this post

    North Star Tax and Legal Briefing: Out of State Witness for a New Mexico Tax Court Trial: Subpoenas, Zoomgov and Kirkland

    Your Tax Court trial is in Albuquerque and the witness who can explain your books moved out of state. This five minute briefing covers the nationwide Tax Court subpoena, why video testimony is the harder ask, the deadlines that come first, and how to prove your case with records.

    Download the MP3 · Episode page on Podbean

    Show / hide the episode transcript

    Your Tax Court trial is set for Albuquerque, and the one witness who can explain your books now lives in Arizona and will not come back. Most New Mexico business owners assume that ends it, because they have heard a federal subpoena only reaches one hundred miles. In Tax Court, that assumption is wrong. Call her Yolanda. She is fictional, but her problem is not. She runs a chile packing business in Deming, the I R S disallowed about three hundred ten thousand dollars of her costs, and her former bookkeeper moved to Tucson. Reaching that bookkeeper turns out to be the easy part. The hard part is something else.

    Start with the distinction that matters. In an ordinary federal lawsuit, and in bankruptcy court, a subpoena generally cannot pull a witness more than one hundred miles from where she lives, works, or regularly does business in person. The Tax Court does not use that rule. It has its own subpoena rule, backed by a statute that lets the court require witnesses to appear from any place in the United States. The clerk issues the subpoena signed but otherwise blank, the party fills it in, and it can be served anywhere in the country. So a process server in Tucson can hand the bookkeeper a subpoena for Albuquerque, as long as the server tenders one day’s witness fee, which is forty dollars, plus mileage. Getting her served is one question. Getting her testimony in front of the judge is a second, separate question.

    Here is how that second question works. Tax Court testimony generally must be taken in open court. The judge may allow video, but only for good cause, in compelling circumstances, with appropriate safeguards. The court’s default is still a trial in person, so plan for a no. A witness who simply prefers to stay in Arizona makes a thin showing. A served subpoena, a written refusal, and a short examination confined to records make a better one.

    You may have heard about the Kirkland case. A federal appeals court on the West Coast threw out subpoenas ordering two distant witnesses to testify by video in a bankruptcy trial, because the one hundred mile limit still applies to a witness on a screen. A rule change answering that decision cannot take effect before December first, two thousand twenty seven. None of it touches the Tax Court’s subpoena rule.

    The picture changes in bankruptcy court. Suppose a bankruptcy trustee in El Paso subpoenas Yolanda, who is not a party to that case. There, the one hundred mile rule applies, and Deming sits right at the edge: about eighty two miles in a straight line, about one hundred two by road. The rule does not say which measure counts.

    Why does this hit ordinary businesses? Because the deadlines arrive long before the trial does. Start with the deposition. Tax Court allows a deposition to preserve testimony when there is a substantial risk the witness will not be available at trial. The application is due at least forty five days before trial, and the other side has fifteen days after service to raise objections. The transcript can then be used at trial if she is too far from the courtroom for attending to be practical.

    Next, a motion to move the whole case to a remote proceeding can be filed up until thirty one days before the first day of the trial session, and granting it is up to the judge. That motion moves everything. Video for one witness is a separate request. Then, under the court’s sample pretrial order, the pretrial memorandum is due twenty one days out, and a witness who is not named in it cannot testify without a showing of good cause. Miss those dates and a witness problem becomes a proof problem.

    The shortcut most owners reach for does not work either. A sworn letter from the bookkeeper is not evidence in Tax Court. The better fix is to need her less. Back to Yolanda. Her cost of goods sold is a paper trail: grower payments, freight bills, box and bag invoices. Bank statements and vendor invoices often prove purchases better than a bookkeeper’s memory.

    If your trial date is set, here are three things to do this week. First, read the pretrial order that came with your notice of trial and calendar every deadline, because that order controls. Second, sort out what the records can prove without the witness. Tax Court requires both sides to agree in advance on evidence that should not fairly be in dispute, and a bank can certify its own statements. Third, if you still need her, choose early between a deposition before trial and a subpoena paired with a request for video. And if a bankruptcy subpoena from another state lands on you, objections can be due in fourteen days or less. That’s what we do at North Star Law Firm. The initial consultation is free, and the full written analysis with citations is at N M dash legal dot net.

    Can the Tax Court subpoena an out of state witness for my Albuquerque trial?

    Yes. The Tax Court does not use Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 45 and its 100 mile limit. It has its own subpoena rule, Tax Court Rule 147, backed by 26 U.S.C. § 7456(a), which lets the Court require witnesses to appear “from any place in the United States at any designated place of hearing.”

    The Clerk issues a subpoena “signed but otherwise in blank” for the party to complete (Rule 147(a)(2)). It “may be served at any place within the United States” (Rule 147(b)(2)), and Rule 147(c) points the place of compliance back to § 7456. A server in Tucson can hand the bookkeeper a subpoena for Albuquerque if the server tenders one day’s fee and mileage. Rule 148 adopts the district court amounts in 28 U.S.C. § 1821: $40 a day plus mileage at the GSA rate.

    Does In re Kirkland or the 2026 Rule 45 amendment matter in Tax Court?

    Mostly no. In In re Kirkland, 75 F.4th 1030 (9th Cir. 2023), the Ninth Circuit ordered quashed the subpoenas directing two Virgin Islands residents to testify by video in a Los Angeles bankruptcy trial, because Rule 45(c)’s distance limits still bind a witness who testifies from her own living room. The Judicial Conference then approved a new Rule 45(c)(2), and on October 20, 2026 the Standing Committee’s chair sent it to the Supreme Court. Under 28 U.S.C. § 2074(a), the earliest effective date is December 1, 2027. The Supreme Court has not yet acted.

    None of that touches Tax Court Rule 147. The provision that matters is Tax Court Rule 143(b): testimony “generally must be taken in open court,” and the Court may permit video “for good cause in compelling circumstances and with appropriate safeguards.” That tracks Federal Rule 43(a), which the amendment leaves alone. Reaching the Tucson witness is easy. Putting her on a screen instead of in the courtroom is the hard part.

    The Tenth Circuit has not decided the Kirkland question, and I found no District of New Mexico decision on it. Rule 43(a) requests do come up here; in Martinez v. Continental Tire The Americas, LLC, No. 1:17-cv-00922 (D.N.M. 2022) (Doc. 687), the court let an out of state witness testify remotely.

    Can my witness appear by Zoomgov at a Tax Court trial in Albuquerque?

    Possibly, but plan for a no. Under Administrative Order No. 2021-01, still in force, “The Court’s default is to conduct in-person trials.” A Motion to Proceed Remotely may be filed “up until 31 days before the first day of the trial session,” and granting it “is at the Judge’s discretion.” That motion moves the whole case. For one witness on video, Yolanda needs a Rule 143(b) motion, and Rule 50(a) requires her to state whether the IRS objects.

    Preferring to stay in Arizona is a thin showing. A served subpoena, a written refusal and a short examination confined to records are better. Review of a denial is narrow: the Tenth Circuit reviews Tax Court decisions as it would a district court bench trial under 26 U.S.C. § 7482(a)(1), and it reviews evidentiary rulings for abuse of discretion. See Arnett v. Commissioner, No. 06-9005 (10th Cir. June 21, 2007) (unpublished).

    Tax Court Trial Date Set? Contact Us Now

    What if my Tax Court trial witness will not appear?

    Start cheap; the bookkeeper may not be needed for most of what she knows. Stipulation in Tax Court is mandatory: Rule 91(a)(1) requires the parties to stipulate “all evidence that fairly should not be in dispute.” IRS counsel usually agrees a bank statement is genuine while disputing what it proves.

    A sworn letter from the bookkeeper will not work. Rule 143(c) says “Ex parte affidavits or declarations” are not evidence, and the hearsay bar in Fed. R. Evid. 802 applies through Rule 143(a) and 26 U.S.C. § 7453. Business records are another matter. Under Rule 803(6) and Rule 902(11), a custodian’s written certification, with reasonable notice to the IRS before trial, lays the foundation without a live witness. Her bank can certify its statements; Yolanda can vouch for her own business records.

    Here my forensic accounting background matters. A chile packer’s cost of goods sold is a paper trail: grower payments, freight bills, box and bag invoices. Bank statements and vendor invoices often prove purchases better than a bookkeeper’s memory. Where records are thin, Cohan v. Commissioner, 39 F.2d 540 (2d Cir. 1930) allows an estimate, “bearing heavily” on the taxpayer, but not for travel, meals, gifts or listed property, which 26 U.S.C. § 274(d) requires to be substantiated. I wrote about rebuilding records in rebutting the bank deposits method.

    If her testimony is still needed, Rule 81 permits a deposition to perpetuate testimony where there is “a substantial risk” she “will not be available at the trial.” The application is due at least 45 days before trial, objections 15 days after service, and the transcript is usable if she is “at such distance from the place of trial that it is not practicable” to attend (Rule 81(i)(3)(B)). Last comes the subpoena itself, plus a Rule 143(b) motion for video.

    Method Rule and timing Cost Main risk
    Stipulation with IRS counsel Rule 91(a); filed 14 days before the session Lowest IRS concedes authenticity, not meaning
    Business records certification Fed. R. Evid. 803(6), 902(11); written notice before trial Low Covers records, not explanations
    Deposition to perpetuate testimony Rule 81; application 45 days before trial Moderate to high Must show substantial risk she is unavailable
    Subpoena plus remote appearance Rules 147, 148, 143(b); motion well before trial Fees, mileage, motion practice Judge may require her in the courtroom

    How does the calendar work for a spring 2027 Albuquerque trial session?

    Assume, for illustration, a session opening Monday, April 12, 2027. Under the Court’s sample Standing Pretrial Order (the order served with her notice of trial controls), discovery motions and her Rule 81 application are due Friday, February 26 (45 days). A Motion to Proceed Remotely is due Friday, March 12 (31 days). Her pretrial memorandum, due Monday, March 22 (21 days), must name the bookkeeper, since unlisted witnesses cannot testify “without a showing of good cause.” The stipulation of facts is due Monday, March 29 (14 days), and unagreed exhibits Monday, April 5 (7 days).

    Suppose she serves the bookkeeper in early February. Tucson to Albuquerque is about 435 road miles each way (Rome2rio); 869 miles at the $0.76 GSA rate for travel on or after July 1, 2026 is $660.44, so the server tenders $700.44 with the $40 fee. The 2027 rate may differ; travel days and overnight stays add fees under § 1821.

    What if an El Paso bankruptcy court subpoenas me from Deming?

    Now Yolanda is the nonparty, and federal Rule 45 applies through Bankruptcy Rule 9016. Rule 45(c)(1)(A) says a subpoena can require her attendance “within 100 miles of where the person resides, is employed, or regularly transacts business in person.” Using Census coordinates, Deming is about 82 miles from El Paso in a straight line; by road it is about 102. The rule does not say which measure governs, and I found no Tenth Circuit or New Mexico federal ruling on it. Counted in a straight line, or if she regularly sells in person in El Paso, she is likely within reach, and Kirkland, a Ninth Circuit case, does not bind a Texas court.

    Document production is limited to a place within 100 miles (Rule 45(c)(2)(A)). Objections are due before the earlier of the compliance date or 14 days after service (Rule 45(d)(2)(B)), so a subpoena served Monday, November 16, 2026 means objections by Monday, November 30. A motion to quash goes to “the court for the district where compliance is required”: the Western District of Texas for compliance in El Paso, or the New Mexico federal court if production is commanded in Deming, subject to transfer under Rule 45(f). And a trustee asking for her purchase records may also be looking at preference claims against payments she received.

    Frequently Asked Questions

    Does the 100 mile rule apply to a Tax Court subpoena?

    No. Section 7456(a) reaches witnesses anywhere in the United States. The real question is whether the judge will accept video testimony under Rule 143(b).

    Can I use my former bookkeeper’s signed statement instead of her testimony?

    Usually not; Rule 143(c) says ex parte declarations are not evidence. A Rule 902(11) business records certification is different, because it only lays a foundation for records.

    How long does a nonparty have to object to a Tax Court document subpoena?

    Rule 147(d)(2)(B) allows 15 days after service, or less if compliance is due sooner. That is one day more than federal Rule 45 allows.

    When will the Rule 45 remote testimony amendment take effect?

    No earlier than December 1, 2027, and only if the Supreme Court adopts it and Congress does not intervene. It will reach bankruptcy subpoenas through Rule 9016, not Tax Court subpoenas.

    Does it matter where my Tax Court trial is held?

    Yes, for cost and witness travel. I compared Albuquerque, El Paso and Lubbock in choosing a Tax Court place of trial in New Mexico.

    How North Star Law Firm Can Help

    North Star Law Firm prepares New Mexico taxpayers for trial through its Tax Court litigation and IRS audit defense practices and advises nonparties served with subpoenas in bankruptcy cases.

    Phillip Zagotti, JD/CPA, represents taxpayers before the IRS and the U.S. Tax Court and is admitted to the U.S. District Court and Bankruptcy Court for the District of New Mexico. The firm works alongside New Mexico-licensed counsel on state-law questions. If your Tax Court case depends on a witness who moved away, or an out of state subpoena arrived, contact North Star Law Firm.


  • After a PPP or EIDL Fraud Referral in New Mexico: Tax, Collection and Bankruptcy Fallout

    After a PPP or EIDL Fraud Referral in New Mexico: Tax, Collection and Bankruptcy Fallout

    Esteban’s Hobbs oilfield services LLC, taxed as an S corporation, had 14 employees in 2020. It took a $212,000 first draw PPP loan that April and a $190,000 second draw in February 2021, both forgiven. He also has a $150,000 COVID EIDL, 11 months behind, and a $10,000 EIDL advance. Last month his former partner said an investigator had asked about payroll.

    A bookkeeper who left on bad terms in 2024 built the PPP applications from gross billings, so the 2020 and 2021 Forms 941 show wages about 35 percent below what the applications claimed. Esteban is fictional; his question is not. Charged or not, what happens to his taxes, his collection exposure and his bankruptcy options?

    Does a PPP loan fraud investigation in New Mexico end if DOJ never files charges?

    No. DOJ’s tip program, formally the Criminal Tip Rewards Pilot Program and often called WHIP, can pay $10,000 to $30,000 once charges are unsealed, and SBA program fraud is covered. It implements Directive 26-12 (Oct. 1, 2026). Directive 26-13 (Oct. 7, 2026) has prosecutors ask, “in every case,” whether “a violation of the internal revenue laws has occurred.” The division is covered in our post on the National Fraud Enforcement Division.

    On Sept. 23, 2026, the SBA said the IRS had matched loan applications against tax data, found discrepancies tied to about $100 billion in loans, and opened examinations. A declination closes none of it.

    Is PPP forgiveness taxable income once the SBA says the loan was obtained by fraud?

    Normally not. Section 276 of the COVID-related Tax Relief Act of 2020 (Pub. L. 116-260, div. N, 134 Stat. 1979) excludes forgiveness, in § 276(a) for first draws and § 276(b) for second draws, and keeps the expenses deductible. Section 278(b) excludes EIDL advances. In an S corporation the excluded amount flows to the owner as tax exempt income.

    The exclusion assumes qualifying forgiveness. In CCA 202237010, released Sept. 16, 2022, IRS Chief Counsel said a borrower who did not meet the conditions “may not exclude the amount of the forgiven loan from gross income,” in the year of forgiveness, second draws included. IR-2022-162 describes the inclusion as “the portion of the loan proceeds that were forgiven based upon misrepresentations or omissions.” The memo is not precedent, but examiners start there. That word “portion” matters.

    Repayment is its own event. The CCA says repaying in a later year “may” support a deduction under § 162 or a loss under § 165. Section 1341 requires income reported because it “appeared” the taxpayer had an unrestricted right; my contestable reading is that it is a hard sell when the right came from a misstatement. Settlement payments also meet § 162(f), which denies a deduction unless the agreement identifies the amount as restitution. If the debt is instead treated as an ordinary loan never put into income, repaying principal yields no deduction.

    PPP or EIDL File Under Scrutiny? Contact Us Now

    How far back can the IRS reach, and what is the IRS civil fraud penalty?

    The IRS normally has three years from filing under 26 U.S.C. § 6501(a), or six under § 6501(e) if the return omitted more than 25 percent of the gross income it stated. A false or fraudulent return with intent to evade can be assessed “at any time” under § 6501(c)(1). The willful evasion rule in § 6501(c)(2) skips income tax; it reaches employment and excise taxes. Whose fraud counts is covered in our post on preparer fraud after Murrin.

    The § 6663 penalty is 75 percent of the underpayment due to fraud. The IRS bears the burden (§ 7454(a)), by clear and convincing evidence in the Tax Court under Rule 142(b). An application inflated by a bookkeeper’s method is not automatically a fraudulent tax return.

    Esteban’s 941 taxes were paid, so the trust fund recovery penalty is off the table; the 941s are the audit trail, and under § 6501(b)(2) his 2021 quarterlies count as filed April 15, 2022.

    After a tax conviction, § 6201(a)(4) lets the IRS assess restitution for unpaid tax as if it were tax, with no deficiency notice (§ 6213(b)(5)) and no challenge based on the underlying liability. Klein v. Commissioner, 149 T.C. 341 (2017), held that interest and failure to pay additions cannot be added to it. Restitution to the SBA for bank or wire fraud is a title 18 judgment instead; under 18 U.S.C. § 3613 its lien works like a tax lien for the later of 20 years from judgment or release from prison.

    How does Treasury collect a defaulted EIDL from a New Mexico borrower?

    A nontax debt delinquent 180 days goes to Treasury under 31 U.S.C. § 3711(g); the SBA’s EIDL page says offset referral can come at 120 days. Tax refunds are offset under 31 U.S.C. § 3720A. Social Security is reduced under 31 C.F.R. § 285.4 by the lesser of 15 percent or the amount above $750 a month. Wage garnishment under 31 U.S.C. § 3720D takes up to 15 percent of disposable pay after 30 days’ notice; a hearing request by day 15 holds the order.

    NMSA 1978, § 35-12-7 protects the greater of 75 percent of disposable earnings or 40 times the highest minimum wage weekly, but federal garnishment applies “notwithstanding any provision of State law.” The demand stage is in our SBA demand letter post. Under 31 C.F.R. § 900.3(a), only DOJ can compromise a debt involving the debtor’s fraud or misrepresentation.

    Is SBA loan fraud debt, or the tax that follows, dischargeable in bankruptcy?

    Debt obtained by fraud survives under 11 U.S.C. § 523(a)(2)(A), but written statements about financial condition fall under § 523(a)(2)(B), which adds reliance and intent to deceive. Lamar, Archer & Cofrin, LLP v. Appling, 584 U.S. 709 (2018), read “respecting” broadly enough to cover a single asset, and United States v. Schoenmann, Adv. No. 23-03043 (Bankr. N.D. Cal. July 3, 2025), treated an EIDL application as one. I found no Tenth Circuit ruling on PPP payroll figures. The creditor must sue within 60 days after the first date set for the § 341 meeting (Rule 4007(c)). In Lashinsky v. Holman, Adv. No. 21-1031-j (Bankr. D.N.M. Feb. 7, 2024), the court found “substantial PPP loan improprieties” yet granted the discharge because intent was not proven.

    Tax on a fraudulent return never discharges (§ 523(a)(1)(C)). Dalton v. IRS, 77 F.3d 1297 (10th Cir. 1996), reads willful as “done voluntarily, consciously or knowingly, and intentionally.” Tax assessed within 240 days before filing also survives (§ 507(a)(8)(A)(ii)). Tax penalties can discharge under § 523(a)(7)(B) if the event was more than three years before the petition, and the Tenth Circuit BAP treated filing the return as the event for a frivolous return penalty in In re Wilson, BAP No. CO-08-092 (June 12, 2009). Title 18 restitution survives (§ 523(a)(13)).

    The stay does not stop a prosecution (§ 362(b)(1)), and its refund setoff exception, § 362(b)(26), covers income tax against income tax, not SBA debt. Chapter 13, or Subchapter V under the $3,424,000 limit in effect since April 1, 2025, can spread out what survives. As of Nov. 6, 2026, H.R. 7730, raising that limit to $7.5 million, has passed both chambers with no signature recorded.

    What would a Hobbs business owner’s PPP investigation cost in tax?

    Illustrative only. Say the SBA rescinds the 2021 forgiveness of the $190,000 second draw, DOJ declines, and the IRS opens 2021. Under the 2022 position $190,000 of company income flows to Esteban’s 1040. At a 24 percent bracket that is $45,600 of tax plus a $34,200 fraud penalty, $79,800 before interest. If only the inflated 35 percent counts, $66,500, the tax is $15,960 and the penalty $11,970. New Mexico base income starts from federal adjusted gross income (NMSA 1978, § 7-2-2), and § 7-1-13(E) requires a federal adjustments report within 180 days of the final determination.

    He filed for 2021 in April 2022, so three years ended in April 2025. Only fraud, or the six year rule through April 2028 if the omission tops 25 percent, keeps 2021 open, which is why a fraud finding matters more than the loan. If he guaranteed the EIDL, Treasury can take his 2026 refund. In Chapter 7, the LLC’s loans are not his unless he guaranteed them, and an entity gets no discharge (§ 727(a)(1)). The 2021 tax survives if fraud is found or it was assessed within 240 days; the penalty likely does not.

    Debt Who collects, and how Time limit Survives Chapter 7?
    PPP second draw after rescinded forgiveness SBA, then Treasury offset and garnishment Referral at 180 days delinquent Only on a timely, proven § 523(a)(2) claim
    EIDL loan plus advance SBA, then Treasury offset and garnishment Offset referral from 120 days Same; personal only if guaranteed
    2021 income tax and § 6663 penalty IRS levy, lien and refund offset Three or six years; no limit for fraud Tax often; penalty usually not
    Criminal restitution, if charged DOJ, lien under 18 U.S.C. § 3613 20 years from judgment or release Yes, § 523(a)(13)

    Frequently Asked Questions

    Must I amend my return if PPP forgiveness is rescinded?

    IR-2022-162 encouraged amended returns but did not require them. The amount depends on whether forgiveness was improper and what portion was affected.

    Can the IRS impose a fraud penalty without a conviction?

    Yes. The § 6663 penalty is civil and survives a declination. The IRS must prove fraud on the return by clear and convincing evidence.

    Will a tip about my PPP loan trigger an IRS audit?

    Not by itself. Directive 26-13 tells prosecutors to look for tax violations, and the SBA separately refers loan files to the IRS.

    Can Treasury take my Social Security for an EIDL default?

    If you are personally liable, yes, after notice. It takes the lesser of 15 percent of the monthly benefit or the amount above $750.

    Does bankruptcy stop a federal fraud investigation?

    No. Criminal proceedings are outside the automatic stay. Fraud debts and restitution may survive the discharge.

    How North Star Law Firm Can Help

    North Star Law Firm helps New Mexico owners whose pandemic loan files draw attention, through IRS audit defense, amended or unfiled returns, and Chapter 7 analysis of which debts would survive.

    Phillip Zagotti, JD/CPA, represents taxpayers before the IRS and the U.S. Tax Court and is admitted to the U.S. District Court and Bankruptcy Court for the District of New Mexico. The firm works alongside New Mexico-licensed counsel on state-law questions. If an investigator has asked about your PPP or EIDL file, contact North Star Law Firm.


  • IRS Audit of a New Mexico Nonprofit: What the Exam Covers and How It Ends

    IRS Audit of a New Mexico Nonprofit: What the Exam Covers and How It Ends

    Lucinda is board treasurer of a youth-services charity in Farmington. It took in about $1.4 million in 2023, runs a thrift store, and rents its building from an LLC owned by one of its directors. In October 2026 IRS Exempt Organizations examinations wrote to schedule a visit about the 2023 Form 990, with an Information Document Request attached. The board meets Thursday.

    A governance checklist will not help her now. Below is the procedure for an IRS audit of a nonprofit in New Mexico, with a section on church rules.

    What kind of IRS exempt organization examination did our New Mexico nonprofit receive?

    The IRS audit process page draws the line: a letter setting an appointment at your premises opens a field audit, and one asking you to mail documents opens a correspondence audit. Lucinda has the first kind. Under IRM 4.70.13, Publication 1 should come with the appointment letter, and the examiner will want a Form 2848 for any representative. Record requests come on Form 4564, the Information Document Request.

    A compliance check is different. IRM 4.70.10.2 says “A compliance check is NOT an examination, and the taxpayer may legally choose not to participate.” Staff can still refer the case for examination, so I rarely ignore one. The fiscal year 2027 TE/GE program letter (Publication 5313, Rev. 10-2026) targets “abusive and prohibited transactions.”

    Tax must be assessed “within 3 years after the return was filed” (26 U.S.C. § 6501(a)), and for § 4958 taxes the organization’s own annual return starts that period (§ 6501(l)(1)). If the 2023 Form 990 was filed May 15, 2024, the 2023 lease year stays open until May 15, 2027. Business income is murkier, since § 6501(g)(2) addresses an organization later held taxable, not a skipped Form 990-T. Examiners short on time ask for Form 872 (§ 6501(c)(4)); see whether to sign IRS Form 872.

    What does the IRS look for in a Form 990 audit?

    Under Treas. Reg. § 1.501(c)(3)-1, an organization fails if “more than an insubstantial part of its activities is not in furtherance of an exempt purpose” ((c)(1)) or if “its net earnings inure in whole or in part to the benefit of private shareholders or individuals” ((c)(2)), and it must serve “a public rather than a private interest” ((d)(1)(ii)). In my experience a single corrected deal draws excise taxes, not revocation.

    The lease raises excise tax. An excess benefit exists where “the value of the economic benefit provided exceeds the value of the consideration” (26 U.S.C. § 4958(c)(1)(A)), and Treas. Reg. § 53.4958-4(b)(1)(i) values “the right to use property” at fair market value. An LLC more than 35 percent owned by an influential director is a disqualified person (§ 4958(f)(1), (f)(3); see Section 4958 after Jagannath). The lease also belongs on Schedule L, Part IV, under the current instructions (Rev. December 2024).

    Payroll often rides along, especially whether tutors or drivers paid on 1099s are employees. For a classification determination, 26 U.S.C. § 7436 allows a Tax Court petition “before the 91st day” after the notice is mailed.

    Nonprofit Got an IRS Exam Letter? Contact Us Now

    Is a nonprofit thrift store taxed as unrelated business income?

    Mostly no. The tax in 26 U.S.C. § 511(a)(1) uses the 21 percent corporate rate of § 11(b) and reaches a business “not substantially related” to the exempt purpose, but § 513(a)(3) excludes “the selling of merchandise, substantially all of which has been received by the organization as gifts or contributions.” Treas. Reg. § 1.513-1(e)(3) calls these “so-called thrift shops.”

    Bought inventory is the weak spot. Under § 1.513-1(b) an activity stays a trade or business within “a larger aggregate of similar activities,” so closeout resales can be split out. No rule puts a number on “substantially all,” and I found no Tenth Circuit decision on a mixed store. Each unrelated business is computed separately (§ 512(a)(6)) after a $1,000 deduction (§ 512(b)(12)), and $1,000 of gross unrelated business income requires a Form 990-T (2023 instructions).

    The lease produces no business income because the charity is the tenant; sublet rent would generally be excluded (§ 512(b)(3)(A)(i)) unless debt-financed (§ 514). New Mexico’s gross receipts exemption for 501(c)(3) organizations, NMSA 1978, § 7-9-29, excludes “receipts derived from an unrelated trade or business as defined in Section 513” (subsection (C)(1)).

    Are churches audited differently under section 7611?

    Yes. Under 26 U.S.C. § 7611(a), a church tax inquiry may begin only if an “appropriate high-level Treasury official reasonably believes (on the basis of facts and circumstances recorded in writing)” that the church may not be exempt or may owe tax, and only after written notice. Examining records takes a second notice at least 15 days later (§ 7611(b)). An inquiry must finish within 90 days of its notice, and an examination “not later than the date which is 2 years after the examination notice date” (§ 7611(c)(1)). A closed inquiry with no revocation, assessment or required change bars a repeat on similar issues for “the applicable 5-year period” (§ 7611(f)).

    Who that official is remains untidy. Treas. Reg. § 301.7611-1, Q&A-1, still names “the appropriate Regional Commissioner,” a post eliminated after the 1998 IRS restructuring; a 2009 fix (74 Fed. Reg. 39003) was never finalized that I can find. IRM 4.70.19 (Nov. 22, 2023) delegates to the Commissioner of TE/GE, which United States v. Bible Study Time, Inc., No. 7:17-cv-02810 (D.S.C. Mar. 13, 2018), accepted. The Tenth Circuit has not decided it. God’s Storehouse Topeka Church v. United States, No. 23-3063 (10th Cir. Apr. 9, 2024), held only that § 7611 does not cover a third-party bank summons.

    The protections exclude “separately incorporated church-supported schools or other organizations” (Q&A-3), so a parish school with its own charter is examined like Lucinda’s charity. Payroll is unsettled. Section 7611(i) never mentions it, the regulation treats withholding questions as routine requests outside the procedures (Q&A-4), and IRM 4.70.19.4(6) says the procedures apply to employment tax inquiries.

    How does a Form 990 audit end, and where does a New Mexico charity appeal?

    Many exams end with a no-change letter, an agreement form or a closing agreement (IRM 4.70.14). Otherwise comes a 30-day letter with the agent’s report; for proposed revocation, Letter 3618 with Form 886-A. Publication 556 requires a written protest in every exempt organization case, which sends it to the IRS Independent Office of Appeals.

    Business income tax and § 4958 taxes follow deficiency procedures (§ 6211(a)): 90 days after a notice of deficiency to petition the Tax Court (§ 6213(a)), which sits in Albuquerque, then the Tenth Circuit (§ 7482(b)(1)). A revoked charity may seek a declaratory judgment under § 7428, filed before the 91st day after the final determination is mailed (see the firm’s Section 7428 post). Revocation can be retroactive if the organization “operated in a manner materially different from that originally represented” (Treas. Reg. § 601.201(n)(6)(i); see Rev. Proc. 2026-5). I found no 2025 or 2026 Tenth Circuit exempt organization decision.

    A revocation also undercuts the § 7-9-29 exemption, and NMSA 1978, § 57-22-6 has charities register with the Attorney General, file their Form 990 there within six months after year-end, and above $500,000 in revenue obtain an independent CPA audit.

    What could the exam cost Lucinda’s Farmington charity?

    Illustration only. Say the store sold $180,000 of purchased closeout goods in 2023, netting $40,000, and no Form 990-T was filed. Taxable income is $40,000 less the $1,000 deduction, or $39,000; at 21 percent, tax is $8,190, plus interest.

    The lease paid the director’s LLC $96,000 when comparable space rented for $60,000, a $36,000 excess benefit. If the director has substantial influence and owns over 35 percent of the LLC, the LLC owes the 25 percent first-tier tax, $9,000, on Form 4720. Directors who knowingly approved it owe 10 percent, $3,600, jointly and severally (capped at $20,000 by § 4958(d)(2)), unless participation “is not willful and is due to reasonable cause.” Uncorrected, the LLC faces a 200 percent second-tier tax: $72,000.

    Under Treas. Reg. § 53.4958-7, the LLC repays $36,000 in cash, not by promissory note, plus interest at least at the applicable federal rate, compounded annually. Rent for 2024 onward needs resetting too. With reasonable cause and timely correction, § 4962 allows abatement of the first-tier taxes.

    Exam outcome Who is liable Forum to contest Deadline to respond
    No change No one None None
    UBIT deficiency The charity Appeals, then Tax Court (Albuquerque) 30-day letter; 90 days after notice of deficiency
    § 4958 excise tax Disqualified person; knowing managers Appeals, then Tax Court 30-day letter; 90 days after notice
    Employment tax The charity Appeals; Tax Court under § 7436 for classification 30-day letter; before 91st day after § 7436 notice
    Revocation The charity Appeals; § 7428 in Tax Court, Court of Federal Claims or D.D.C. 30-day letter (Letter 3618); before 91st day after final determination

    Frequently Asked Questions

    Is an IRS compliance check the same as an audit?

    No. The IRS manual says a compliance check is not an examination and participation is optional, though staff can refer the case for one.

    How far back can the IRS examine a nonprofit’s Form 990?

    Generally three years from filing, which also covers that year’s § 4958 taxes. A signed Form 872 extends the period, and a missing Form 990-T can leave business income open.

    Does a thrift store make a New Mexico charity pay tax?

    Donated-goods sales fall within § 513(a)(3). Resold purchased merchandise can be unrelated business income taxed at 21 percent, and § 7-9-29 does not exempt unrelated business receipts.

    Can the IRS audit a church in New Mexico?

    Yes, under § 7611: a written reasonable belief by a high-level official, advance notice, and 90-day and two-year limits. A separately incorporated church school is not covered.

    Who pays the § 4958 tax, the charity or the insider?

    The insider owes 25 percent of the excess benefit, and knowing managers owe 10 percent, capped at $20,000. The charity owes none.

    How North Star Law Firm Can Help

    North Star Law Firm represents New Mexico charities, boards and insiders in IRS audit defense, from the first document request through IRS Appeals and Tax Court litigation.

    Phillip Zagotti, JD/CPA, represents taxpayers before the IRS and the U.S. Tax Court and is admitted to the U.S. District Court and Bankruptcy Court for the District of New Mexico. The firm works alongside New Mexico-licensed counsel on state-law questions. If your nonprofit or church has an IRS exam or compliance check letter on the table, contact North Star Law Firm.


  • Divorce and IRS Tax Debt in New Mexico: Community Property and Innocent Spouse Relief

    Divorce and IRS Tax Debt in New Mexico: Community Property and Innocent Spouse Relief

    Dolores teaches school in Las Vegas, New Mexico. Her husband ran a trucking business, and every spring she signed the joint return he brought home. She filed for divorce in March 2026. By summer the IRS wanted $64,000 for 2022 and 2023, mostly tax and penalties on hauling income that never reached his Schedule C.

    Her divorce lawyer is drafting a clause that says he pays the IRS. It helps less than she thinks. Federal law offers better ways out, and New Mexico’s community property rules shape them.

    Does a New Mexico divorce decree decide who owes the IRS?

    No. On a joint return, 26 U.S.C. § 6013(d)(3) makes the liability “joint and several,” so each spouse owes all of it. In Asad v. Commissioner, T.C. Memo. 2017-80, the Tax Court said a divorce agreement dividing tax debts binds the spouses to each other but “does not control their liabilities to the IRS.” IRS Publication 504 (2025) tells divorced filers the same.

    New Mexico’s bankruptcy court applied that idea to state taxes in Chavez v. Internal Revenue Service, Adv. No. 01-1186 S (Bankr. D.N.M. Sept. 27, 2002). The husband had assumed his business’s unpaid taxes in the divorce, yet the court called that allocation “irrelevant of course for third parties such as these taxing authorities.” (The IRS had withdrawn its claim.) The wife kept a claim against him.

    What the decree does control is tax between the spouses. Alimony under an instrument executed after December 31, 2018 is neither deductible nor income, because Pub. L. 115-97, § 11051 repealed §§ 71 and 215. Transfers incident to divorce carry over basis with no gain under § 1041. Plans divide by a qualified domestic relations order under § 414(p), IRAs under § 408(d)(6), and head-of-household status follows § 2(b). None of that touches the old joint balance.

    How does innocent spouse relief work for a New Mexico spouse?

    26 U.S.C. § 6015 offers three routes, all requested on Form 8857. Subsection (b) removes an understatement from the other spouse’s erroneous items if she “did not know, and had no reason to know” of it. Subsection (c) lets a spouse who is divorced, legally separated, or out of the household for 12 months limit her share of a deficiency to her own items. Both are due within two years after the IRS “has begun collection activities” against her; under Treas. Reg. § 1.6015-5(b)(2) a § 6330 levy notice or refund offset counts, but a notice of deficiency or lien notice does not. Equitable relief under (f) covers the rest, including unpaid reported tax, while the ten-year collection period is open (§ 6015(f)(2)).

    Here community property helps. Section 6015(a) says every determination “shall be made without regard to community property laws,” and Treas. Reg. § 1.6015-1(f) charges an erroneous item to the spouse “whose activities gave rise to such item.” Under § 1.6015-3(d)(2)(iii), business income belongs to the owner, and under (c)(2) the IRS must prove she actually knew. For (f), Rev. Proc. 2013-34 allows relief on an item charged to her “solely due to the operation of community property law.”

    If the IRS denies relief, she has 90 days from the final determination to petition the Tax Court (§ 6015(e)(1)(A)), which since 2019 reviews de novo on the administrative record plus newly discovered evidence (§ 6015(e)(7), added by Pub. L. 116-25, § 1203). Appeals go to the Tenth Circuit (§ 7482(b)(1)(A)), which reviews law de novo and facts for clear error, Jonson v. Commissioner, 353 F.3d 1181 (10th Cir. 2003). I found no Tenth Circuit decision applying (e)(7), and none on § 6015 in 2025 or 2026.

    Divorcing With IRS Debt in New Mexico? Contact Us Now

    Can the IRS collect one spouse’s tax debt from New Mexico community property?

    For joint-return tax the question hardly arises, since the § 6321 lien reaches “all property and rights to property” of each liable spouse. It matters when the tax is his alone.

    NMSA 1978, § 40-3-9 treats a debt incurred during marriage as community unless a listed exception, such as a premarital or post-decree debt, applies. Under § 40-3-10, a separate debt reaches the debtor’s separate property and his half of the community, not the other spouse’s interests. Section 40-3-11 sends community debts to all community property first.

    IRM 25.18.4.8 limits a spouse’s premarital tax to his half of the community, while IRM 25.18.4.9 treats tax incurred during the marriage as collectible from all of it. In In re Pinon, No. 13-98-10568 SA (Bankr. D.N.M. Mar. 31, 2000), a husband’s partnership tax liability was a community debt reachable by the federal lien. Chavez added that the statutes’ shield for the family home does not reach a tax debt, because “No writing is required for the creation of a tax debt.”

    Whether those statutes bind the IRS is less clear. Under United States v. Craft, 535 U.S. 274 (2002), “State law determines only which sticks are in a person’s bundle,” and federal law decides what the lien reaches. Eaves v. United States, 433 F.2d 1296 (10th Cir. 1970), let the government offset a husband’s deficiency against his wife’s community-funded refund, but it predates the 1973 statute. I found no federal decision applying today’s § 40-3-10 to an IRS levy, so I would take that question to New Mexico-licensed counsel.

    On separate returns, each spouse ordinarily reports half the community income (IRS Publication 555). Section 66 adjusts that when spouses live apart all year or one hides income, and § 66(c) relieves a spouse taxed on community income she knew nothing about.

    What happens to a federal tax lien on a house awarded in a New Mexico divorce?

    It stays. Under § 6322 the lien arises at assessment and lasts until paid or time-barred. In Craft, a husband’s one-dollar quitclaim of the home to his wife did not free his interest from the lien. To sell or refinance, the spouse who kept the house generally needs a certificate of discharge under § 6325(b), requested on Form 14135 at least 45 days ahead (IRS Publication 783). See the firm’s post on selling a New Mexico home with a federal tax lien.

    Can a divorcing spouse get her own installment agreement or offer in compromise?

    Yes. Under the Form 656 booklet (Form 656 rev. April 2026), legally separated or divorced spouses cannot make a joint offer, so each offers on his or her own share, with a separate Form 433-A (OIC). An offer can rest on doubt as to collectibility or on doubt as to liability, a “genuine dispute as to the existence or amount of the correct tax liability” (Treas. Reg. § 301.7122-1(b)). An installment agreement under § 6159, or hardship status under IRM 5.16.1, can follow.

    Order matters. A pending relief request bars levies against the requesting spouse through any Tax Court case (§ 6015(e)(1)(B)), and § 6015(e)(2) stops the ten-year clock on “the assessment” for that time plus 60 days. Only she is protected. The IRS can still pursue him, and under the Form 8857 instructions it must contact him and let him participate. In my experience, that is when he offers his own version of who knew what. On the state side, NMSA 1978, § 7-1-17.1 lets a spouse the IRS relieved ask New Mexico for similar relief.

    What should a Las Vegas, New Mexico spouse file first, and when?

    Illustration only. Her husband moved out March 1, 2026, and on August 3, 2026 the IRS mails Dolores a levy notice under § 6330. Her two-year window for (b) and (c) now runs to August 3, 2028. Waiting risks a continuous paycheck levy under § 6331(e), minus the exempt amount in § 6334(d).

    Filing Form 8857 that August stops the levy and puts (b) and (f) in play. Subsection (c) waits until the decree or early March 2027, when the household test is met. Treas. Reg. § 1.6015-1(h)(5) allows a second (c) election once she qualifies, so waiting gains nothing. The decree’s “husband pays” clause will not stop collection if relief fails, but Rev. Proc. 2013-34 § 4.03(2)(d) counts it toward (f) relief unless she knew he would not pay. A (c) allocation refunds nothing (§ 6015(g)(3)), so payments she already made come back, if at all, only under (b) or (f).

    Relief Who qualifies Deadline What it covers
    § 6015(b) Joint filer with no knowledge or reason to know 2 years after first collection activity Understatement from the other spouse’s items
    § 6015(c) Divorced, legally separated, or apart 12 months 2 years after first collection activity Deficiency allocated as on separate returns; no refunds
    § 6015(f) Joint filer when (b) and (c) fail Collection period, or refund period if paid Understatements and unpaid reported tax
    § 66(c) Separate filer taxed on the other’s community income 6 months before the assessment period ends Tax on the omitted community income

    Frequently Asked Questions

    Does my divorce decree stop the IRS from collecting from me?

    No. Joint filers each owe the full tax, and the IRS is not bound by the decree.

    Do I have to be divorced to file Form 8857?

    No. Relief under § 6015(b) and (f) does not require divorce. Separation of liability under § 6015(c) requires divorce, legal separation, or 12 months living apart.

    Can the IRS levy my wages while my request is pending?

    Generally not. Section 6015(e)(1)(B) bars levies against the requesting spouse while the request is pending, but the collection clock pauses and interest continues.

    Can the IRS take my half of the community for my husband’s premarital taxes?

    The IRS manual says a premarital tax in New Mexico reaches only the liable spouse’s half of the community plus his separate property. How the state debt statutes apply to a federal levy is unsettled.

    Will my former spouse learn that I asked for relief?

    Yes. The IRS must contact the other spouse and let him participate. Its instructions say your personal information is protected.

    How North Star Law Firm Can Help

    North Star Law Firm handles innocent spouse relief claims for New Mexico taxpayers and negotiates installment agreements and offers in compromise when relief is not the whole answer. Its tax defense practice covers liens and levies too.

    Phillip Zagotti, JD/CPA, represents taxpayers before the IRS and the U.S. Tax Court and is admitted to the U.S. District Court and Bankruptcy Court for the District of New Mexico. The firm works alongside New Mexico-licensed counsel on state-law questions. If your divorce is underway and IRS notices are still arriving for joint years, contact North Star Law Firm.


  • 351 ETF Conversions and Exchange Funds in New Mexico: Notice 2026-62 and Rev. Rul. 2026-20

    351 ETF Conversions and Exchange Funds in New Mexico: Notice 2026-62 and Rev. Rul. 2026-20

    Helen retired from engineering in Los Alamos with about $2.4 million in two dozen stocks bought since the 1990s, combined basis near $300,000. In April 2025 her adviser moved it all into a newly launched exchange-traded fund and called it tax-free. Within weeks the fund handed her old shares to a broker-dealer.

    On September 28, 2026, Treasury and the IRS released Revenue Ruling 2026-20, which treats that plan as a taxable exchange, and Notice 2026-62, which flags it and its partnership “exchange fund” cousin for possible tax shelter reporting. Her 2025 return is filed. The harder question is what she must now disclose, and what silence would cost.

    What is a section 351 ETF conversion, and what does Revenue Ruling 2026-20 change?

    Section 351 lets people move property into a corporation “solely in exchange for stock” without recognizing gain if they control it immediately afterward (26 U.S.C. § 351(a)). An ETF is a corporation that qualifies as a regulated investment company, and 26 U.S.C. § 852(b)(6) lets it hand appreciated securities to a redeeming shareholder, typically an authorized participant (a broker-dealer that creates and redeems shares in blocks), without paying tax on the gain. Stocks go in tax-free and come out tax-free.

    The ruling (2026-43 I.R.B. 511) collapses the steps. When the fund, under one plan, issues shares to an authorized participant and “shortly thereafter” redeems them with the investor’s securities, the ruling treats the investor “as undertaking a taxable exchange under § 1001” with the participant. It states no effective date, and under 26 U.S.C. § 7805(b)(8) rulings apply retroactively unless the IRS limits them, so I read it as reaching 2025 conversions. The Notice excludes seeding a fund with assets it means to keep.

    A direct conversion needs an already diversified portfolio, because § 351(e)(1) excludes transfers to an investment company unless each contributor holds no more than 25 percent in one issuer and 50 percent in five or fewer (Treas. Reg. § 1.351-1(c)(6)(i); 26 U.S.C. § 368(a)(2)(F)(ii)). Helen cleared that line. A one-stock owner does not, and gets pitched an exchange fund.

    Is a partnership exchange fund still an option for concentrated stock in New Mexico?

    An exchange fund pools concentrated positions in a partnership. Contributions are normally tax-free under 26 U.S.C. § 721(a), but § 721(b) withdraws that when the partnership “would be treated as an investment company (within the meaning of section 351) if the partnership were incorporated.” Under Treas. Reg. § 1.351-1(c)(1), the test is whether more than 80 percent of its assets are readily marketable stocks or securities held for investment (§ 351(e)(1) counts even REIT shares). So exchange funds keep at least 20 percent in something else, usually real estate held directly.

    The Notice does not condemn that. Section 2.03 targets a partnership that, once it holds everyone’s pooled stock, runs its own 351 conversion into an ETF. The IRS is weighing guidance denying nonrecognition to those contributions and offers no view on other exchange funds. If a Santa Fe adviser pitches one, ask whether the documents contemplate a later ETF conversion. The Notice’s box spread and “tax-aware” derivative strategies operate inside funds and reach investors mainly if later guidance names them.

    Already Did a 351 Conversion or Exchange Fund? Contact Us Now

    What happens if the IRS makes this a listed transaction or a transaction of interest?

    Nothing is designated yet. Listed transactions and transactions of interest are reportable under Treas. Reg. § 1.6011-4, and each participant must attach Form 8886 to the return and send a copy to the IRS Office of Tax Shelter Analysis (OTSA). “Substantially similar” deals count, a phrase that “must be broadly construed in favor of disclosure.”

    The rule I would flag is § 1.6011-4(e)(2)(i). If a transaction is designated after you file a return reflecting it, while that year is still open for assessment, Form 8886 goes to OTSA “within 90 calendar days” of the designation. Helen’s 2025 return, filed in April 2026, stays open under 26 U.S.C. § 6501(a) until April 2029.

    Missing it costs money even if the position holds. 26 U.S.C. § 6707A imposes 75 percent of the tax decrease from the transaction, at least $5,000 for an individual and at most $100,000 for a listed transaction or $10,000 for other reportable transactions. For an undisclosed listed transaction, § 6501(c)(10) keeps the year open until one year after the information is furnished. Section 6662A adds 20 percent of a “reportable transaction understatement” (30 percent if undisclosed), figured at the highest § 1 rate. Its reasonable cause defense under 26 U.S.C. § 6664(d) requires disclosure, and a promoter’s opinion does not count.

    Why is October 28, 2026 the comment deadline, and can the IRS list these deals by notice?

    Comments are due October 28, 2026, the day this post is published. In my reading that is an information request, not the rulemaking courts now require before a listing.

    In Mann Construction, Inc. v. United States, 27 F.4th 1138 (6th Cir. 2022), the Sixth Circuit held that a listing notice is a legislative rule and set aside Notice 2007-83 for skipping notice and comment under the Administrative Procedure Act. Green Rock LLC v. IRS, 104 F.4th 220 (11th Cir. 2024), did the same for the conservation easement listing, as did the Tax Court in Green Valley Investors, LLC v. Commissioner, 159 T.C. 80 (2022). In AOD 2024-01 the IRS acquiesced, giving up reportable transaction penalties for post-2004 listings that skipped notice and comment.

    I found no Tenth Circuit decision on point. A New Mexico individual’s Tax Court case appeals there under 26 U.S.C. § 7482(b)(1)(A), and the Tax Court has Green Valley. I expect any listing here to come as a proposed regulation. That buys time; it is not a defense.

    How does a federal recharacterization reach a New Mexico income tax return?

    New Mexico “base income” starts from federal adjusted gross income (NMSA 1978, § 7-2-2). The capital gains deduction barely helps: starting with 2025, NMSA 1978, § 7-2-34 allows the greater of $2,500 of net capital gain or 40 percent of up to $1 million of gain from selling a business; the 2024 amendment (Laws 2024, ch. 67) ended the general 40 percent deduction. A stock portfolio is not a business. The 2025 top rate is 5.9 percent on single filers’ taxable income over $210,000 (NMSA 1978, § 7-2-7).

    After an IRS adjustment or an amended federal return, NMSA 1978, § 7-1-13(E) requires a federal adjustments report and payment within 180 days after the final determination date, and § 7-1-18(E) runs the state’s assessment window from that report (see the firm’s Form 872 post). How the Taxation and Revenue Department applies these rules is a question for New Mexico-licensed counsel.

    What would the numbers look like for a Los Alamos retiree?

    Illustration only. Assume Helen files single, the fund used all her shares to redeem the authorized participant, and her other 2025 taxable income is $120,000 (federal and state), with $140,000 of adjusted gross income. She recognizes $2.1 million of long-term capital gain.

    For 2025 a single filer’s 15 percent rate ends at $533,400 of taxable income (Rev. Proc. 2024-40), so $413,400 is taxed at 15 percent ($62,010) and $1,686,600 at 20 percent under 26 U.S.C. § 1(h) ($337,320). The 3.8 percent tax of 26 U.S.C. § 1411 on modified AGI above $200,000 adds $77,520, for about $476,850 federal. (The 2026 threshold is $545,500 under Rev. Proc. 2025-32.) New Mexico: after the $2,500 deduction, $90,000 is taxed at 4.9 percent and $2,007,500 at 5.9 percent, about $122,850.

    Amending before the IRS first contacts her about an examination makes it a qualified amended return, removing the 20 percent accuracy-related penalty of 26 U.S.C. § 6662 on that tax (Treas. Reg. § 1.6664-2(c)); an IRS promoter examination of the arrangement can also close that window. Interest runs from April 15, 2026 regardless (26 U.S.C. § 6601(a)). If she waits, the deal is listed, and she misses the 90-day filing, the § 6707A penalty hits its $100,000 cap. This is rarely a case for the IRS voluntary disclosure practice, which is aimed at criminal exposure.

    Strategy IRS position Who bears the risk What to check
    351 conversion into a new ETF Rev. Rul. 2026-20: taxable § 1001 exchange Contributing investor Whether your securities left the fund quickly
    Exchange fund that converts to an ETF Notice § 2.03: may deny § 721 nonrecognition Contributing partner Whether documents contemplate a conversion
    Box spread ETF Notice § 2.04: questions § 852(b)(6) redemptions of options Fund, unless guidance names investors Fund tax disclosures
    Tax-aware straddles, forwards, swaps Notice § 3: elective character concerns Fund; results flow to partners K-1s pairing capital gain with ordinary loss
    351 seeding with retained assets Not addressed No change announced That holdings stayed

    Frequently Asked Questions

    Is every 351 ETF conversion taxable now?

    No. The ruling covers plans where the fund uses contributed securities to redeem an authorized participant shortly afterward. Seeding a fund with assets it keeps is outside the Notice.

    Do I have to file Form 8886 for a 351 conversion today?

    Not because of Notice 2026-62, which designates nothing. A duty would arise if later guidance designates the transaction and covers investors, or if your deal already fit another category, such as a deal offered under confidentiality conditions for a fee of at least $50,000.

    Can I still comment on Notice 2026-62?

    Comments are due October 28, 2026, at regulations.gov (IRS-2026-1255) or by mail. Later comments will be considered unless that would delay guidance.

    Does New Mexico tax the gain if the IRS recharacterizes my conversion?

    Yes. New Mexico starts from federal adjusted gross income. For 2025 and later a stock investor generally gets only a $2,500 capital gains deduction.

    What is the most an individual can owe under section 6707A?

    $100,000 per listed transaction and $10,000 for other reportable transactions, with a $5,000 minimum. Within those limits it is 75 percent of the tax decrease.

    How North Star Law Firm Can Help

    North Star Law Firm reviews completed 351 conversions and exchange fund investments for New Mexico investors through its tax defense practice, including whether to amend, and represents clients in IRS audits and penalty abatement requests.

    Phillip Zagotti, JD/CPA, represents taxpayers before the IRS and the U.S. Tax Court and is admitted to the U.S. District Court and Bankruptcy Court for the District of New Mexico. The firm works alongside New Mexico-licensed counsel on state-law questions. If an adviser moved your portfolio into a new ETF or exchange fund and you doubt your 2025 return, contact North Star Law Firm.


  • Nonprofit Loans to Insiders in New Mexico: Section 4958 Taxes After Jagannath

    Nonprofit Loans to Insiders in New Mexico: Section 4958 Taxes After Jagannath

    Picture a retired schoolteacher who became treasurer of a Silver City after-school program in July. In the draft 2025 Form 990 she finds $85,000 listed as “loans and other receivables” from officers, owed by the founder’s LLC on a note the founder signed for both sides. Nobody voted on it. Whose problem is this?

    Mostly the founder’s, though not only hers. In an opinion filed September 24, 2026, the Tax Court sustained $1,327,500 in excise taxes against the president of a Tennessee charity over a $590,000 note much like this one. The taxes land on people, not the charity, and the clock behind the largest one is already running.

    When is a nonprofit loan to an insider an excess benefit transaction?

    The definition in 26 U.S.C. § 4958(c)(1)(A) covers any transfer from a public charity to a disqualified person worth more than what the charity gets back.

    The taxes, called intermediate sanctions, reach anyone positioned to exercise substantial influence during the five years before the deal. Treas. Reg. § 53.4958-3(c) puts voting directors, presidents, executive directors and treasurers in that group automatically, along with their family members and any corporation, partnership or trust in which they hold more than 35 percent. A benefit routed through the insider’s own LLC counts as one provided indirectly (Treas. Reg. § 53.4958-4(a)(2)).

    Why did the Tax Court refuse to treat the Jagannath note as a real loan?

    In Jagannath v. Commissioner, T.C. Memo. 2026-92, $590,000 left the charity’s money market account on April 4, 2016. Eleven days later the president signed an interest-free note for the charity as lender and for Pingala Group, LLC, his single-member company, as borrower. Nothing was repaid. The charity’s 2016 and 2017 returns showed the $590,000 as a receivable from officers, without the required Schedule L, Part II.

    At trial he dropped the loan theory, pointing instead to a December 2016 wire and a 2018 building purchase. Judge Weiler trusted the bank records and the original Forms 990 (no amended returns were offered), found no consideration, and taxed all $590,000. With real debt, the fight would have been over the value of free interest. A note the borrower approves for the lender also never reaches the rebuttable presumption of reasonableness in Treas. Reg. § 53.4958-6, which needs advance approval by an unconflicted body relying on comparable data, with minutes kept at the time.

    The Tenth Circuit has said little. My search found only Farr v. Commissioner, No. 18-9002 (10th Cir. Oct. 1, 2018), unpublished, affirming both tiers against a charity head who argued, among other things, that personal charges on its account repaid her own loans.

    How do the 25 percent, 200 percent and manager taxes add up?

    The insider owes 25 percent of the excess benefit under § 4958(a)(1), and § 4958(b) adds 200 percent if it is not corrected within the “taxable period.” A manager who knowingly participated owes 10 percent under § 4958(a)(2), unless the participation was not willful and was due to reasonable cause, with a $20,000 ceiling per transaction (§ 4958(d)(2)). The IRS must prove the knowing part (26 U.S.C. § 7454(b)), and relying on a reasoned written professional opinion ordinarily defeats it (Treas. Reg. § 53.4958-1(d)(4)(iii)).

    Jagannath ran $147,500 plus $1,180,000. Ten percent of $590,000 is $59,000, which is why the manager tax the IRS conceded before trial was exactly $20,000.

    Under Treas. Reg. § 53.6011-1(b), anyone owing § 4958(a) tax also files Form 4720 for the year of the transaction, due May 15 for a calendar-year individual (§ 53.6071-1(f)). He never did, and the court sustained additions under 26 U.S.C. § 6651(a)(1) and (2). The notice’s figures, $33,187.50 and $36,875, equal 22.5 and 25 percent of the first-tier tax.

    Nonprofit Insider Loan Under Exam? Contact Us Now

    Does repaying the loan before the IRS mails a notice of deficiency still matter?

    Yes, though it is not the last chance. The taxable period ends when the IRS mails a notice of deficiency for the 25 percent tax or assesses it (§ 4958(f)(5)). Correct inside that window and the 200 percent tax never arises. If an examiner has already opened the year, get the IRS’s correction figure in writing and pay before the notice issues. Correction under Treas. Reg. § 53.4958-7 means repaying in cash, never with a new note, plus interest compounded annually at least at the applicable federal rate for the transaction month.

    Section 4961(a) wipes out the 200 percent tax if correction comes within the “correction period,” which under § 4963(e) runs 90 days past the notice and stretches while a Tax Court case bars assessment. The 25 percent tax is abated under § 4962 only with correction plus reasonable cause, a hard showing for someone who signed both sides.

    In February 2020 the IRS told Mr. Jagannath correction required $590,000 plus $26,215.21 of interest. The opinion never mentions § 4961. Rule 155 computations are due December 27, 2026, so no decision exists to appeal, and an appeal would go to the Sixth Circuit, where he lived. On my reading of § 4963(e), his correction period may still be open.

    What would a $120,000 insider loan cost a Farmington nonprofit?

    Illustration only: on November 4, 2024, the executive director of a Farmington youth-services nonprofit moves $120,000 to her solely owned LLC to close on a duplex, signing an interest-free note for both sides. The treasurer, who knows the LLC is hers, releases the wire without a board vote.

    Her first-tier tax is $30,000. Left uncorrected until a notice of deficiency, the second tier adds $240,000. The 10 percent manager tax is $12,000, under the cap, and if the IRS proves knowledge she and the treasurer are jointly and severally liable for it. That makes $282,000 before additions for her missed May 15, 2025 Form 4720.

    Now suppose she pays $129,792 in cash on November 4, 2026, before any notice. That is $120,000 plus two years at 4.00 percent, the November 2024 short-term rate in Rev. Rul. 2024-24, compounded annually. The $240,000 never arises; the $30,000 and any manager tax remain.

    Can New Mexico law or the IRS also reach the board and the nonprofit?

    The IRS can also pursue exemption, because private inurement of net earnings to insiders disqualifies a charity (Treas. Reg. § 1.501(c)(3)-1(c)(2)). Under § 1.501(c)(3)-1(f)(2) the IRS compares the benefit with the charity’s programs and then looks hard at what the board did, and correction after the IRS discovers the problem is never enough alone. Collecting the cash and adopting a conflict policy before any exam counts most. Report the transaction as an excess benefit on Schedule L, Part I, not as a loan in Part II; for an earlier year, Part IV, line 25b of the next return asks about it (see also the firm’s note on the Form 990 rewrite). What follows a revocation is in the firm’s post on 501(c)(3) revocation and section 7428.

    Gross receipts tax follows the federal answer. NMSA 1978, § 7-9-29(A) exempts receipts of organizations the IRS has recognized under 501(c)(3), so an insider loan alone changes nothing, while a revocation removes the footing.

    NMSA 1978, § 53-8-29 does not ban these loans or offer a disinterested-vote safe harbor; it says a director or officer “who assents to or participates in the making of any loan to a director or officer shall be personally liable to the corporation for the amount of the loan until the repayment thereof.” Whether it reaches a loan to a director’s LLC is a question for New Mexico counsel. The Charitable Solicitations Act sets a trustee’s standard of care (§ 57-22-10), puts the Form 990 in the Attorney General’s file each year (§ 57-22-6), and lets the Attorney General investigate and seek restitution (§ 57-22-9).

    Who Exposure Amount How it is avoided or reduced
    Disqualified person First-tier tax, § 4958(a)(1) 25% of excess benefit Abated only with correction plus reasonable cause (§ 4962)
    Disqualified person Second-tier tax, § 4958(b) 200% of excess benefit Correct before the notice, or within the correction period (§ 4961)
    Knowing organization managers Manager tax, § 4958(a)(2) 10%, capped at $20,000 per transaction IRS bears the burden on knowledge; reasoned written opinion
    The nonprofit Revocation for inurement Loss of 501(c)(3) and the GRT exemption Correction and safeguards before an exam
    New Mexico directors and officers NMSA § 53-8-29 Unpaid balance, owed to the nonprofit Repayment ends the liability

    Frequently Asked Questions

    Is an interest-free loan to a nonprofit director automatically an excess benefit transaction?

    Not for most public charities. On my reading, a real loan is measured mainly by the forgone interest, but a note nobody expects repaid can be taxed in full, as in Jagannath. Supporting organizations are different, because § 4958(c)(3) treats any loan to a disqualified person as an excess benefit.

    Who files Form 4720 for an excess benefit transaction?

    The disqualified person files it personally, as does any manager who owes the 10 percent tax. A calendar-year individual’s return is due May 15 of the following year.

    Can a nonprofit pay the excise tax for its executive director?

    It can, but not for free. Under Treas. Reg. § 53.4958-4(b)(1)(ii)(B)(2), a charity’s payment or reimbursement of a section 4958 tax counts as compensation to the insider. If her pay was already at market, the reimbursement becomes a second excess benefit.

    Does repaying the loan after the IRS opens an examination help?

    Yes. Cash repayment with interest ahead of the deficiency notice prevents the 200 percent tax, and correction within the later correction period abates it. Correction made after the IRS finds the problem does not, by itself, protect exemption.

    Are New Mexico board members personally liable for a loan to the executive director?

    Potentially, twice over. A manager who knowingly participated owes the federal 10 percent tax, up to $20,000 per transaction. Under NMSA § 53-8-29, a director or officer who assented to or participated in a loan to a director or officer is liable to the corporation until it is repaid.

    How North Star Law Firm Can Help

    North Star Law Firm represents disqualified persons and organization managers in IRS examinations of Form 990 insider transactions, computes correction amounts, and contests section 4958 notices in Tax Court litigation. It also seeks penalty abatement where a missed Form 4720 had reasonable cause.

    Phillip Zagotti, JD/CPA, represents taxpayers before the IRS and the U.S. Tax Court and is admitted to the U.S. District Court and Bankruptcy Court for the District of New Mexico. The firm works alongside New Mexico-licensed counsel on state-law questions. If an insider note is sitting on your nonprofit’s balance sheet, contact North Star Law Firm.


  • Tax Court Trials From New Mexico: Albuquerque, El Paso or Lubbock, and the S Case Box

    Tax Court Trials From New Mexico: Albuquerque, El Paso or Lubbock, and the S Case Box

    An oilfield services owner in Hobbs opens a notice of deficiency for 2024 and pulls up the Tax Court’s petition form. Two items look like paperwork. One is a box asking whether the case should run as a small tax case. The other is a separate sheet, Form 5, asking where the trial should be held, and New Mexico’s row has exactly one city.

    In September the Tax Court changed that list and how it may manage cases before trial. For someone in Lea County, the practical questions are which courtroom will actually sit and what the small-case box gives up. Then there is whether a trial across the Texas line changes the law.

    Where are the Tax Court trial locations for New Mexico after the 2026 changes?

    Still Albuquerque, and only Albuquerque. The Tax Court’s September 8, 2026 announcement added Austin, Charlotte, Newark, Orlando and Sacramento for 79 in all, and dropped none. The Court’s current list of trial cities shows Albuquerque as the lone New Mexico entry, with no permanent courtroom. The announcement rests on 26 U.S.C. § 7446, which asks for sessions “with as little inconvenience and expense to taxpayers as is practicable.”

    Opening every city to regular cases adds nothing for Albuquerque. Some cities used to be reserved for small cases, and the Court’s 2008 version of Form 5 flagged them with an asterisk (Cheyenne and Wichita among them). Albuquerque had none, and the Spring 2026 schedule set a hybrid session there, small and regular cases together, for the week of May 4, 2026.

    Can a New Mexico taxpayer request a Tax Court trial in El Paso, Lubbock or Denver?

    Yes. Tax Court Rule 140(a) requires a place-of-trial request with each Tax Court petition, and the Court makes “reasonable efforts” to try the case at the location “most convenient to that requested.” Nothing ties it to your home state; the current Form 5 says you “may choose any location that is convenient to you.” Switching later takes a motion under Rule 140(b).

    How often a city sits matters too. I went through the five posted schedules from Fall 2025 through Winter 2027, which the Court labels forecasts. Albuquerque appears once, that May 2026 session; Spring 2027 is not posted yet. El Paso and Lubbock share a swing session, one judge covering both, held the week of March 16, 2026 and set again for January 25, 2027. Denver sat in four of the five terms, five sessions in all. So did Phoenix, though none of its five falls in 2027.

    In a straight line, Lubbock is about 100 miles from Hobbs or Clovis, and Las Cruces about 40 from El Paso. Raton, though, is nearer Albuquerque than Denver, and Gallup is half as far from Albuquerque as from Phoenix, so the pull of those cities is frequency and a permanent courtroom. Tucson is not a place of trial.

    Should a New Mexico petitioner make the small tax case election (S case)?

    Under 26 U.S.C. § 7463(a), a deficiency case qualifies if no more than $50,000 is contested for any one taxable year, and § 7463(e) counts penalties toward that figure. Rule 174(b) calls for trials “as informally as possible consistent with orderly procedure.”

    The cost is § 7463(b): an S decision “shall not be reviewed in any other court and shall not be treated as a precedent for any other case.” Neither side can appeal. For a self-represented owner arguing about receipts, that trade often makes sense. Where the issue is legal and will come back next year, I usually think it does not.

    The box is not locked on filing day. Rule 171(c) allows an S request any time before trial, the IRS may oppose one by motion, and Rule 171(d) lets the Court remove the designation on its own or on a motion made before trial starts. Afterward, § 7463(d) permits discontinuance only if the amount appears to exceed the limit by enough to justify it. Leave both boxes blank and, per the Court’s petition kit, the case is filed as regular.

    Filing a Tax Court Petition? Contact Us Now

    Does a Tax Court trial in El Paso put a New Mexico case in the Fifth Circuit?

    No. The appeal follows the taxpayer. Under 26 U.S.C. § 7482(b)(1)(A), an individual’s appeal goes to the circuit of legal residence on the day the petition was filed, so a Las Cruces resident tried in Texas still has a Tenth Circuit case, with 90 days to appeal under § 7483. The exception, in § 7482(b)(2), is a written stipulation with the IRS naming another circuit.

    That shapes the trial itself because of Golsen v. Commissioner, 54 T.C. 742 (1970), aff’d, 445 F.2d 985 (10th Cir. 1971), where the Tax Court agreed to follow a circuit decision “squarely in point” when appeal lies to that circuit alone. The El Paso judge applies Tenth Circuit law to the New Mexico petitioner and Fifth Circuit law to the local resident called next.

    Equitable tolling shows why. The reviewed opinion in Sanders v. Commissioner, 161 T.C. 112 (2023), kept the § 6213(a) deadline jurisdictional and said the Third Circuit’s contrary Culp v. Commissioner, 75 F.4th 196 (3d Cir. 2023), did not trigger Golsen for a Fourth Circuit case. The Sixth Circuit joined Culp in Oquendo v. Commissioner, No. 24-1205 (6th Cir. Aug. 25, 2025). The Tenth Circuit still has Foster v. Commissioner, 445 F.2d 799 (10th Cir. 1971), treating a late petition as a jurisdictional defect. A late filer from Ohio can argue tolling; one from Hobbs cannot, whatever city hears it. The firm’s post on the 90-day deadline and tolling covers the rest.

    What is the Tax Court’s reporting calendar pilot, and what would it change in New Mexico?

    Little is published. “Beginning no earlier than for the Fall 2027 term,” the announcement says, some cases may go on a reporting calendar instead of a trial calendar. Rather than a trial date, the case gets a judge and “a standing scheduling order governing pretrial proceedings.” More detail is promised first, and the Court’s May 2026 proposed rule amendments, on practitioner admission and discipline, do not touch it.

    Today a case waits for a trial notice and a standing pretrial order whose deadlines count back from trial. The pilot reverses that. For a self-represented petitioner in Artesia or Portales, I would expect the informal exchange to start sooner. Rule 70(a)(1) expects informal consultation before formal discovery, which Branerton Corp. v. Commissioner, 61 T.C. 691 (1974), said “means exactly what it says,” and Rule 91(a)(1) requires stipulation “to the fullest extent” the parties can fairly agree.

    That is my inference. The Court has not said which cases or cities are in, or whether S cases qualify, and the order’s dates are unknown.

    Can a New Mexico Tax Court trial be held remotely on Zoomgov?

    Yes, if the judge agrees. Administrative Order 2021-01 keeps in-person trial as the default but lets “either party” file a Motion to Proceed Remotely up to 31 days before the session, granted at the judge’s discretion. The January 2026 sample standing pretrial order repeats that deadline; Rule 140 is not the vehicle. Stand-alone remote sessions are set for the weeks of November 16 and December 14, 2026.

    From Clovis, a laptop beats any drive. It works less well when credibility is the whole case. I decide after the stipulation is drafted.

    How would a Hobbs oilfield services owner weigh an S case in Albuquerque or Lubbock?

    Illustration only. The IRS determines a $38,000 deficiency for 2024 after disallowing equipment rental and subcontract labor, plus the 20 percent accuracy penalty under 26 U.S.C. § 6662(a), $7,600. With the penalty counted, $45,600 is in dispute, under the $50,000 line.

    If the fight is over whether crews were paid, with records in Lea County and crew leads who would lose a workday to testify, I would lean toward an S case in Lubbock, about 100 miles away against roughly 260 to Albuquerque. If it turns on a legal reading, say whether the rent was really an installment purchase of equipment, a regular case keeps the Tenth Circuit open, and the city matters less because the appeal goes to Denver either way.

    Option for the Hobbs owner Sessions, Fall 2025 to Winter 2027 Appeal Best fit
    S case, Lubbock El Paso/Lubbock swing, March 2026 and January 2027 None, § 7463(b) Fact disputes with local witnesses
    S case, Albuquerque One hybrid session, May 2026 None Advisors or records near the Rio Grande
    Regular case, Lubbock Same swing session Tenth Circuit, § 7482(b)(1)(A) Legal issues that will recur
    Regular case, Denver Five sessions in four terms Tenth Circuit Most frequent regional calendar, long trip
    Remote (Zoomgov) Remote calendars each term Depends on S status Motion to Proceed Remotely, 31 days out

    Frequently Asked Questions

    Is Albuquerque the only Tax Court trial city in New Mexico?

    Yes. It is the only New Mexico location among the Court’s 79 places of trial, and it has no permanent courtroom. El Paso, Lubbock, Denver and Phoenix are the nearest alternatives.

    Can I change my place of trial after filing?

    Yes, by a motion under Rule 140(b) stating the reasons. A motion filed after the trial notice may be denied as dilatory unless the reason arose later or there was good cause for waiting.

    Can I appeal a small tax case decision to the Tenth Circuit?

    No. Section 7463(b) bars review in any other court, for you and the IRS alike. To keep that option, file as regular or move before trial to remove the S designation.

    Does the $50,000 small tax case limit include penalties?

    Yes, in a deficiency case. The limit applies year by year, so a three-year dispute can qualify if no single year goes over $50,000.

    When does the reporting calendar pilot start?

    No earlier than the Fall 2027 term. The Court has not said which cases will be included and has promised more information first.

    How North Star Law Firm Can Help

    North Star Law Firm handles Tax Court litigation for New Mexico taxpayers, from the place-of-trial request through trial, and represents them in IRS Appeals and collection due process hearings. Its tax defense work starts earlier, with which forum to use at all.

    Phillip Zagotti, JD/CPA, represents taxpayers before the IRS and the U.S. Tax Court and is admitted to the U.S. District Court and Bankruptcy Court for the District of New Mexico. The firm works alongside New Mexico-licensed counsel on state-law questions. If a notice of deficiency has you choosing between Albuquerque, Lubbock and the small-case box, contact North Star Law Firm.