Brenda and Clay lived as husband and wife in Muleshoe, Texas, from 2015 to 2022, signing a lease and insurance forms there as spouses, though they never had a ceremony. In 2022 they moved to Portales. Since then Brenda, a school district employee with $58,000 in W-2 wages, has filed as head of household with her daughter. Clay hauls hay, nets about $74,000, files as single, and owes the IRS about $41,000 for 2022 through 2024. A neighbor told them New Mexico “has no common law marriage,” so after eleven years together they are single here.
Brenda and Clay are fictional, and their neighbor is half right. New Mexico will not let a couple become married by living together here, but it honors a marriage valid where it was made, and it is a community property state. That produces two opposite tax mistakes.
Does New Mexico recognize a common law marriage from Texas or Colorado?
Yes, if the marriage was valid where it was formed. Marriage here is a civil contract under NMSA 1978, § 40-1-1, and requires a county clerk’s license under § 40-1-10. In re Gabaldon’s Estate, 38 N.M. 392, 34 P.2d 672 (1934) held that no common law marriage can be formed in this state. But § 40-1-4 makes marriages celebrated elsewhere valid here if they were valid where celebrated.
The New Mexico Supreme Court applied that rule to a Texas informal marriage in Gallegos v. Wilkerson, 79 N.M. 549, 445 P.2d 970 (1968), where the couple lived in El Paso and held themselves out as spouses. In In re Estate of Lamb, 99 N.M. 157, 655 P.2d 1001 (1982), by contrast, repeating vows during a day or two at an El Paso hotel was not enough contact with Texas.
Texas Family Code § 2.401(a)(2) looks for an agreement to be married, living together in Texas as spouses, and representing to others in Texas that they were married. Colorado asks whether the couple mutually agreed to enter marriage and then acted on it, under In re Marriage of Hogsett & Neale, 2021 CO 1. Whether a couple qualifies is a question for counsel in that state; if they do, the marriage lasts until divorce, annulment or death.
Is a Texas informal marriage still a marriage for IRS filing status in New Mexico?
Yes. Treas. Reg. § 301.7701-18(b)(1) recognizes a marriage for federal tax purposes if the state where it was entered into recognizes it, “regardless of domicile.” The IRS took that position for common law marriages in Rev. Rul. 58-66, as described in Rev. Rul. 2013-17, even after a move to a state that requires a ceremony.
Marital status is fixed on the last day of the year under 26 U.S.C. § 7703(a)(1). Head of household under § 2(b)(1) requires that the filer be “not married at the close of his taxable year,” and § 7703(b) treats a married parent as unmarried only if the other spouse was out of the household for the last six months of the year. Clay lives in the house, so their real choices were always joint or separate.
How does married filing separately work with community property in New Mexico?
Under NMSA 1978, § 40-3-8(B), community property is property acquired by either or both spouses during marriage that is not separate property, and § 40-3-12(A) presumes property acquired during marriage is community. Federal tax follows that ownership: Poe v. Seaborn, 282 U.S. 101 (1930) let Washington spouses each report half of their community income.
IRS Publication 555 (Rev. December 2024) counts wages earned during the marriage in New Mexico or Texas as community income and requires each spouse filing separately to report half of all community income plus all separate income, with Form 8958 attached. Each spouse also claims half the tax withheld from community wages. Self-employment tax does not split; under § 1402(a)(5)(A) it follows the spouse carrying on the business.
Not knowing is a weak defense. In United States v. Mitchell, 403 U.S. 190 (1971), wives who knew little about the community income owed tax on their half. The relief lies in § 66(c) for separate filers and § 6015 for joint filers. How far the IRS can reach community assets for one spouse’s debt is covered in our post on community property and IRS tax debt in New Mexico.
What does the wrong filing status cost in an illustrative Portales example?
Take tax year 2025, with the 2025 standard deductions after the 2025 tax act ($15,750 single or separate, $31,500 joint, $23,625 head of household) and the 2025 brackets in Rev. Proc. 2024-40. I ignore credits and other deductions except the deduction for half of Clay’s self-employment tax (the tax itself is about $10,460 in every version).
As filed, Brenda’s income tax is about $3,790 and Clay’s about $6,580, roughly $10,360 together. Jointly, it is about $10,960. Separately with the community split, each reports $29,000 of her wages and $37,000 of his profit; her tax is about $5,970 and his about $5,160, roughly $11,130.
The correct status costs roughly $600 to $800 a year, because head of household brackets were never theirs. The bigger change is whose name the tax sits under: separately, Brenda’s share rises by more than half. An underpayment from the wrong status can also draw the 20 percent accuracy penalty in § 6662(a) if the IRS shows negligence.
Cleanup has clocks. The IRS has three years after filing to assess under § 6501(a), with a parallel refund window in § 6511(a). Section 6013(b) lets spouses who filed married filing separately switch to a joint return, but under § 6013(b)(2)(A) not more than three years after the original due date. Brenda and Clay filed as head of household and single. The Eighth Circuit in Ibrahim v. Commissioner, 788 F.3d 834 (8th Cir. 2015) and the Tax Court in Camara v. Commissioner, 149 T.C. No. 13 (2017), held that a return wrongly claiming one of those statuses is not a “separate return,” so that bar did not apply; the IRS argued the opposite in both cases, and I found no Tenth Circuit decision on those facts. Electing joint is not automatic: § 6013(d)(3) makes joint filers jointly and severally liable, putting Brenda on the hook for Clay’s unpaid tax for those years.
We only ever lived together in New Mexico. Can we file a joint return?
No, however long you have been together. Merrill v. Davis, 100 N.M. 552, 673 P.2d 1285 (1983) refused to read cohabitation as an implied agreement to share property. Unmarried partners have no community property and no income splitting.
Section 6013(a) lets only a husband and wife file jointly. A “joint” return signed by two unmarried people is not a valid joint return; each owes tax on his or her own income, and the joint and several liability of § 6013(d)(3) should not attach. I rest on the statute here; I found no opinion on these facts. A partner keeping a home for his or her own qualifying child may file as head of household.
Can an unmarried New Mexico couple file a joint bankruptcy petition?
No. 11 U.S.C. § 302(a) allows a joint case only for an individual “and such individual’s spouse,” and the Albuquerque bankruptcy court looked to state law on that question in In re Cohen, No. 7-10-15616 JR (Bankr. D.N.M. Feb. 7, 2012). I found no Tenth Circuit or Tenth Circuit BAP decision on a debtor claiming a common law spouse. Unmarried partners need two cases, each with $338 in Chapter 7 filing fees (28 U.S.C. § 1930(a)(1)(A) and the Bankruptcy Court Miscellaneous Fee Schedule effective December 1, 2023).
If Clay files alone, § 541(a)(2) brings community property under his management or liable for his debts into his estate. In exchange, § 524(a)(3) protects later acquired community property from discharged community claims, subject to § 524(b) and to debts that are not discharged. His IRS debt turns on the three year, two year and 240 day rules in § 507(a)(8)(A) and § 523(a)(1). Late returns matter: in Mallo v. IRS, 774 F.3d 1313 (10th Cir. 2014), a Form 1040 filed after the IRS assessed the tax was not a “return,” and the debt survived. See our post on the automatic stay and the spouse who did not file.
| Couple | Married for federal tax? | Community property here; return options | Joint bankruptcy petition? |
|---|---|---|---|
| Informally married in Texas, moved here | Yes, if valid in Texas | Yes; joint, or separate with half each | Yes |
| Common law married in Colorado, moved here | Yes, if valid in Colorado | Yes; joint, or separate with half each | Yes |
| Lived together only in New Mexico | No | No; each files on own income | No; two cases |
| Ceremonially married anywhere | Yes | Yes; joint or separate | Yes |
Frequently Asked Questions
We were common law married in Texas. Can I file head of household in New Mexico?
Usually not. You must be unmarried on December 31, and a married parent counts as unmarried only if the other spouse lived elsewhere for the last six months.
Do I report half of my spouse’s income on a separate return?
If you are married and domiciled in New Mexico, generally yes. Each spouse reports half of the community income and all separate income, with Form 8958 showing the split.
Does New Mexico recognize common law marriage?
A couple cannot form one here, but New Mexico recognizes one validly formed in another state.
Can we switch from separate returns to a joint return later?
If you filed married filing separately, often yes, within three years after the original due date, unless a Tax Court petition, refund suit, closing agreement or compromise cuts it off. A joint return makes both spouses liable for the full tax for that year.
Does leaving Texas start the two year clock on a Texas informal marriage?
No. The presumption in Family Code § 2.401(b) runs from when the couple separated and stopped living together, not from a move together.
How North Star Law Firm Can Help
North Star Law Firm helps New Mexico couples whose out of state marriage never made it onto their returns, including unfiled or incorrect returns, innocent spouse relief, broader IRS tax defense and, where the numbers call for it, Chapter 7.
Phillip Zagotti, JD/CPA, represents taxpayers before the IRS and the U.S. Tax Court and is admitted to the U.S. District Court and Bankruptcy Court for the District of New Mexico. The firm works alongside New Mexico-licensed counsel on state-law questions. If you moved here from Texas or Colorado as a couple and have been filing as single, contact North Star Law Firm.








