Fabrication in Juárez, Cabinets in New Mexico: Compensating Tax on Cross Border Services

Desert view toward the community of Tortugas below the Organ Mountains in Dona Ana County, New Mexico

Rogelio builds custom cabinets in Santa Teresa and installs them in homes and businesses from Las Cruces to El Paso. A Ciudad Juárez company he owns 90 percent of cuts, sands and finishes them. He trucks El Paso lumber south, his trucks bring finished boxes back through the Santa Teresa port of entry, and the Juárez company bills him about $38,000 a month. He pays gross receipts tax on installed jobs, never compensating tax on those invoices. Now the Taxation and Revenue Department (TRD) has sent an audit notice for 2023 through 2025.

Rogelio is fictional. In Appeal of Bachor, 2026-OTA-309, as described in an October 2026 practitioner note, a divided California Office of Tax Appeals panel held a San Diego area cabinet contractor liable for use tax on the cutting and finishing work his 99 percent owned company in Tecate did for him, and refused to treat the Mexican workers as his own employees. A dissent thought fabrication alone is not a taxable event. New Mexico’s tax is built differently.

What is New Mexico compensating tax, and how does it differ from gross receipts tax?

Gross receipts tax falls on the seller; compensating tax falls on the buyer. NMSA 1978, § 7-9-7 imposes it on the person making “taxable use” of property, licenses, franchises or services in New Mexico. Subsection D measures the tax on services by “the value of the services at the time the services were performed or the product of the service was acquired,” but only if the receipts “were not subject to the gross receipts tax.” Under Subsection E, that means receipts of a seller that “lacked nexus in New Mexico” and exempt or deductible receipts.

The state rate is 4.875 percent for periods beginning July 1, 2023, and 5 percent before. With local compensating taxes in place since July 1, 2021, TRD’s FYI-230 says each reporting location “shares the same tax rate as the rate for gross receipts tax.” The tax goes on Form TRD-41412, due by the 25th of the following month and filed only when tax is owed.

Do I owe compensating tax on fabrication work done in Mexico?

Maybe. Processing Rogelio’s own lumber is a service; the Act defines a “manufacturing service” as “the service of combining or processing components or materials owned by another” (NMSA 1978, § 7-9-3). Under § 7-9-3.5(A)(1), gross receipts include receipts “from selling services performed outside New Mexico, the product of which is initially used in New Mexico.” “Initial use” means “the first employment for the intended purpose,” which for a cabinet is installation.

A 2021 regulation, 3.2.10.23 NMAC, says who owes. In its first example a firm works entirely outside the state and delivers to a New Mexico buyer, who “does not owe compensating tax on the service. Instead, Y owes the gross receipts tax on that service because it was initially used in New Mexico.” The buyer owes compensating tax when the seller had no New Mexico obligation, or relied in good faith on the buyer’s word that first use would happen elsewhere.

Cabinets installed in El Paso were never used here, since “use” in § 7-9-3 excludes storage “for use solely outside this state.” I found no New Mexico appellate decision applying the services language in effect since July 1, 2021.

How far back can a TRD compensating tax audit reach, and what gets added?

The baseline in NMSA 1978, § 7-1-18(A) is three years “from the end of the calendar year in which payment of the tax was due.” Subsection D allows six years when a return “understates by more than twenty-five percent,” Subsection C seven for failing “to complete and file any required return,” and Subsection B ten for fraud. Rogelio’s gross receipts returns were accurate, but he never filed the compensating tax return, so my reading is that the seven year rule applies, reaching periods before 2023.

The penalty in § 7-1-69(A) for negligence is 2 percent per month or partial month, capped at 20 percent, and Subsection B excuses “a mistake of law made in good faith and on reasonable grounds.” Interest under § 7-1-67(B) follows the federal individual underpayment rate, computed daily; TRD’s posted rate for the second half of 2026 is 7 percent.

After an assessment, § 7-1-24(E) allows a written protest “within ninety days after” the notice is mailed, and the Administrative Hearings Office hears it under § 7-1B-8. Our guide to New Mexico gross receipts tax audits covers the field audit.

Compensating Tax Audit Letter? Contact Us Now

Does owning the Juárez company change the New Mexico tax?

Probably not. “Person” in § 7-9-3 includes any corporation, company or “other entity,” and I found nothing in Article 9 exempting sales between commonly owned businesses. In Westland Corp. v. Commissioner of Revenue, 1971-NMCA-083, 83 N.M. 29, 487 P.2d 1099, a company owned by the same two people as three sister corporations was engaging in business when it kept their books for a fee. If the price “does not represent the value” of the service, § 7-9-3.5(A)(1) substitutes “the reasonable value.”

Ownership sharpens one question. Since July 1, 2019, a seller with no physical presence is “engaging in business” if its taxable gross receipts sourced here in the previous calendar year reached $100,000 (NMSA 1978, § 7-9-3.3). A shop billing about $456,000 a year for cabinets mostly installed here may qualify. If so, its receipts were taxable, § 7-9-7(E) takes them out of compensating tax, and 3.2.10.23 NMAC puts the tax on the Juárez company. TRD could answer that § 7-1-14(F)(5) sources such services to “the location where the product of the service is delivered,” and the boxes are loaded in Juárez.

What could the audit math look like for a Santa Teresa cabinet shop?

Illustrative only. Over 36 months, $38,000 a month comes to $1,368,000. TRD’s rate schedules for July 1, 2025 through June 30, 2027 list unincorporated Doña Ana County, where Santa Teresa sits, at 6.4975 percent. Using that rate for every month (a real audit uses each period’s rate) gives $88,886 of tax. Placing first use at Las Cruces job sites (8.39 percent, § 7-1-14(H)) makes it $114,775.

At the county figure, the 20 percent penalty adds $17,777, and interest through December 31, 2026 at TRD’s quarterly rates of 6 to 8 percent adds about $15,100, for roughly $121,800 before El Paso jobs come out. A managed audit under § 7-1-11.1, had Rogelio applied first and the secretary agreed, would have left the tax but removed the penalty under § 7-1-69(G)(2), and the interest if he paid within 180 days of the assessment under § 7-1-67(A)(4).

Had the Juárez company registered and charged gross receipts tax, the dollars would be similar but the liability would be the seller’s, and 3.2.10.24 NMAC lets a buyer rely on an invoice showing New Mexico tax was charged.

Do resale certificates, Mexican taxes or the federal return change the answer?

Resale deductions belong to the seller. Section 7-9-48 lets a seller deduct a service sold for resale when the buyer “delivers a nontaxable transaction certificate to the seller”; § 7-9-47 covers goods, and § 7-9-52 covers construction services “directly contracted for or billed to” a project. They touch compensating tax only because § 7-9-7(H) and, for goods, 3.2.10.8 NMAC ask whether the purchase would have been deductible here, and a flat monthly shop invoice fits none easily.

The § 7-9-79 credit covers tax levied “by another state or political subdivision thereof.” It does not mention foreign countries, and I found no TRD guidance on Mexican value added tax. The affiliate’s IMMEX (maquiladora) status is Mexican customs law, which this post does not address. The constitutional backdrop is Complete Auto Transit, Inc. v. Brady, 430 U.S. 274 (1977), which upholds a state tax with substantial nexus, fair apportionment, no discrimination and a fair relation to state services; see our post on Maryland’s digital advertising tax.

Federally, Rogelio deducts the fees under 26 U.S.C. § 162, but 26 U.S.C. § 482 lets the IRS reallocate income between businesses “owned or controlled directly or indirectly by the same interests,” foreign ones included, and Treas. Reg. § 1.482-1(a) aims at “tax parity” with unrelated parties.

Purchase Tax and who owes it Rate location Usual audit issue
Lumber and hardware from El Paso Compensating tax on Rogelio unless deductible had he bought here First use in New Mexico Which jobs used it; Texas tax paid (§ 7-9-79)
Juárez fabrication labor Gross receipts tax on the affiliate if it had nexus; if not, compensating tax Delivery or first use Affiliate nexus, El Paso installs, reasonable value
Design software from a Texas vendor Gross receipts tax if charged; if not, compensating tax His Santa Teresa office Whether invoices show New Mexico tax
Installation by his employees No tax on wages (§ 7-9-17); gross receipts tax on his job receipts The job site (§ 7-1-14(F)(2)) Worker status and location coding

Frequently Asked Questions

Is New Mexico compensating tax the same as a use tax?

It works like one, and TRD calls it a use tax. The user owes it, not the seller, on Form TRD-41412.

Can a Mexican company charge New Mexico gross receipts tax?

Yes, once it is engaging in business here, which includes reaching $100,000 of prior year receipts sourced to New Mexico. Buyers may rely on an invoice showing the tax.

How long do I have to protest a compensating tax assessment?

Ninety days after TRD mails the notice of assessment. Undisputed amounts must be paid by then.

Does Mexican value added tax reduce my New Mexico compensating tax?

The § 7-9-79 credit refers to other states and their subdivisions. I found no TRD guidance extending it to Mexican tax.

Can TRD assess years before 2023?

Sometimes. The three year limit becomes six for a large understatement, seven when a required return was never filed, and ten for fraud.

Will TRD waive the penalty if I never knew about compensating tax?

The statute excuses penalty for a good faith mistake of law on reasonable grounds, and the facts matter. TRD says interest cannot be waived.

How North Star Law Firm Can Help

North Star Law Firm helps border businesses respond to gross receipts and compensating tax audits, reviews how affiliated companies are structured, and handles federal questions through its IRS audit defense practice.

Phillip Zagotti, JD/CPA, represents taxpayers before the IRS and the U.S. Tax Court and is admitted to the U.S. District Court and Bankruptcy Court for the District of New Mexico. The firm works alongside New Mexico-licensed counsel on state-law questions. If a TRD letter has arrived about work done in Juárez, contact North Star Law Firm.