Celeste makes silver and turquoise jewelry in Socorro and sells it at weekend markets and through an online marketplace. For 2023 her payment processor issued a Form 1099-K showing $61,400 in gross payments, while her return reported $18,000 of Schedule C gross receipts and no expenses. A CP2000 notice arrived in 2025 and went into a drawer, and the IRS assessed the tax. In October 2026 the New Mexico Taxation and Revenue Department (TRD) sent a notice assessing personal income tax on the same increase, and a second letter asked about gross receipts tax.
Celeste is fictional. The instinct to fight the state letter first is usually backward.
The IRS changed my return. Why is New Mexico assessing me too?
Under 26 U.S.C. § 6103(d), the IRS may share return information with a state tax agency that asks in writing. New Mexico’s income tax is built on federal adjusted gross income: “base income” in NMSA 1978, § 7-2-2 begins with adjusted gross income plus listed additions. Raise the AGI and the state number rises.
Under NMSA 1978, § 7-1-13(E), a taxpayer must file a “federal adjustments report” and pay the resulting state tax within 180 days after the final determination date. For IRS action, that is generally the first day nothing remains open, with appeal rights waived or exhausted. Most people I see never file it, and TRD assesses instead.
Should I fight the TRD assessment or the IRS adjustment?
Both, but the IRS number usually decides it. A New Mexico assessment “is presumed to be correct” under NMSA 1978, § 7-1-17(C). The Administrative Hearings Office, which hears protests under NMSA 1978, § 7-1B-1 et seq., says in its tax protest FAQ that a taxpayer must offer evidence beyond unsubstantiated statements. When TRD’s figure mirrors a final federal figure, the best proof it is wrong is a corrected federal figure.
California shows the alternative. In Appeal of G. Barraza, 2025-OTA-663 (Cal. Off. Tax App. Apr. 25, 2025) (nonprecedential), the taxpayer’s Tax Court petition had been dismissed for lack of jurisdiction and the IRS apparently never acted on his amended return; arguing expenses to the state with the federal assessment standing, he lost most of the case. A New Mexico protest saying only “the IRS was wrong,” without the federal correction in hand, has the same problem.
Got an IRS or TRD Notice? Contact Us
I ignored the CP2000 notice. What federal options are left?
IRS Topic 652 describes the CP2000 as a proposal, not a bill, with 30 days to respond; silence brings a statutory notice of deficiency under § 6212. Under § 6213(a) you then have 90 days to petition the Tax Court, and the IRS cannot assess until that time passes. If you are inside those 90 days, petition; our post on the Tax Court 90 day deadline covers the traps.
Once the tax is assessed, the main door is audit reconsideration. IRM 4.13.1 (rev. Dec. 10, 2025) requires a filed return, an unpaid assessment, and information the IRS has not considered. A taxpayer turned down can ask for Appeals review or pay and file a refund claim, and the IRM describes no Tax Court review of the denial.
If you pay instead, under § 6511(a) a refund claim is due within three years from filing the return or two years from payment, whichever is later, and § 7422(a) requires that claim before any refund suit. At a collection due process hearing you may contest the liability itself only if you did not receive a notice of deficiency or otherwise have a chance to dispute it, under § 6330(c)(2)(B). The July 2026 Form 656-L (doubt as to liability offers) tells people disputing unreported income adjustments not to use it.
Is the full Form 1099-K amount taxable income?
No. The IRS page on what to do with Form 1099-K says the gross payment amount “isn’t adjusted for any” fees, credits, refunds, shipping, cash equivalents or discounts. Schedule C then subtracts returns and cost of goods sold. The assessment Celeste ignored taxed every dollar the processor touched.
In a court proceeding, § 6201(d) puts on the IRS the burden of producing reasonable and probative information beyond the information return, once the taxpayer raises a reasonable dispute and has fully cooperated. The Tenth Circuit holds that “some reasonable foundation” is needed to keep a deficiency presumptively correct, Erickson v. Commissioner, 937 F.2d 1548 (10th Cir. 1991), though a 1099-K in your name usually supplies one. See our bank deposits post on that presumption.
An illustrative reconstruction for Celeste assumes she is single with $30,000 of wages and sets aside the qualified business income deduction and credits. From the $61,400 gross, she documents $2,900 of refunds, $7,400 of marketplace and processing fees, $1,800 of tax the marketplace collected inside the gross, $2,700 of postage, $16,500 of silver, stones and findings, and $1,600 of booth fees and supplies. Her corrected Schedule C net is $28,500 against the $18,000 she reported.
Using the 2023 brackets and $13,850 standard deduction in Rev. Proc. 2022-38, plus self-employment tax of 15.3 percent on 92.35 percent of net earnings (§ 1401; § 1402(a)(12)), the unreduced $43,400 increase costs about $7,689 of income tax and $6,132 of self-employment tax, or $13,821. That clears the $5,000 substantial understatement floor, so § 6662 adds a 20 percent penalty of about $2,764. The corrected increase is about $2,655, under the floor. New Mexico’s 2023 single schedule in NMSA 1978, § 7-2-7 (rates before 2025) yields roughly $1,976 of added tax on the IRS version and $478 on the corrected one.
Can a Schedule C change bring a gross receipts tax inquiry too?
It can. TRD compares federal Schedule C figures with gross receipts tax filings; in In re Marduk Consultants, Decision and Order No. 20-13 (N.M. Admin. Hearings Office Sept. 9, 2020), the Department compared the federal form to the CRS-1 returns and found they did not match.
Selling at New Mexico markets is “engaging in business,” defined in NMSA 1978, § 7-9-3.3 as carrying on any activity, and § 7-9-4 taxes that privilege at a state rate of 4.875 percent since July 1, 2023, plus local rates. TRD’s FYI-206 explains that a marketplace provider reports receipts from the sales it facilitates, and § 7-9-117 lets the seller deduct those receipts with documentation that the provider is registered and paying. So the federal gross can overstate her gross receipts tax base too, at least for her marketplace sales. Our gross receipts tax audit guide covers that side.
What New Mexico deadlines run while the IRS number is reopened?
NMSA 1978, § 7-1-24(E) requires a written protest within 90 days after the notice of assessment is mailed; I found no provision letting TRD extend it, and the older regulation, 3.1.7.11 NMAC, calls the 90 day outer limit jurisdictional. Celeste’s notice is dated October 20, 2026. If mailed that day, day 90 is Monday, January 18, 2027, Martin Luther King Jr. Day, a legal holiday under NMSA 1978, § 12-5-2. NMSA 1978, § 12-2A-7(F) should move a deadline that lands on a holiday to the next day, Tuesday, January 19, 2027. TRD may not agree, so the safer reading treats January 18 as the deadline. TRD’s Protest Office page warns that protesting and paying then claiming a refund are alternative remedies.
Section 7-1-18(E) lets TRD assess tax from a federal adjustment until three years after the end of the year the report was required. If the IRS later abates, § 7-1-26(F)(1)(c) allows a state refund claim until three years after the end of the calendar year in which that net negative federal adjustment becomes final. Interest runs at the federal underpayment rate under § 7-1-67, which TRD lists as 7 percent for July 1 through December 31, 2026, and the negligence penalty under § 7-1-69 is 2 percent a month, capped at 20 percent.
The usual sequence, with New Mexico counsel on the state side: a timely protest holds the place, the federal reconsideration goes in with the reconstruction attached, and TRD gets the IRS abatement when it comes.
| Notice in hand | Deadline | Where it goes and who must prove what | Effect on the other government’s number |
|---|---|---|---|
| CP2000 still open | Response date on the notice (30 days, Topic 652) | IRS; you document the gross | Nothing final; no state report due |
| Notice of deficiency | 90 days to petition, § 6213(a) | Tax Court; § 6201(d) can shift production to the IRS | Its outcome fixes the final determination date for the 180 day report |
| Federal tax already assessed | None for reconsideration; § 6511 for refunds | Reconsideration, then refund claim; on you | An abatement opens a § 7-1-26 state refund claim |
| TRD notice of assessment | 90 days from mailing, § 7-1-24(E) | TRD protest, Administrative Hearings Office; presumed correct | None; it follows the federal result |
Frequently Asked Questions
Do I have to report an IRS change to New Mexico?
Yes. Section 7-1-13(E) requires a federal adjustments report and payment within 180 days after the final determination date.
Can I protest the TRD assessment just because I am fighting the IRS?
Yes. A protest filed within the 90 days keeps the state dispute alive while the federal number is reopened, but a pending federal dispute with no reconstruction behind it is a thin ground.
Is audit reconsideration available after a CP2000 assessment?
Yes, if the assessment is unpaid and you have information the IRS has not seen. It goes to the campus that issued the CP2000, and approval is discretionary.
What if I already paid the IRS?
Then the path is generally a refund claim under § 6511, due within three years of filing or two years of payment. A refund suit under § 7422 can follow.
Does the 1099-K threshold matter for 2023?
The IRS says the 2025 tax act retroactively reinstated the threshold of more than $20,000 and more than 200 transactions (IR-2025-107). Celeste’s $61,400 clears the dollar test regardless.
Will the gross receipts tax letter follow the income tax result?
Not automatically. It turns on New Mexico receipts and deductions such as the marketplace seller deduction, so it needs its own response.
How North Star Law Firm Can Help
North Star Law Firm reopens the federal numbers behind state assessments through IRS audit defense and audit reconsideration, IRS appeals and CDP hearings, and Tax Court litigation, and rebuilds Schedule C records that also answer gross receipts tax questions.
Phillip Zagotti, JD/CPA, represents taxpayers before the IRS and the U.S. Tax Court and is admitted to the U.S. District Court and Bankruptcy Court for the District of New Mexico. The firm works alongside New Mexico-licensed counsel on state-law questions. If an IRS change has turned into a TRD notice with a 90 day clock, contact North Star Law Firm.
