Harlan runs cattle outside Clayton. In November 2020 he lent his son-in-law $240,000 for feedlot equipment and a truck, took a signed security agreement, and on March 12, 2021 filed a UCC-1 financing statement with the New Mexico Secretary of State. On January 20, 2026 the son-in-law filed Chapter 7 in Albuquerque. He filed a secured claim. Nobody remembered the five-year clock, March 12, 2026 passed, and now the trustee says the lapsed filing leaves Harlan in line with the credit card companies.
A Utah bankruptcy judge answered this lapsed financing statement question for a father who lent to his son. The Tenth Circuit has not, but the Utah ruling rests on uniform text New Mexico shares.
Does a lapsed financing statement in bankruptcy make a New Mexico lender unsecured?
Against the Chapter 7 trustee, probably not, if the lien was perfected on the petition date. That is the holding of Thomson v. Short (In re Short), 669 B.R. 81 (Bankr. D. Utah 2025), Adv. No. 22-02004. Raymond Short’s UCC-1 against his son’s personal property was filed in October 2015, the son filed Chapter 7 on December 31, 2019, and the five years ran out the following October. Judge Anderson ruled that “The Claim was perfected on the petition date, and that status controls” despite the lapse.
Two grounds carried it. Under Utah’s UCC 9-515(c), lapse is retroactive only against “a purchaser of the collateral for value,” and a trustee is a lien creditor, not a purchaser. And the court applied the freeze rule (rights are fixed at the petition date), relying on Official Comment 4 to 9-515. Utah’s § 70A-9a-515 has no bankruptcy tolling clause; the bankruptcy language is the comment’s. The lapse ruling first issued May 2, 2023; the May 9, 2025 amended decision corrected the allowed amount to $24,417.60. I found no appeal.
What does New Mexico’s 55-9-515 say about a lapse during bankruptcy?
Nothing specific. NMSA 1978, § 55-9-515 is the uniform text, last amended in 2013. A filed financing statement “is effective for a period of five years after the date of filing” (subsection (a)). Upon lapse the security interest “becomes unperfected unless the security interest is perfected otherwise,” and “it is deemed never to have been perfected as against a purchaser of the collateral for value” (subsection (c)). The section has no insolvency or bankruptcy language, and I found no 2025 or 2026 amendment.
Short did not need a tolling statute either. New Mexico defines “purchase” as a taking by sale, lien, security interest or “any other voluntary transaction” (§ 55-1-201(b)(29)), and a purchaser under (b)(30) takes by purchase. A judicial lien is not voluntary. Section 55-9-102(a)(52)(C) makes “a trustee in bankruptcy from the date of the filing of the petition” a lien creditor, and 11 U.S.C. § 544(a)(1) gives the trustee that lien “as of the commencement of the case.” On the petition date Harlan was perfected and ahead of the trustee.
Secured Claim Being Challenged? Contact Us Now
Has the Tenth Circuit or the New Mexico bankruptcy court decided the In re Short freeze rule question?
Not under current Article 9, as far as I could find. The closest New Mexico case is old. In Bond Enterprises, Inc. v. Western Bank of Farmington (In re Bond Enterprises, Inc.), 54 B.R. 366 (Bankr. D.N.M. 1985), Judge McFeeley held that a liquor-license lien due to expire mid-case “does not lapse where the creditor fails to file a continuation statement.” That was former law, and its view that a continuation filing would violate the stay is outdated. In re Wilkinson, No. 10-62223 (Bankr. N.D.N.Y. Apr. 10, 2012), still relied on it to protect a mother’s lien on a dairy herd she sold her son.
The Tenth Circuit case the Short trustee relied on cuts both ways. In re Reliance Equities, Inc., 966 F.2d 1338 (10th Cir. 1992), refused to freeze a temporary automatic perfection that expired after the filing, but said “No secret liens are created when perfection occurs by means of a financing statement.” Elsewhere the majority follows In re Chaseley’s Foods, Inc., 726 F.2d 303 (7th Cir. 1983), and In re Essex Construction, LLC, 591 B.R. 630 (Bankr. D. Md. 2018). In re Hilyard Drilling Co., 840 F.2d 596 (8th Cir. 1988), sometimes cited here, involved a lapse nine months before the petition.
I expect a D.N.M. judge would side with Harlan against a Chapter 7 trustee, given Reliance’s secret-lien reasoning. The trustee’s best point is the comment’s own statement that subsection (c) “deletes the former tolling provision” and imposes “a new burden” on the secured party. In a Chapter 11 or 13, though, a lender who later finances the retained equipment is a purchaser, and a lapse can cost priority.
Can I file a UCC continuation statement in New Mexico after the debtor files bankruptcy?
Yes. Section 362(a)(4) stays acts to “create, perfect, or enforce” a lien, but § 362(b)(3) excepts any act “to maintain or continue the perfection of” an interest to the extent § 546(b) subjects the trustee to it, wording added in 1994. Section 546(b)(1)(B) subjects the trustee to law that “provides for the maintenance or continuation of perfection.” Comment 4 says the secured party may continue “without first obtaining relief from the automatic stay.” Essex adds that the exception “does not require a creditor to do anything.”
The window is strict. Section 55-9-515(d) allows a continuation “only within six months before” the five-year mark, and § 55-9-510(c) makes an early one ineffective. A timely continuation adds five years from the original lapse date (§ 55-9-515(e)). The Secretary of State’s online filing guide (March 2024) lists a $20 fee for a UCC-3.
The truck is separate. Under § 55-9-311(a)(2), a financing statement “is not necessary or effective” for property governed by Chapter 66, the Motor Vehicle Code, so Harlan’s truck lien depends on the title.
What else does a trustee check on a family loan secured in bankruptcy?
Insider status. A “relative of the debtor” is an insider under 11 U.S.C. § 101(31)(A)(i), and the definition of relative in § 101(45) reaches in-laws. Insiders face a one-year preference look-back (§ 547(b)(4)(B)), and under § 547(e)(2) a lien perfected more than 30 days after it attached counts as transferred when perfected. A relative who files once trouble starts can lose the lien that way (see the firm’s post on preference defense). Short shows the scrutiny: the court disallowed $105,000 tied to a 1998 loan first written up in 2015.
Then the paperwork. Attachment needs a signed security agreement that “provides a description of the collateral” (§ 55-9-203(b)(3)(A)), and “all the debtor’s assets” will not do (§ 55-9-108(c)). The proof of claim must attach the writing and “evidence that the security interest has been perfected” (Fed. R. Bankr. P. 3001(c)(1), (d)). Claim objections go on 30 days’ notice (Rule 3007(a)(1)), but a challenge to “the validity, priority, or extent of a lien” is an adversary proceeding (Rule 7001(b)), which is how Short got there.
A valid lien is secured only “to the extent of the value” of the collateral (§ 506(a)(1)). The debtor can avoid “a nonpossessory, nonpurchase-money security interest” in tools of the trade that impairs an exemption (§ 522(f)(1)(B)), but Harlan’s loan bought the equipment, making it a purchase-money obligation under § 55-9-103(a)(2). The 2023 overhaul set a $15,000 trade-equipment exemption in NMSA 1978, § 42-10-1(A)(5), adjusted for inflation every two years starting July 1, 2025 (§ 42-10-14), and repealed § 42-10-2 (see the 2023 exemption overhaul).
What happens when a UCC-1 lapses during a New Mexico Chapter 7?
Illustration only. Filed March 12, 2021, the UCC-1 reached its five-year mark March 12, 2026, and the continuation window opened September 12, 2025. The January 20, 2026 petition fell inside it. Say $205,000 is owed and the trustee sells the equipment for $150,000.
If Harlan does nothing, he argues Short: perfected on January 20, and nothing in § 55-9-515 makes the trustee a purchaser. The trustee answers with the comment’s “new burden” language and the missing Tenth Circuit ruling. If Harlan wins, § 506(a) gives him a $150,000 secured claim and a $55,000 unsecured one.
The fix was cheap. A $20 UCC-3 filed between September 12, 2025 and March 12, 2026 would have continued the filing, with § 362(b)(3) covering the days after January 20.
| Scenario | Against the trustee | Against a later purchaser or lender | Risk |
|---|---|---|---|
| Continuation filed before the petition | Perfected | Perfected | Low |
| Lapse during the case, no continuation | Likely perfected under Short and the majority view | Deemed never perfected (§ 55-9-515(c)) | Litigation; no Tenth Circuit ruling |
| Continuation filed during the case | Perfected; § 362(b)(3) stay exception | Perfected | Low if inside the window |
| Never perfected | Avoidable under § 544(a) | Subordinate | High |
| Insider perfects late, within one year | Preference exposure (§ 547(b)(4)(B), (e)(2)) | Perfected from filing | High |
Frequently Asked Questions
Does my lien disappear if my UCC-1 lapses after the debtor files bankruptcy?
Not automatically. Most courts, including Short, hold that perfection on the petition date controls against the trustee. Against a later purchaser for value, the lapse does count.
Does New Mexico law pause the five-year lapse during bankruptcy?
No. NMSA 1978, § 55-9-515 has no tolling language, and the official comment says the old tolling rule was deleted. Any protection comes from bankruptcy law.
Do I need court permission to file a continuation statement during a bankruptcy?
No. Section 362(b)(3) excepts acts to maintain or continue perfection from the automatic stay. File the UCC-3 within the six months before the fifth anniversary.
Is a loan to a family member treated differently in bankruptcy?
Often. A relative is an insider, so the preference look-back is one year instead of 90 days. Courts also look hard at whether an insider loan was real and documented when made.
Can the debtor wipe out my lien on equipment I financed?
Not under § 522(f)(1)(B) if your loan paid for the equipment, because that power reaches only nonpurchase-money liens. The trustee can still contest validity, perfection or value.
How North Star Law Firm Can Help
North Star Law Firm represents secured creditors and family lenders in New Mexico bankruptcy cases, including Chapter 7 claim objections, Chapter 11 lien disputes, and preference and clawback defense.
Phillip Zagotti, JD/CPA, is admitted to the U.S. District Court and Bankruptcy Court for the District of New Mexico and represents taxpayers before the IRS and the U.S. Tax Court. The firm works alongside New Mexico-licensed counsel on state-law questions. If a trustee calls your claim unsecured because a filing lapsed, contact North Star Law Firm.
