After a PPP or EIDL Fraud Referral in New Mexico: Tax, Collection and Bankruptcy Fallout

The Harold L. Runnels Federal Building, a federal office building in Las Cruces, New Mexico

Esteban’s Hobbs oilfield services LLC, taxed as an S corporation, had 14 employees in 2020. It took a $212,000 first draw PPP loan that April and a $190,000 second draw in February 2021, both forgiven. He also has a $150,000 COVID EIDL, 11 months behind, and a $10,000 EIDL advance. Last month his former partner said an investigator had asked about payroll.

A bookkeeper who left on bad terms in 2024 built the PPP applications from gross billings, so the 2020 and 2021 Forms 941 show wages about 35 percent below what the applications claimed. Esteban is fictional; his question is not. Charged or not, what happens to his taxes, his collection exposure and his bankruptcy options?

Does a PPP loan fraud investigation in New Mexico end if DOJ never files charges?

No. DOJ’s tip program, formally the Criminal Tip Rewards Pilot Program and often called WHIP, can pay $10,000 to $30,000 once charges are unsealed, and SBA program fraud is covered. It implements Directive 26-12 (Oct. 1, 2026). Directive 26-13 (Oct. 7, 2026) has prosecutors ask, “in every case,” whether “a violation of the internal revenue laws has occurred.” The division is covered in our post on the National Fraud Enforcement Division.

On Sept. 23, 2026, the SBA said the IRS had matched loan applications against tax data, found discrepancies tied to about $100 billion in loans, and opened examinations. A declination closes none of it.

Is PPP forgiveness taxable income once the SBA says the loan was obtained by fraud?

Normally not. Section 276 of the COVID-related Tax Relief Act of 2020 (Pub. L. 116-260, div. N, 134 Stat. 1979) excludes forgiveness, in § 276(a) for first draws and § 276(b) for second draws, and keeps the expenses deductible. Section 278(b) excludes EIDL advances. In an S corporation the excluded amount flows to the owner as tax exempt income.

The exclusion assumes qualifying forgiveness. In CCA 202237010, released Sept. 16, 2022, IRS Chief Counsel said a borrower who did not meet the conditions “may not exclude the amount of the forgiven loan from gross income,” in the year of forgiveness, second draws included. IR-2022-162 describes the inclusion as “the portion of the loan proceeds that were forgiven based upon misrepresentations or omissions.” The memo is not precedent, but examiners start there. That word “portion” matters.

Repayment is its own event. The CCA says repaying in a later year “may” support a deduction under § 162 or a loss under § 165. Section 1341 requires income reported because it “appeared” the taxpayer had an unrestricted right; my contestable reading is that it is a hard sell when the right came from a misstatement. Settlement payments also meet § 162(f), which denies a deduction unless the agreement identifies the amount as restitution. If the debt is instead treated as an ordinary loan never put into income, repaying principal yields no deduction.

PPP or EIDL File Under Scrutiny? Contact Us Now

How far back can the IRS reach, and what is the IRS civil fraud penalty?

The IRS normally has three years from filing under 26 U.S.C. § 6501(a), or six under § 6501(e) if the return omitted more than 25 percent of the gross income it stated. A false or fraudulent return with intent to evade can be assessed “at any time” under § 6501(c)(1). The willful evasion rule in § 6501(c)(2) skips income tax; it reaches employment and excise taxes. Whose fraud counts is covered in our post on preparer fraud after Murrin.

The § 6663 penalty is 75 percent of the underpayment due to fraud. The IRS bears the burden (§ 7454(a)), by clear and convincing evidence in the Tax Court under Rule 142(b). An application inflated by a bookkeeper’s method is not automatically a fraudulent tax return.

Esteban’s 941 taxes were paid, so the trust fund recovery penalty is off the table; the 941s are the audit trail, and under § 6501(b)(2) his 2021 quarterlies count as filed April 15, 2022.

After a tax conviction, § 6201(a)(4) lets the IRS assess restitution for unpaid tax as if it were tax, with no deficiency notice (§ 6213(b)(5)) and no challenge based on the underlying liability. Klein v. Commissioner, 149 T.C. 341 (2017), held that interest and failure to pay additions cannot be added to it. Restitution to the SBA for bank or wire fraud is a title 18 judgment instead; under 18 U.S.C. § 3613 its lien works like a tax lien for the later of 20 years from judgment or release from prison.

How does Treasury collect a defaulted EIDL from a New Mexico borrower?

A nontax debt delinquent 180 days goes to Treasury under 31 U.S.C. § 3711(g); the SBA’s EIDL page says offset referral can come at 120 days. Tax refunds are offset under 31 U.S.C. § 3720A. Social Security is reduced under 31 C.F.R. § 285.4 by the lesser of 15 percent or the amount above $750 a month. Wage garnishment under 31 U.S.C. § 3720D takes up to 15 percent of disposable pay after 30 days’ notice; a hearing request by day 15 holds the order.

NMSA 1978, § 35-12-7 protects the greater of 75 percent of disposable earnings or 40 times the highest minimum wage weekly, but federal garnishment applies “notwithstanding any provision of State law.” The demand stage is in our SBA demand letter post. Under 31 C.F.R. § 900.3(a), only DOJ can compromise a debt involving the debtor’s fraud or misrepresentation.

Is SBA loan fraud debt, or the tax that follows, dischargeable in bankruptcy?

Debt obtained by fraud survives under 11 U.S.C. § 523(a)(2)(A), but written statements about financial condition fall under § 523(a)(2)(B), which adds reliance and intent to deceive. Lamar, Archer & Cofrin, LLP v. Appling, 584 U.S. 709 (2018), read “respecting” broadly enough to cover a single asset, and United States v. Schoenmann, Adv. No. 23-03043 (Bankr. N.D. Cal. July 3, 2025), treated an EIDL application as one. I found no Tenth Circuit ruling on PPP payroll figures. The creditor must sue within 60 days after the first date set for the § 341 meeting (Rule 4007(c)). In Lashinsky v. Holman, Adv. No. 21-1031-j (Bankr. D.N.M. Feb. 7, 2024), the court found “substantial PPP loan improprieties” yet granted the discharge because intent was not proven.

Tax on a fraudulent return never discharges (§ 523(a)(1)(C)). Dalton v. IRS, 77 F.3d 1297 (10th Cir. 1996), reads willful as “done voluntarily, consciously or knowingly, and intentionally.” Tax assessed within 240 days before filing also survives (§ 507(a)(8)(A)(ii)). Tax penalties can discharge under § 523(a)(7)(B) if the event was more than three years before the petition, and the Tenth Circuit BAP treated filing the return as the event for a frivolous return penalty in In re Wilson, BAP No. CO-08-092 (June 12, 2009). Title 18 restitution survives (§ 523(a)(13)).

The stay does not stop a prosecution (§ 362(b)(1)), and its refund setoff exception, § 362(b)(26), covers income tax against income tax, not SBA debt. Chapter 13, or Subchapter V under the $3,424,000 limit in effect since April 1, 2025, can spread out what survives. As of Nov. 6, 2026, H.R. 7730, raising that limit to $7.5 million, has passed both chambers with no signature recorded.

What would a Hobbs business owner’s PPP investigation cost in tax?

Illustrative only. Say the SBA rescinds the 2021 forgiveness of the $190,000 second draw, DOJ declines, and the IRS opens 2021. Under the 2022 position $190,000 of company income flows to Esteban’s 1040. At a 24 percent bracket that is $45,600 of tax plus a $34,200 fraud penalty, $79,800 before interest. If only the inflated 35 percent counts, $66,500, the tax is $15,960 and the penalty $11,970. New Mexico base income starts from federal adjusted gross income (NMSA 1978, § 7-2-2), and § 7-1-13(E) requires a federal adjustments report within 180 days of the final determination.

He filed for 2021 in April 2022, so three years ended in April 2025. Only fraud, or the six year rule through April 2028 if the omission tops 25 percent, keeps 2021 open, which is why a fraud finding matters more than the loan. If he guaranteed the EIDL, Treasury can take his 2026 refund. In Chapter 7, the LLC’s loans are not his unless he guaranteed them, and an entity gets no discharge (§ 727(a)(1)). The 2021 tax survives if fraud is found or it was assessed within 240 days; the penalty likely does not.

Debt Who collects, and how Time limit Survives Chapter 7?
PPP second draw after rescinded forgiveness SBA, then Treasury offset and garnishment Referral at 180 days delinquent Only on a timely, proven § 523(a)(2) claim
EIDL loan plus advance SBA, then Treasury offset and garnishment Offset referral from 120 days Same; personal only if guaranteed
2021 income tax and § 6663 penalty IRS levy, lien and refund offset Three or six years; no limit for fraud Tax often; penalty usually not
Criminal restitution, if charged DOJ, lien under 18 U.S.C. § 3613 20 years from judgment or release Yes, § 523(a)(13)

Frequently Asked Questions

Must I amend my return if PPP forgiveness is rescinded?

IR-2022-162 encouraged amended returns but did not require them. The amount depends on whether forgiveness was improper and what portion was affected.

Can the IRS impose a fraud penalty without a conviction?

Yes. The § 6663 penalty is civil and survives a declination. The IRS must prove fraud on the return by clear and convincing evidence.

Will a tip about my PPP loan trigger an IRS audit?

Not by itself. Directive 26-13 tells prosecutors to look for tax violations, and the SBA separately refers loan files to the IRS.

Can Treasury take my Social Security for an EIDL default?

If you are personally liable, yes, after notice. It takes the lesser of 15 percent of the monthly benefit or the amount above $750.

Does bankruptcy stop a federal fraud investigation?

No. Criminal proceedings are outside the automatic stay. Fraud debts and restitution may survive the discharge.

How North Star Law Firm Can Help

North Star Law Firm helps New Mexico owners whose pandemic loan files draw attention, through IRS audit defense, amended or unfiled returns, and Chapter 7 analysis of which debts would survive.

Phillip Zagotti, JD/CPA, represents taxpayers before the IRS and the U.S. Tax Court and is admitted to the U.S. District Court and Bankruptcy Court for the District of New Mexico. The firm works alongside New Mexico-licensed counsel on state-law questions. If an investigator has asked about your PPP or EIDL file, contact North Star Law Firm.