Marisol runs an HVAC and plumbing contractor in Silver City. A slow summer and two merchant cash advances have left the company owing $410,000: $140,000 on an SBA EIDL loan, $95,000 to a parts supplier owned by her brother-in-law, $60,000 in payroll taxes, $70,000 to two MCA funders and $45,000 to the bank. The account holds $85,000. She wants to pay her brother-in-law and the IRS and let the MCA companies wait.
Marisol is fictional; the question is not. New Mexico lets a struggling business choose whom to pay, with two big exceptions: a state rule aimed at insiders, and a bankruptcy trustee’s power to reverse recent payments. The creditor she most wants to pay is the one most likely to have to give the money back.
Listen to this post
North Star Tax and Legal Briefing: Can a Struggling New Mexico Business Pay One Creditor First? Preferences and the UVTA
A struggling New Mexico business can usually choose which creditors to pay, but a payment to a family member's company is the one most likely to be clawed back. This episode walks through New Mexico's insider preference rule, the bankruptcy trustee's 90 day and one year windows, why IRS trust fund taxes are treated differently, and a safer payment order.
Download the MP3 · Episode page on Podbean
Show / hide the episode transcript
Picture a New Mexico contractor in Silver City. Call her Marisol. She is fictional, but her problem is not. Her company owes four hundred ten thousand dollars: an E I D L loan, a parts supplier owned by the owner’s brother-in-law, sixty thousand in payroll taxes, two merchant cash advance funders, and the bank. The account holds eighty five thousand. Marisol wants to pay her brother-in-law and the I R S first, and let the merchant cash advance companies wait. That instinct is human. It is also the choice most likely to get reversed. In New Mexico, the creditor you most want to pay is often the one who ends up handing the money back, and the clock on that can run a full year.
A struggling business is generally allowed to choose whom it pays. The Supreme Court said so back in eighteen thirty eight: a debtor may prefer one creditor, pay him in full, and exhaust his whole property. New Mexico’s Uniform Voidable Transactions Act keeps that rule. Paying an unrelated creditor what you owe is a fair exchange, dollar for dollar, and the Tenth Circuit confirmed that in twenty twenty five. The question is which picks get undone, and two systems can undo them. The state act reaches insiders with no bankruptcy filed at all. A bankruptcy trustee’s preference power reaches ordinary creditors for ninety days and insiders for a year. And an insider is not just an owner. It includes relatives, and a spouse’s relatives out to the third degree. A spouse’s brother is on that list.
Under New Mexico’s act, an earlier creditor can unwind a payment to an insider on an old debt if the business was insolvent and the insider had reason to believe it. A business that is generally not paying its bills as they come due is presumed insolvent. A merchant cash advance funder could sue to recover that payment within one year, with no bankruptcy anywhere. If the company files, the trustee gets the same one year against insiders, and ninety days against everyone else, counted back from the filing date. A payment is a preference when it was made on an old debt, while insolvent, inside the window, and left that creditor better off than a Chapter seven liquidation would have. Some points cut the other way. A fully secured lender is usually not better off, so paying it is rarely recoverable. Ordinary course payments are protected. In a business case, transfers totaling less than eight thousand five hundred seventy five dollars are off the table. And payroll taxes are special. Income tax and the employees’ share of Social Security and Medicare withheld from paychecks are held in trust for the United States. The Supreme Court held in nineteen ninety that those funds were never the debtor’s property, so the trustee cannot claw them back. The employer’s own matching share gets no such protection.
The clawback does not land on the company. It lands on the person who got paid. A trustee sues your brother-in-law’s company, and the family is litigating over money meant as a kindness. It compounds. An undesignated tax payment often gets applied to the non trust portion first, leaving the owner exposed to the trust fund penalty. And if she guaranteed the bank line or the E I D L, paying those down does not end her liability. For payments made ninety days to a year before filing, the trustee can recover from her, the guarantor, instead of the lender. The fix is sequencing. Back to Marisol and her eighty five thousand. The lower risk order: forty seven thousand goes to the I R S, designated in writing to the trust fund taxes. The rest goes to current payroll, rent, and new parts on normal terms. Compare her original plan: forty thousand to the brother-in-law’s company on an old balance. Even if he ships six thousand in parts on credit afterward, the trustee could recover about thirty four thousand of it.
Three things to do this week if your New Mexico business is deciding whom to pay. First, pull your creditor list and mark every insider: owners, officers, their relatives, and their spouses’ relatives. Those payments carry a one year tail. Second, if you owe payroll taxes, pay the trust fund portion first and designate it in writing when you pay. Third, move family suppliers to cash on delivery. New parts for cash is defensible. Old balances are not. And read your E I D L loan agreement; the standard form bars preferential treatment of affiliates without S B A’s written consent. That’s what we do at North Star Law Firm. The initial consultation is free, and the full written analysis with citations is at N M dash legal dot net.
Can a struggling New Mexico business pay one creditor first?
Generally, yes. In Clarke v. White, 37 U.S. (12 Pet.) 178 (1838), the Supreme Court upheld a 70-cents-on-the-dollar settlement and observed that “[t]he debtor may prefer one creditor, pay him fully, and exhaust his whole property.” It is the classic statement of first-come, first-served collection.
New Mexico’s Uniform Voidable Transactions Act, NMSA 1978, §§ 56-10-14 through 56-10-29, keeps that baseline. Under § 56-10-17(A), value is given when “an antecedent debt is secured or satisfied,” so paying an unrelated creditor what the business owes is ordinarily a fair exchange. The Tenth Circuit read identical uniform language the same way in July 2025, finding reasonably equivalent value in a dollar-for-dollar debt payment. Bird v. Wardley (In re White), No. 24-4033 (10th Cir. July 22, 2025). A transfer meant to defeat creditors is a separate matter under § 56-10-18(A)(1), whose first listed factor is that “the transfer or obligation was to an insider.”
Why is paying a family creditor before bankruptcy the riskiest choice?
Because New Mexico kept the uniform act’s insider-preference rule. Section 56-10-19(B) lets an earlier creditor undo a payment “if the transfer was made to an insider for an antecedent debt, the debtor was insolvent at that time and the insider had reasonable cause to believe that the debtor was insolvent.” For a corporation, § 56-10-15 counts officers, directors, persons in control and their relatives, and “relative” includes “an individual related to a spouse within the third degree,” which covers a spouse’s brother. A business that is “generally not paying” its bills as they come due is presumed insolvent (§ 56-10-16(B)).
No bankruptcy is needed. An MCA funder could sue to unwind the payment within one year after the transfer (§ 56-10-23(C)). The defenses in § 56-10-22(F) are narrow: later new value from the insider, a payment in the ordinary course of business between the two, or a good-faith rehabilitation effort that also secured present value. How a state court applies them is a question for New Mexico counsel.
In bankruptcy, 11 U.S.C. § 547(b)(4)(B) stretches the look-back from 90 days to one year for a creditor that “was an insider,” and § 101(31)(B) reaches relatives of those in control “by affinity or consanguinity within the third degree” (§ 101(45)). If the supplier is his LLC, it is not on the list, but the Tenth Circuit treats a creditor as a non-statutory insider when closeness comes with non-arm’s-length dealing. Anstine v. Carl Zeiss Meditec AG (In re U.S. Medical, Inc.), 531 F.3d 1272 (10th Cir. 2008). Recovery runs against “the initial transferee” under § 550(a)(1).
Section 544(b)(1) also lets the trustee borrow state law, which matters most for intent claims: § 56-10-23(A) allows four years, against two under § 548(a)(1)(A). If Marisol later files personally, § 727(a)(2)(A) can deny her a discharge for moving her own property to defeat creditors within the prior year.
Buying from family can be defended. Cash on delivery for new parts is “a contemporaneous exchange for new value” under § 547(c)(1), parts shipped on credit after a payment reduce exposure under § 547(c)(4), and § 56-10-22(F)(1) has a matching state defense.
Deciding Which Creditor to Pay First? Contact Us Now
How does the 90-day preference window work in a New Mexico bankruptcy?
A section 547 preference is a payment to or for a creditor on an existing debt, made while the debtor was insolvent and inside the window, that leaves the creditor better off than a Chapter 7 liquidation would. A fully secured lender usually fails that last test. Insolvency is presumed for the 90 days before filing (§ 547(f)), though the trustee carries the burden (§ 547(g)). Since 2020 the trustee may sue only “based on reasonable due diligence in the circumstances of the case and taking into account a party’s known or reasonably knowable affirmative defenses” (added by Pub. L. 116-54).
Section 547(c)(2) protects ordinary-course payments, discussed in my post on the ordinary course defense in the Tenth Circuit. When debts are not primarily consumer debts, § 547(c)(9) shields transfers aggregating less than $8,575, the figure for cases filed on or after April 1, 2025 under 90 Fed. Reg. 8941; the next adjustment under § 104(a) is due April 1, 2028.
Should a New Mexico business pay IRS trust fund taxes first?
Usually, yes. Income tax withheld from paychecks and the employees’ share of Social Security and Medicare are “a special fund in trust for the United States” under 26 U.S.C. § 7501(a). In Begier v. IRS, 496 U.S. 53 (1990), an airline paid such taxes from general accounts within 90 days of filing. The Court held the funds “were not the property of the debtor prior to payment,” so the trustee could not recover them.
Paying them also reduces Marisol’s personal exposure under 26 U.S.C. § 6672(a), which penalizes a responsible person who willfully fails to pay over the tax. Two cautions. The employer’s matching share is not withheld from anyone, so it is not trust money and gets neither protection. Undesignated payments often go to non-trust tax first; IRS Chief Counsel Advice 202129007 says a designation must be “specific, in writing, and made at the time of the payment.”
State taxes differ. NMSA 1978, § 7-3-4 makes withheld amounts “a collected tax,” but I found no statutory trust language and no D.N.M. decision extending Begier to it. Gross receipts tax is the seller’s own tax, imposed “for the privilege of engaging in business” (§ 7-9-4(A)).
What about merchant cash advance, SBA EIDL and bank payments?
MCA debits inside 90 days are tested the same way if the advance is a loan; if it is a true sale of receivables, the funder will say the money was never the debtor’s. See the post on MCA debt attacked as a fraudulent transfer.
One COVID EIDL loan agreement filed publicly with the SEC bars the borrower, without SBA’s written consent, from giving “any preferential treatment” to owners, employees or affiliated companies. Marisol’s own agreement controls. Assume she also guaranteed the EIDL and bank line. Paying them down does not end her liability if the company files; even a discharge does not affect “the liability of any other entity on” the debt (§ 524(e)). It can backfire: a guarantor is a contingent insider creditor, and for payments made 90 days to one year out, §§ 547(i) and 550(c) shift recovery from the lender to her.
What payment order minimizes clawback risk?
Illustration only. Say the company is a corporation, the payroll debt is $47,000 of trust fund taxes and $13,000 of employer share, and it files Chapter 7 in Albuquerque on Monday, February 1, 2027. The 90-day window opens November 3, 2026; the insider window, February 1, 2026.
The lower-risk order: on November 10, 2026, Marisol sends the IRS $47,000 designated in writing to the trust fund taxes, which Begier places outside § 547. The other $38,000 goes to current payroll, rent and new parts on normal terms. Her brother-in-law gets cash on delivery only.
Her original plan: $40,000 to his company on November 10 and $45,000 to the IRS undesignated. Even if he ships $6,000 of parts on credit afterward, the trustee can recover $34,000 from his company. Outside bankruptcy, an MCA funder could bring the state claim until November 10, 2027. If the IRS puts $13,000 toward the employer share, that slice is exposed, and $15,000 of trust fund tax remains assessable against Marisol personally. The math is the same in Subchapter V (see this field guide).
| Payee (safest first) | Section 547 window | New Mexico UVTA exposure | Main defense |
|---|---|---|---|
| IRS, trust fund taxes | None (Begier) | None identified | Not debtor’s property; cuts § 6672 exposure |
| Unrelated supplier, ordinary terms | 90 days | Generally none (§ 56-10-17 value) | Ordinary course, § 547(c)(2) |
| MCA funder | 90 days, if a loan | Generally none absent intent | True sale; $8,575 floor |
| Owner-guaranteed bank or SBA | 90 days; one year against the guarantor | Generally none | Full collateral defeats § 547(b)(5) |
| Brother-in-law’s company | One year | One year (§ 56-10-19(B)) | New value only |
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I pay my brother-in-law’s company before filing bankruptcy in New Mexico?
You can, but a payment on an old balance can be recovered for one year, in bankruptcy under § 547(b)(4)(B) and outside it under § 56-10-19(B). Paying cash on delivery for new goods is defensible.
How far back can a bankruptcy trustee claw back payments?
Ninety days for ordinary creditors and one year for insiders. Fraudulent-intent claims reach two years under § 548 and up to four through § 544(b) and New Mexico’s UVTA.
Is paying IRS payroll taxes before bankruptcy a preference?
Not the trust fund portion, under Begier v. IRS. The employer’s matching share has no such protection.
Does New Mexico’s Uniform Voidable Transactions Act have an insider preference rule?
Yes. Section 56-10-19(B) reaches payments to insiders on old debts while the debtor was insolvent, if the insider had reason to know it. A creditor must sue within one year.
Is there a minimum preference amount in a business bankruptcy?
Yes. For cases filed on or after April 1, 2025, § 547(c)(9) protects transfers totaling less than $8,575 when debts are not primarily consumer debts.
How North Star Law Firm Can Help
North Star Law Firm advises owners and the relatives they pay on preference and clawback exposure, evaluates whether Subchapter V or another New Mexico bankruptcy fits, and handles the payroll tax side through its tax defense practice.
Phillip Zagotti, JD/CPA, is admitted to the U.S. District Court and Bankruptcy Court for the District of New Mexico and represents taxpayers before the IRS and the U.S. Tax Court. The firm works alongside New Mexico-licensed counsel on state-law questions. If you are deciding which creditors to pay before a possible filing, contact North Star Law Firm.
