Yolanda runs a chile processing and packing business in Deming as a sole proprietor. The IRS disallowed about $310,000 of her 2022 and 2023 cost of goods sold and contract labor and sent a notice of deficiency. Her Tax Court case is set for the Albuquerque trial session in spring 2027. The one person who can explain her books, her former bookkeeper, moved to Tucson in 2025 and will not come back voluntarily.
Then a Chapter 7 trustee served Yolanda, a nonparty, with a subpoena from the bankruptcy court in El Paso for her purchase records from a failed produce broker and for testimony “by videoconference” at an adversary trial. Yolanda is fictional. Both problems are common, and they run on different rules.
Listen to this post
North Star Tax and Legal Briefing: Out of State Witness for a New Mexico Tax Court Trial: Subpoenas, Zoomgov and Kirkland
Your Tax Court trial is in Albuquerque and the witness who can explain your books moved out of state. This five minute briefing covers the nationwide Tax Court subpoena, why video testimony is the harder ask, the deadlines that come first, and how to prove your case with records.
Download the MP3 · Episode page on Podbean
Show / hide the episode transcript
Your Tax Court trial is set for Albuquerque, and the one witness who can explain your books now lives in Arizona and will not come back. Most New Mexico business owners assume that ends it, because they have heard a federal subpoena only reaches one hundred miles. In Tax Court, that assumption is wrong. Call her Yolanda. She is fictional, but her problem is not. She runs a chile packing business in Deming, the I R S disallowed about three hundred ten thousand dollars of her costs, and her former bookkeeper moved to Tucson. Reaching that bookkeeper turns out to be the easy part. The hard part is something else.
Start with the distinction that matters. In an ordinary federal lawsuit, and in bankruptcy court, a subpoena generally cannot pull a witness more than one hundred miles from where she lives, works, or regularly does business in person. The Tax Court does not use that rule. It has its own subpoena rule, backed by a statute that lets the court require witnesses to appear from any place in the United States. The clerk issues the subpoena signed but otherwise blank, the party fills it in, and it can be served anywhere in the country. So a process server in Tucson can hand the bookkeeper a subpoena for Albuquerque, as long as the server tenders one day’s witness fee, which is forty dollars, plus mileage. Getting her served is one question. Getting her testimony in front of the judge is a second, separate question.
Here is how that second question works. Tax Court testimony generally must be taken in open court. The judge may allow video, but only for good cause, in compelling circumstances, with appropriate safeguards. The court’s default is still a trial in person, so plan for a no. A witness who simply prefers to stay in Arizona makes a thin showing. A served subpoena, a written refusal, and a short examination confined to records make a better one.
You may have heard about the Kirkland case. A federal appeals court on the West Coast threw out subpoenas ordering two distant witnesses to testify by video in a bankruptcy trial, because the one hundred mile limit still applies to a witness on a screen. A rule change answering that decision cannot take effect before December first, two thousand twenty seven. None of it touches the Tax Court’s subpoena rule.
The picture changes in bankruptcy court. Suppose a bankruptcy trustee in El Paso subpoenas Yolanda, who is not a party to that case. There, the one hundred mile rule applies, and Deming sits right at the edge: about eighty two miles in a straight line, about one hundred two by road. The rule does not say which measure counts.
Why does this hit ordinary businesses? Because the deadlines arrive long before the trial does. Start with the deposition. Tax Court allows a deposition to preserve testimony when there is a substantial risk the witness will not be available at trial. The application is due at least forty five days before trial, and the other side has fifteen days after service to raise objections. The transcript can then be used at trial if she is too far from the courtroom for attending to be practical.
Next, a motion to move the whole case to a remote proceeding can be filed up until thirty one days before the first day of the trial session, and granting it is up to the judge. That motion moves everything. Video for one witness is a separate request. Then, under the court’s sample pretrial order, the pretrial memorandum is due twenty one days out, and a witness who is not named in it cannot testify without a showing of good cause. Miss those dates and a witness problem becomes a proof problem.
The shortcut most owners reach for does not work either. A sworn letter from the bookkeeper is not evidence in Tax Court. The better fix is to need her less. Back to Yolanda. Her cost of goods sold is a paper trail: grower payments, freight bills, box and bag invoices. Bank statements and vendor invoices often prove purchases better than a bookkeeper’s memory.
If your trial date is set, here are three things to do this week. First, read the pretrial order that came with your notice of trial and calendar every deadline, because that order controls. Second, sort out what the records can prove without the witness. Tax Court requires both sides to agree in advance on evidence that should not fairly be in dispute, and a bank can certify its own statements. Third, if you still need her, choose early between a deposition before trial and a subpoena paired with a request for video. And if a bankruptcy subpoena from another state lands on you, objections can be due in fourteen days or less. That’s what we do at North Star Law Firm. The initial consultation is free, and the full written analysis with citations is at N M dash legal dot net.
Can the Tax Court subpoena an out of state witness for my Albuquerque trial?
Yes. The Tax Court does not use Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 45 and its 100 mile limit. It has its own subpoena rule, Tax Court Rule 147, backed by 26 U.S.C. § 7456(a), which lets the Court require witnesses to appear “from any place in the United States at any designated place of hearing.”
The Clerk issues a subpoena “signed but otherwise in blank” for the party to complete (Rule 147(a)(2)). It “may be served at any place within the United States” (Rule 147(b)(2)), and Rule 147(c) points the place of compliance back to § 7456. A server in Tucson can hand the bookkeeper a subpoena for Albuquerque if the server tenders one day’s fee and mileage. Rule 148 adopts the district court amounts in 28 U.S.C. § 1821: $40 a day plus mileage at the GSA rate.
Does In re Kirkland or the 2026 Rule 45 amendment matter in Tax Court?
Mostly no. In In re Kirkland, 75 F.4th 1030 (9th Cir. 2023), the Ninth Circuit ordered quashed the subpoenas directing two Virgin Islands residents to testify by video in a Los Angeles bankruptcy trial, because Rule 45(c)’s distance limits still bind a witness who testifies from her own living room. The Judicial Conference then approved a new Rule 45(c)(2), and on October 20, 2026 the Standing Committee’s chair sent it to the Supreme Court. Under 28 U.S.C. § 2074(a), the earliest effective date is December 1, 2027. The Supreme Court has not yet acted.
None of that touches Tax Court Rule 147. The provision that matters is Tax Court Rule 143(b): testimony “generally must be taken in open court,” and the Court may permit video “for good cause in compelling circumstances and with appropriate safeguards.” That tracks Federal Rule 43(a), which the amendment leaves alone. Reaching the Tucson witness is easy. Putting her on a screen instead of in the courtroom is the hard part.
The Tenth Circuit has not decided the Kirkland question, and I found no District of New Mexico decision on it. Rule 43(a) requests do come up here; in Martinez v. Continental Tire The Americas, LLC, No. 1:17-cv-00922 (D.N.M. 2022) (Doc. 687), the court let an out of state witness testify remotely.
Can my witness appear by Zoomgov at a Tax Court trial in Albuquerque?
Possibly, but plan for a no. Under Administrative Order No. 2021-01, still in force, “The Court’s default is to conduct in-person trials.” A Motion to Proceed Remotely may be filed “up until 31 days before the first day of the trial session,” and granting it “is at the Judge’s discretion.” That motion moves the whole case. For one witness on video, Yolanda needs a Rule 143(b) motion, and Rule 50(a) requires her to state whether the IRS objects.
Preferring to stay in Arizona is a thin showing. A served subpoena, a written refusal and a short examination confined to records are better. Review of a denial is narrow: the Tenth Circuit reviews Tax Court decisions as it would a district court bench trial under 26 U.S.C. § 7482(a)(1), and it reviews evidentiary rulings for abuse of discretion. See Arnett v. Commissioner, No. 06-9005 (10th Cir. June 21, 2007) (unpublished).
Tax Court Trial Date Set? Contact Us Now
What if my Tax Court trial witness will not appear?
Start cheap; the bookkeeper may not be needed for most of what she knows. Stipulation in Tax Court is mandatory: Rule 91(a)(1) requires the parties to stipulate “all evidence that fairly should not be in dispute.” IRS counsel usually agrees a bank statement is genuine while disputing what it proves.
A sworn letter from the bookkeeper will not work. Rule 143(c) says “Ex parte affidavits or declarations” are not evidence, and the hearsay bar in Fed. R. Evid. 802 applies through Rule 143(a) and 26 U.S.C. § 7453. Business records are another matter. Under Rule 803(6) and Rule 902(11), a custodian’s written certification, with reasonable notice to the IRS before trial, lays the foundation without a live witness. Her bank can certify its statements; Yolanda can vouch for her own business records.
Here my forensic accounting background matters. A chile packer’s cost of goods sold is a paper trail: grower payments, freight bills, box and bag invoices. Bank statements and vendor invoices often prove purchases better than a bookkeeper’s memory. Where records are thin, Cohan v. Commissioner, 39 F.2d 540 (2d Cir. 1930) allows an estimate, “bearing heavily” on the taxpayer, but not for travel, meals, gifts or listed property, which 26 U.S.C. § 274(d) requires to be substantiated. I wrote about rebuilding records in rebutting the bank deposits method.
If her testimony is still needed, Rule 81 permits a deposition to perpetuate testimony where there is “a substantial risk” she “will not be available at the trial.” The application is due at least 45 days before trial, objections 15 days after service, and the transcript is usable if she is “at such distance from the place of trial that it is not practicable” to attend (Rule 81(i)(3)(B)). Last comes the subpoena itself, plus a Rule 143(b) motion for video.
| Method | Rule and timing | Cost | Main risk |
|---|---|---|---|
| Stipulation with IRS counsel | Rule 91(a); filed 14 days before the session | Lowest | IRS concedes authenticity, not meaning |
| Business records certification | Fed. R. Evid. 803(6), 902(11); written notice before trial | Low | Covers records, not explanations |
| Deposition to perpetuate testimony | Rule 81; application 45 days before trial | Moderate to high | Must show substantial risk she is unavailable |
| Subpoena plus remote appearance | Rules 147, 148, 143(b); motion well before trial | Fees, mileage, motion practice | Judge may require her in the courtroom |
How does the calendar work for a spring 2027 Albuquerque trial session?
Assume, for illustration, a session opening Monday, April 12, 2027. Under the Court’s sample Standing Pretrial Order (the order served with her notice of trial controls), discovery motions and her Rule 81 application are due Friday, February 26 (45 days). A Motion to Proceed Remotely is due Friday, March 12 (31 days). Her pretrial memorandum, due Monday, March 22 (21 days), must name the bookkeeper, since unlisted witnesses cannot testify “without a showing of good cause.” The stipulation of facts is due Monday, March 29 (14 days), and unagreed exhibits Monday, April 5 (7 days).
Suppose she serves the bookkeeper in early February. Tucson to Albuquerque is about 435 road miles each way (Rome2rio); 869 miles at the $0.76 GSA rate for travel on or after July 1, 2026 is $660.44, so the server tenders $700.44 with the $40 fee. The 2027 rate may differ; travel days and overnight stays add fees under § 1821.
What if an El Paso bankruptcy court subpoenas me from Deming?
Now Yolanda is the nonparty, and federal Rule 45 applies through Bankruptcy Rule 9016. Rule 45(c)(1)(A) says a subpoena can require her attendance “within 100 miles of where the person resides, is employed, or regularly transacts business in person.” Using Census coordinates, Deming is about 82 miles from El Paso in a straight line; by road it is about 102. The rule does not say which measure governs, and I found no Tenth Circuit or New Mexico federal ruling on it. Counted in a straight line, or if she regularly sells in person in El Paso, she is likely within reach, and Kirkland, a Ninth Circuit case, does not bind a Texas court.
Document production is limited to a place within 100 miles (Rule 45(c)(2)(A)). Objections are due before the earlier of the compliance date or 14 days after service (Rule 45(d)(2)(B)), so a subpoena served Monday, November 16, 2026 means objections by Monday, November 30. A motion to quash goes to “the court for the district where compliance is required”: the Western District of Texas for compliance in El Paso, or the New Mexico federal court if production is commanded in Deming, subject to transfer under Rule 45(f). And a trustee asking for her purchase records may also be looking at preference claims against payments she received.
Frequently Asked Questions
Does the 100 mile rule apply to a Tax Court subpoena?
No. Section 7456(a) reaches witnesses anywhere in the United States. The real question is whether the judge will accept video testimony under Rule 143(b).
Can I use my former bookkeeper’s signed statement instead of her testimony?
Usually not; Rule 143(c) says ex parte declarations are not evidence. A Rule 902(11) business records certification is different, because it only lays a foundation for records.
How long does a nonparty have to object to a Tax Court document subpoena?
Rule 147(d)(2)(B) allows 15 days after service, or less if compliance is due sooner. That is one day more than federal Rule 45 allows.
When will the Rule 45 remote testimony amendment take effect?
No earlier than December 1, 2027, and only if the Supreme Court adopts it and Congress does not intervene. It will reach bankruptcy subpoenas through Rule 9016, not Tax Court subpoenas.
Does it matter where my Tax Court trial is held?
Yes, for cost and witness travel. I compared Albuquerque, El Paso and Lubbock in choosing a Tax Court place of trial in New Mexico.
How North Star Law Firm Can Help
North Star Law Firm prepares New Mexico taxpayers for trial through its Tax Court litigation and IRS audit defense practices and advises nonparties served with subpoenas in bankruptcy cases.
Phillip Zagotti, JD/CPA, represents taxpayers before the IRS and the U.S. Tax Court and is admitted to the U.S. District Court and Bankruptcy Court for the District of New Mexico. The firm works alongside New Mexico-licensed counsel on state-law questions. If your Tax Court case depends on a witness who moved away, or an out of state subpoena arrived, contact North Star Law Firm.
